In this intriguing discussion, philosopher L.A. Paul from Yale University dives into how transformative experiences shape our identities. She addresses how pivotal moments, like those in the lives of John Newton and Malcolm X, redefine personal values and perspectives. Paul challenges listeners to reflect on their own life-altering decisions and the gap between who we are and who we might become. The conversation also explores the complexities of advanced directives in medicine, emphasizing the need for adaptability as circumstances change.
Decisions are complicated by our failure to recognize that our future selves may have drastically different values and feelings.
Life-altering experiences can profoundly reshape identity, challenging the perception of a stable self and altering fundamental worldviews.
Deep dives
The Complexity of Decision-Making
When faced with decisions, individuals often focus heavily on potential outcomes, trying to predict how these choices will influence their happiness. People create lists of pros and cons and seek advice from friends in their quest for the best choice. However, a critical aspect frequently overlooked is that our future selves may hold different values and feelings than we do at present. This disconnect complicates the decision-making process, as the person we imagine will exist after the choice may not align with our current self.
Transformative Experiences and Identity
Philosopher L.A. Paul highlights how certain life experiences fundamentally reshape our identities, referencing figures like John Newton and Malcolm X. Both men underwent critical transformations that dramatically altered their worldviews and core beliefs. For instance, Newton’s shift from a life immersed in the slave trade to one of religious devotion illustrates how profound experiences can lead to moral awakenings. These transformations challenge the notion of a stable self, showing that who we might become can be vastly different from who we are today.
The Limitations of Simulation in Decision-Making
In making future life choices, individuals often employ simulation to envision how they might feel about different options. However, this predictive approach can fail when the choices involve drastic life changes leading to a shift in identity. The metaphor of Mary, who lives in a black-and-white world and struggles to imagine color, exemplifies the limitations of our capacity to simulate future experiences accurately. This highlights the difficulty of assessing future happiness based on experiences that are beyond current comprehension.
Challenges of Advanced Directives
The concept of advanced directives in medical contexts reflects the tensions surrounding understanding future selves. These directives are crafted based on current values and preferences, aiming to guide decisions when individuals can no longer advocate for themselves. However, as people undergo cognitive decline or other transformations, they may lose sight of their former commitments, rendering those directives potentially irrelevant. This raises questions about the appropriateness of making decisions today for a self that may very well be a stranger in the future.
Often in life, we find ourselves wrestling with a decision. But in running these mental calculations, there's something we rarely consider about the future: we might not be the same person when we get there. This week, philosopher L.A. Paul explores how life-altering events reshape who we are.
Want more of our work on understanding your future self? Give these Hidden Brain episodes a listen:
And for the latest insights about human behavior, delivered straight to your inbox, sign up for the weekly Hidden Brain newsletter! Each issue brings you the latest research, along with a brain teaser and a moment of joy. You can read and subscribe here: https://news.hiddenbrain.org/
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode