Ep. 207 Free speech news: NetChoice, Taylor Swift, October 7, and Satan
Feb 29, 2024
auto_awesome
Join Alex Morey, Aaron Terr, and Ronnie London as they discuss a range of compelling topics on the podcast, from NetChoice oral arguments to Taylor Swift's cease and desist letter, doxxing incidents on college campuses, challenges with no-contact orders at Princeton University, and the legal implications of property destruction related to Satanic worship in public spaces. The conversation also touches on censorship issues in universities and debates surrounding viewpoint neutrality in public forums.
Princeton revised no contact order policy to prevent misuse against journalists.
Importance of fair policies in universities to protect journalistic freedom and prevent censorship.
Government interference in expressive activities raises concerns about religious freedom and viewpoint discrimination.
Deep dives
Princeton's Loophole: No Contact Orders for Journalists
Princeton University faced controversy over students misusing no contact orders towards journalists who covered protests. The policy allowed students to obtain no contact orders for any reason, leading to incidents where a journalist was blocked from covering events. Students were exploiting the vague policy to circumvent negative press coverage, resulting in unwarranted restrictions on journalists' ability to report.
No Contact Order Policy Amended: Changing Implementation Practices
After intervention from organizations like FIRE and the ADL, Princeton amended its no contact order policy. The policy had been misapplied, allowing students to use it as a tool to interfere with journalists. Princeton swiftly changed the policy after criticism, recognizing the need for due process and fair implementation to prevent misuse.
Impact on Student Journalism: Upholding Press Freedom
The misuse of no contact orders at Princeton had serious implications for student journalists' ability to cover events and report news. By restricting communication with sources and subjects, the policy hindered journalistic freedom and raised concerns about censorship and intimidation in campus reporting.
Lessons Learned: Ensuring Proper Application of University Policies
The incidents at Princeton underscore the importance of clear and fair policies regarding no contact orders. Universities need to ensure that such measures are not exploited to stifle journalistic activities and undermine press freedom. By addressing loopholes and implementing safeguards, institutions can protect the rights of student journalists and promote transparency in reporting.
Challenges of Free Speech on Campus
The podcast episode discusses instances where free speech on university campuses faced challenges. It highlights a case where a university police department issued a no-contact order against a parent for discussing their daughter's grade with a faculty member. Additionally, it delves into the denial of official recognition to a student group at Columbia Law School due to objections regarding its definition of anti-Semitism.
Government Interference in Expressive Activities
The episode explores government interference in expressive activities, focusing on a case involving the destruction of a display by the Satanic Temple of Iowa in the Iowa State Capitol. It details the introduction of a bill to ban Satanic worship on public property and prohibit the recognition of Satanism as a religion. The discussion touches on the implications of viewpoint discrimination and the protection of religious groups' rights to express their beliefs in public forums.
On today’s free speech news roundup, we discuss the recent NetChoice oral argument, Taylor Swift, doxxing, October 7 fallout on campus, and Satan in Iowa.
Joining us on the show are Alex Morey, FIRE director of Campus Rights Advocacy; Aaron Terr, director of Public Advocacy; and Ronnie London, our general counsel.
Timestamps
0:00 Introduction
0:44 NetChoice oral arguments
19:39 Taylor Swift cease and desist letter
29:20 Publishing unlawfully obtained information
39:28 Harvard and doxxing
47:44 Princeton no contact orders
55:52 Columbia law denies recognition to Law Students Against Antisemitism
1:02:38 Columbia adopts Kalven Report
1:06:06 Indiana University art exhibit canceled, professor suspended