Clare Jackson, a Senior Tutor at Trinity Hall, University of Cambridge, Micheál Ó Siochrú, a Modern History Professor at Trinity College Dublin, and Laura Stewart, an Early Modern History expert at the University of York, dive into the tumultuous Interregnum period. They discuss the radical political shifts following Charles I's execution and Cromwell's controversial invasion of Ireland. The complexities of Scotland's political allegiance to Charles II are examined, alongside Cromwell's legacy and the pivotal role of General Monk in restoring monarchy, shedding light on lasting impacts across Britain.
The execution of Charles I ushered in the Interregnum, creating a governance vacuum that led to a tumultuous political landscape in England.
Cromwell's military campaigns in Ireland, driven by vengeance, resulted in significant casualties and had lasting repercussions on Anglo-Irish relations.
The restoration of Charles II in 1660 reestablished monarchy but intensified existing divisions, particularly regarding land and power among Catholics and Protestants.
Deep dives
Regicide and Parliamentary Authority
The execution of Charles I in 1649 marked a significant turning point for England's governance, leading to the establishment of the Interregnum. Following the regicide, Parliament moved swiftly to abolish the monarchy and the House of Lords, yet there was no clear plan for governance, which left the country in a state of uncertainty. The situation was further complicated by Pride's Purge, where the New Model Army selectively removed moderates from Parliament, resulting in a radicalized assembly often perceived as illegitimate. This turbulent political landscape set the stage for conflicting power dynamics between Parliament and the military forces, particularly around the figure of Oliver Cromwell.
Cromwell's Invasion of Ireland
Following the regicide, Cromwell's leadership saw a decisive military campaign in Ireland, driven by motives of vengeance and control. The historical context included the massacre of English and Scottish Protestant settlers during the 1641 rebellion, which intensified the English Parliament's desire to reassert their dominance in the region. Significant battles, such as the stormings of Drogheda and Wexford, resulted in heavy casualties and left a legacy of devastation that resonated in both Ireland and abroad. The brutal tactics employed by Cromwell, aimed at quelling resistance quickly, further perpetuated a narrative of extermination among the Catholic Irish population.
Cromwell's Role in Scotland
During the English Civil War, Scotland operated under a regal union with England, but following the execution of Charles I, Cromwell's New Model Army sought to establish control. The Covenanters, key Scottish political figures, believed in maintaining Charles II's kingship but could not accept the execution of his father. Cromwell’s subsequent military actions in Scotland were motivated by a need to secure peace but resulted in tensions that would define future Anglo-Scottish relations. Ultimately, Charles II's restoration would complicate these dynamics further, as the English and Scots navigated the fraught legacy left by the Interregnum.
The Complexity of Cromwell's Legacy
Cromwell's rule is often remembered for its harsh military tactics, especially in Ireland, yet it also fostered a period of religious tolerance within England. The policies instituted under his regime included provisions for various nonconformist groups and allowed for some press freedoms, which had been stifled previously. Despite this, Cromwell maintained a personal and intricate relationship with religion, believing his actions were divinely ordained. However, his reluctance to embrace kingship, despite being offered the crown, reflects his complex views on governance amid an era characterized by revolutionary aspirations and the contradictory nature of his power.
The Aftermath of the Interregnum
The restoration of Charles II in 1660 signified a return to monarchy but also consolidated the divisions and turmoil of the Interregnum era, especially regarding land and power in Ireland. The Protestant settlers, who thrived during Cromwell's rule, feared a resurgence of the Catholic majority and thus influenced the terms of Charles’s return to power, demanding that the Cromwellian land settlement remain intact. Moreover, Scotland's acceptance of Charles II as king complicated its relationship with England, particularly as it had not embraced the radical changes seen in Ireland. This restoration period established a framework for future governance and highlighted the ongoing tensions stemming from the previous decade of upheaval.
Melvyn Bragg and guests discuss the period between the execution of Charles I in 1649 and the unexpected restoration of his son Charles II in 1660, known as The Interregnum. It was marked in England by an elusive pursuit of stability, with serious consequences in Scotland and notorious ones in Ireland. When Parliament executed Charles it had also killed Scotland and Ireland’s king, without their consent; Scotland immediately declared Charles II king of Britain, and Ireland too favoured Charles. In the interests of political and financial security, Parliament's forces, led by Oliver Cromwell, soon invaded Ireland and then turned to defeating Scotland. However, the improvised power structures in England did not last and Oliver Cromwell's death in 1658 was followed by the threat of anarchy. In England, Charles II had some success in overturning the changes of the 1650s but there were lasting consequences for Scotland and the notorious changes in Ireland were entrenched.
The Dutch image of Oliver Cromwell, above, was published by Joost Hartgers c1649
With
Clare Jackson
Senior Tutor at Trinity Hall, University of Cambridge
Micheál Ó Siochrú
Professor in Modern History at Trinity College Dublin
And
Laura Stewart
Professor in Early Modern History at the University of York
Producer: Simon Tillotson
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
