A haunted house in New York becomes the center of a legal case known as the Ghostbusters ruling. Spooky encounters, the impact on property value, and the settlement between buyers and sellers are discussed, along with the psychological stigma on real estate.
The Ghostbusters ruling established that sellers have a duty to disclose known stigmas or risks associated with a property, even if they are paranormal.
Psychological stigmas, such as a property being haunted, can impact its market value, emphasizing the importance of considering the emotional and psychological aspects in real estate.
Deep dives
The Haunted House on the Hudson
A house in Nyack, New York, known as one Levetta place, gained notoriety for being haunted. Helen Ackley, the mother of Cynthia Kavanaugh, lived in the house and shared stories of her encounters with ghosts. The house was sold to a young couple, the Stambovskis, who later learned about its haunted reputation. They filed a lawsuit to rescind their purchase, arguing that the ghosts affected the property's value. The case became known as the Ghostbusters ruling, as the court ruled that the house was haunted as a matter of law, due to Helen Ackley's promotion of its paranormal activity. The ruling established that sellers have a duty to disclose known stigmas or risks associated with a property, even if they are paranormal.
The Impact of Stigma on Property Value
The Stambovski case set a precedent for cases involving stigmatized properties. Randall Bell, a specialist in real estate damage economics, explains that psychological stigmas, such as a property being haunted, can impact its market value. Disclosure laws vary by state, with some requiring sellers to disclose deaths or other events that may create a stigma. In some cases, properties with paranormal activity may even attract buyers and increase in value. Perception plays a significant role in real estate, and the Stambovski case highlighted the importance of considering the emotional and psychological aspects that can affect a property's value.
Legacy and Reflections
After settling the case, the Stambovskis were released from their contract to purchase the haunted house. The property has changed ownership several times since then, and no residents have reported any paranormal encounters. Helen Ackley, the original owner, moved to Florida but expressed her hope of returning to the house after passing away. Cynthia Kavanaugh, her daughter, reflects on the memories and comforts associated with the house, even missing the presence of ghosts at times. The enduring ghostly reputation of one Levetta place serves as a reminder of the complex interplay between belief, stigma, and property value.
In 1989, Helen Ackley decided to sell her old Victorian house in Nyack, New York. It didn’t go as planned. The house became the center of a case that’s referred to as “The Ghostbusters ruling.”
Criminal is going back on tour in February! We’ll be telling brand new stories, live on stage. You can even get meet and greet tickets to come and say hi before the show. Tickets are on sale now at thisiscriminal.com/live. We can’t wait to see you there!
Sign up for Criminal Plus to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, members-only merch, and more. Learn more and sign up here.