In this intriguing discussion, guest Makena Kelly, a senior writer at WIRED focusing on politics and technology, delves into Elon Musk's ambitious government initiatives. She addresses the anxieties of federal employees under Musk's Doge program, exploring potential job security threats amidst efficiency drives. The conversation highlights the legal and political murkiness surrounding Musk's actions and their implications for democratic accountability. Kelly raises concerns on the growing influence of wealth in U.S. agencies, questioning the balance between private interests and public service.
Elon Musk's Department of Government Efficiency is dramatically reshaping the GSA to become an AI-first organization, causing anxiety among employees about job security.
Concerns about legality and ethics have arisen as Musk's influence grants access to sensitive federal data, potentially leading to a constitutional crisis.
Deep dives
Transformation of the General Services Administration (GSA)
The GSA is undergoing a significant transformation under the guidance of Thomas Shedd, who has set a vision to turn the agency into an AI-first organization akin to a Silicon Valley tech firm. This change is initiated by the influence of Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency, which seeks to streamline federal agencies and reduce personnel. GSA employees expressed concerns during a meeting, questioning the implications of these changes for their positions and job security, especially as some were offered incentives to resign. The uncertainty surrounding their employment status has created an atmosphere of anxiety, hindering their ability to focus on their core missions.
Concerns Over Legal and Ethical Implications
Musk's team has gained unprecedented access to various federal departments, raising serious questions about legality and ethics regarding their actions. Reports indicate that Doge employees now control access to sensitive financial data, with concerns about potential conflicts of interest given Musk's extensive federal contracts. Lawmakers and legal experts highlight this as a potential constitutional crisis, as the operational scope of Doge appears to exceed the original executive order’s intent. Despite protests and calls for accountability, the response from federal officials has been tepid, raising fears that significant legal repercussions may only arise long after the damage is done.
Impact on Federal Workforce and Culture
The influx of young, less experienced engineers from Musk's network into roles traditionally held by seasoned federal employees has led to significant disruptions within the GSA and other agencies. Many veteran civil servants feel perturbed by the sudden presence of these individuals, often unsure of their motives or authority within the existing framework. As these young recruits begin assessing and directing federal projects, entrenched staff experience confusion, frustration, and a sense of disempowerment. This dynamic shift not only threatens established processes but also poses risks to the job security and morale of the federal workforce.
Want more What Next TBD? Subscribe to Slate Plus to access ad-free listening to the whole What Next family and all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Evan Campbell and Patrick Fort.