Khaled El-Gindi, a Senior Fellow at the Middle East Institute, joins experts including Sarah Yael Hirshhorn, who explores the American Jewish role in Israeli settlements, and Avi Shlaim, an Israeli-British historian discussing historical tensions. They delve into the evolution of settlements, their socio-economic impacts, and the motivations behind them, highlighting key figures like Ariel Sharon. The discussion also touches on the recent surge in settlement activities and its broader implications for the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, revealing deep-rooted complexities.
The evolution of Israeli settlements from a small religious initiative to a dominant political force reflects changing socio-economic motivations among settlers.
Increased settler violence and the structural segregation created by infrastructure exacerbate the already tense Israeli-Palestinian conflict and hinder coexistence.
Deep dives
The Nature of Highway 443
Highway 443 running from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem provides a clear representation of the Israeli-Palestinian divide. The road is bordered by walls and barriers that separate it from Palestinian territories, showcasing how infrastructure can contribute to segregation. Israeli citizens, particularly settlers, can use this highway freely, while most Palestinian residents face heavy restrictions, often requiring permits to access segments of it. This disparity highlights a broader reality where the Israeli experience in the West Bank is designed to minimize contact with Palestinians, while Palestinian society suffers from the disruption caused by such infrastructure.
The Growth of Settlements
Israeli settlements in the West Bank are more than just military outposts; they resemble suburban communities with schools, shopping centers, and well-maintained infrastructure. Many of the 700,000 settlers live in these areas for economic reasons, seeking a quality of life that is promoted through government subsidies, rather than for ideological or religious motives. Despite some settlers identifying as religious Zionists, the majority are attracted by the suburban lifestyle available in these settlements. This shift highlights how settlement expansion is intertwined with the socio-economic aspirations of Israel's residents, often at the direct expense of Palestinian communities.
The Historical Context of Settler Politics
The settler movement began as a religious mission but has evolved into a significant political force, particularly with the rise of leaders like Ariel Sharon and the Likud party. The movement gained momentum in the aftermath of the 1967 Six-Day War, when Israel occupied the West Bank and allowed settlement expansion as a strategic and ideological choice. Early settlement ideology was rooted in security concerns, but it shifted towards a more assertive claim of sovereignty over the land. The increased political power of settlers within the current government reflects a commitment to maintaining these settlements, even amid growing international criticism.
Continued Violence and the Reality for Palestinians
The violence accompanying the settlement expansion has escalated, particularly in the wake of significant incidents such as the shooting of Palestinians and settler attacks on villages. The situation is precarious for many Palestinian residents, who contend with military checkpoints, violence, and a legal framework that typically favors settlers. The Israeli government's support for settlements has created a climate where extremist actions by settlers can often go unpunished, further straining Israeli-Palestinian relations. As the settlements grow and the Palestinian presence declines, the narrative around rights and land ownership becomes increasingly complex and contentious.
The question of settlements has loomed over the Israeli-Palestinian conflict for decades, and has only intensified in the past year. According to a UN report, since October 7, 2023, there has been a record surge in settlement activities and increased settler violence against Palestinians. Today on the show: how the settlement movement grew from a small religious mission to one of the central tenets of the current Israeli government. It's a story that intersects with other topics we've covered in our series relating to this conflict – the history of Hamas, the rise of the Israeli right wing, Hezbollah, and Zionism.
To access bonus episodes and listen to Throughline sponsor-free, subscribe to Throughline+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org/throughline.