Sick of hearing us shouting about Bayesianism? Well today you're in luck, because this time, someone shouts at us about Bayesianism! Richard Meadows, finance journalist, author, and Ben's secretive podcast paramour, takes us to task. Are we being unfair to the Bayesians? Is Bayesian rationality optimal in theory, and the rest of us are just coping with an uncertain world? Is this why the Bayesian rationalists have so much cultural influence (and money, and fame, and media attention, and ...), and we, ahem, uhhh, don't?

Check out Rich's website, his book Optionality: How to Survive and Thrive in a Volatile World, and his podcast.

We discuss

• The pros of the rationality and EA communities
• Whether Bayesian epistemology contributes to open-mindedness
• The fact that evidence doesn't speak for itself
• The fact that the world doesn't come bundled as discrete chunks of evidence
• Whether Bayesian epistemology would be "optimal" for Laplace's demon
• The difference between truth and certainty
• Vaden's tone issues and why he gets animated about this subject.

References

• Scott's original piece: In continued defense of non-frequentist probabilities
• Scott Alexander's post about rootclaim
• Our previous episode on Scott's piece: #69 - Contra Scott Alexander on Probability
• Rootclaim
• Ben's blogpost You need a theory for that theory
• Cox's theorem
• Aumann's agreement theorem
• Vaden's blogposts mentioned in the episode:
  • Critical Rationalism and Bayesian Epistemology
  • Proving Too Much

Socials

• Follow us on Twitter at @IncrementsPod, @BennyChugg, @VadenMasrani
• Follow Rich at @MeadowsRichard
• Come join our discord server! DM us on twitter or send us an email to get a supersecret link
• Help us calibrate our credences and get exclusive bonus content by becoming a patreon subscriber here. Or give us one-time cash donations to help cover our lack of cash donations here.
• Click dem like buttons on youtube

What's your favorite theory that is neither true nor useful? Tell us over at incrementspodcast@gmail.com.

Special Guest: Richard Meadows.

Support Increments