This podcast explores the discipline of judgment in Stoicism, discussing the importance of reasoning well, making accurate judgments, and withholding judgment when uncertain. It also delves into developing clear thinking with stoic checklists and the challenges of applying the discipline of ascent. The hosts emphasize the gradual development of virtue and the importance of building virtue over time.
The discipline of assent is crucial in stoicism to form accurate judgments and make good decisions.
Practicing the discipline of assent involves exercises such as decomposition and suspending judgment.
Challenges in the discipline of assent include dealing with conflicting beliefs, recognizing ignorance, and working with others who do not accept objective truths.
Deep dives
The Importance of the Discipline of Ascent
The discipline of ascent is a crucial aspect of stoicism, allowing individuals to form accurate judgments and make good decisions. It involves seeing things as they are without adding unnecessary value judgments. Ascent is influenced by our beliefs and evidence, and constantly refining our beliefs through continuous learning and seeking evidence is essential. The discipline of ascent is diachronic, meaning it is gained and maintained over time. It is not just about individual actions, but also about character development and building virtuous habits.
Training the Discipline of Ascent
Practicing the discipline of ascent involves various exercises. One important exercise is the decomposition exercise, which involves describing things objectively and seeing them as they truly are. Another exercise is suspending judgment, giving yourself time to think and reflect before forming beliefs. This involves actively introducing counterarguments and considering stoic thoughts or values. Additionally, building a consistent standard of judgment and stacking the odds in your favor by having better propositions or beliefs can aid in refining the discipline of ascent.
Challenges in the Discipline of Ascent
Challenges in the discipline of ascent include dealing with conflicting beliefs and propositions, ensuring a diachronic perspective by considering patterns over time, and working with people who are not willing to accept objective truths. It can be difficult to communicate with those who are not playing the game of accepting what is better than what is worse. Additionally, recognizing and overcoming our own moments of ignorance or bad faith can present challenges in practicing the discipline of ascent.
Importance of External Discourse and Good Faith
Apart from internalizing the discipline of ascent, it is important to consider external discourse and how it aligns with our beliefs and values. Communicating with others in good faith, sharing true beliefs, and representing the world as accurately as possible are also crucial aspects of honing the discipline of ascent.
Continuing the Practice of the Discipline of Ascent
The discipline of ascent is not a one-time practice, but an ongoing effort to refine our judgments and beliefs. It requires consistent effort and a willingness to challenge and improve our understanding of the world. By practicing the discipline of ascent, individuals can develop more accurate judgments and make better decisions in alignment with their stoic values.