Matt Lewis, a commentator known for unraveling the complexities of historical events, is joined by Steve Tibble to reveal the shocking truth behind the Crusaders. They delve into how many individuals took advantage of the Holy War as a cover for committing heinous acts, often driven by chaos and dislocation. The discussion highlights the unique historical context of violence during the Crusades, where moral decay became normalized. They also touch on the intriguing parallels with modern-day issues of crime and governance.
The Crusades were marred by widespread criminality, with many taking advantage of the chaos to commit heinous acts against local populations.
Climate change and mass migration exacerbated the conditions for violence, revealing historical patterns that are alarmingly relevant to today's societal challenges.
Deep dives
The Criminal Underbelly of the Crusades
The Crusades, often perceived as noble religious missions, were riddled with crime committed by individuals who exploited the chaos of war. Historical accounts reveal that many who ventured to the Holy Land used the guise of holy war to engage in criminal activities, from theft to violence. For instance, records from the period indicate that expectation of criminality was so high that even mundane acts went noteworthy when no crime occurred. This perspective shifts the narrative from a simplistic view of moral righteousness to one that acknowledges the rampant lawlessness that characterized this era.
Societal Impact and Desensitization
The continuous state of warfare and criminal acts led to desensitization among crusaders and local populations alike. Soldiers returning home often brought with them a mindset shaped by violence and a breakdown of societal norms, leading to a normalization of criminal behavior. Evidence suggests that over generations, the local communities, initially victims of crime, adapted to this new reality by engaging in similar behaviors. Consequently, a complete transformation of society occurred, where once peaceful populations became embroiled in cycles of crime and violence.
The Role of Climate Change and Migration
Underlying factors like climate change and mass migration significantly contributed to the conditions that led to the Crusades and subsequent criminality. A drastic deterioration in climate disrupted traditional livelihoods in the region, pushing populations, including Turkic tribes, into conflict zones like the Middle East. This migration created an influx of armed young men devoid of familial structures or productive roles, serving as a recipe for violence and crime. Understanding these broader ecological drivers offers insights into how historical conflicts often intersect with environmental challenges.
Lessons from Crusader Criminality
The historical examination of criminality during the Crusades raises significant contemporary implications, particularly concerning how societies respond to crisis and migration. Modern parallels can be drawn to today's climate-induced migrations, suggesting that without strategic planning and compassion, societies may face similar unrest and violence. Governments are urged to address these issues proactively, recognizing that the same social dynamics observed a thousand years ago remain relevant. Such lessons underline the importance of addressing root causes of conflict rather than merely reacting to the symptoms of societal breakdown.
Please be aware that this episode mentions sexual violence
Amongst the countless crusaders who travelled to the Holy Land, there were undoubtedly some who believed they were doing the right thing for their God and King. Others though were gangsters, bandits and even worse, murderers and rapists, bringing horror and terror to the region. In fact, the real tensions stemmed not from religion but from young men - dislocated, disinhibited and present in disturbingly large numbers.
Matt Lewis finds out more about the shocking levels of criminality during the Crusades from Steve Tibble. They discuss those who used the cover of Holy War to commit a variety of crimes and how the clues are everywhere, even in the film Casablanca.
Gone Medieval is presented by Matt Lewis. The editor is Ella Blaxill, the producer is Rob Weinberg. The senior producer is Anne-Marie Luff.
Gone Medieval is a History Hit podcast.
Enjoy unlimited access to award-winning original TV documentaries that are released weekly and AD-FREE podcasts. Sign up HERE for 50% off your first 3 months using code ‘MEDIEVAL’: https://historyhit.com/subscription