John McWhorter, a prominent linguist and commentator, tackles misconceptions about identity and authenticity in politics. He discusses the complex idea of 'sellouts' within the Black community, emphasizing that differing beliefs don't equate to disloyalty. The conversation includes critiques of public figures like Clarence Thomas and explores loyalty's shifting nature. McWhorter enriches the dialogue with personal anecdotes about parenthood and the importance of self-critique, blending cultural narratives with the pressures of societal expectations.
John McWhorter clarifies misconceptions about his academic work, emphasizing his broader focus on language change rather than just Black English.
Glenn Lowry and John McWhorter discuss JD Vance's political shift, highlighting issues of authenticity and the pressures faced by public intellectuals.
The speakers examine the term 'sellout' among Black commentators, arguing it often misrepresents individual beliefs and societal expectations.
Deep dives
Clarifying Academic Focus
The speakers address misconceptions about their academic work and public perception, particularly related to John McWhorter's expertise. McWhorter emphasizes that while he is often associated with the study of Black English and sociolects, his primary focus lies in language change and contact across various languages globally. He asserts that his scholarly contributions extend far beyond the narrow categorizations found in his Wikipedia entry, asserting his broader interest in how languages evolve over time. This clarification is particularly important for both the speakers and their audience to understand their comprehensive academic endeavors.
Reflections on JD Vance's Journey
Glenn Lowry and John McWhorter discuss JD Vance's evolution from author of 'Hillbilly Elegy' to a prominent right-wing politician, expressing disappointment in his shift towards conservative populism. They compare this trajectory to their own, noting that while both started with critical examinations of culture within their communities, Vance seems to have aligned himself with more extreme right-wing views. Lowry reflects on the challenges he faced for his nuanced perspectives, contrasting them with Vance's current embrace of sensationalism. This raises questions about authenticity, integrity, and the complexities of navigating public intellectualism in today’s polarized political landscape.
The Concept of Sellouts
The speakers delve into the contentious notion of 'sellouts' among Black intellectuals and commentators, dissecting its implications and accuracy. Lowry notes that he has never personally encountered a Black commentator who knowingly compromises their beliefs for financial gain, emphasizing that most individuals they refer to as sellouts genuinely hold their beliefs. The conversation also explores societal expectations around racial representation and the unfair labeling of those who deviate from the perceived norms. They propose that the term 'sellout' itself often reflects a deeper misunderstanding of individual intellect and agency.
Parenthood and Personal Reflections
The discussion turns to parenting, with both speakers sharing contrasting views on the responsibilities and rewards of raising children. Lowry expresses pride in his experiences as a father while contemplating the societal implications of parenting choices, referencing JD Vance's encouragement for families to have children. McWhorter counters, sharing a perspective shaped by his own upbringing that leads him to question whether everyone should be inclined to raise children. Their dialogue highlights the complexity of parental roles and societal expectations surrounding family dynamics.
Maintaining Personal Integrity in Public Discourse
Lowry and McWhorter reflect on the pressures of public life and the importance of maintaining personal integrity while engaging in socio-political discourse. They acknowledge how public figures often negotiate their beliefs against societal expectations, hinting at the challenges faced when one's views diverge from broader narratives. Both express a commitment to articulate their perspectives honestly, despite the potential backlash that may arise. This commitment underscores the value they place on representing their ideologies authentically, even within a contentious cultural landscape.
Order Glenn's memoir, LATE ADMISSIONS: CONFESSIONS OF A BLACK CONSERVATIVE. Available here or wherever you get your books: https://wwnorton.com/books/9780393881349
1:28 John corrects some Wikipedia-driven misconceptions about his work
This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit glennloury.substack.com/subscribe
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode