Best of the Spectator Holy Smoke: the mystifying process – and problems – behind choosing the next Archbishop of Canterbury
May 27, 2025
Andrew Graystone, a journalist and theologian known for his insights into church affairs, joins features editor William Moore to unpack the convoluted selection process for the next Archbishop of Canterbury. They discuss why the vacancy has persisted for over six months, touching on intermittent scandals and the role of the Crown Nominations Commission. Their conversation reveals the intricate dynamics at play, including potential candidates, LGBTQ+ considerations, and the influence of the monarchy, making it a riveting tale of church politics.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Opaque Appointment Process
- The Crown Nominations Commission (CNC) has 20 members, but only 17 vote on the Archbishop of Canterbury appointment. - Complex elections and resignations, including a former MI5 head chairing it, delay progress and add intrigue.
Small Minority Can Block Appointment
- The CNC requires a two-thirds majority to appoint the Archbishop, meaning 6 of 17 members can block a candidate. - This allows minority factions to stall the appointment indefinitely, especially on contentious issues like gender or LGBT inclusion.
Mystery Over Anglican Representatives
- The process to select the Anglican Communion representatives on the CNC is unclear and secretive. - Although there are regional and gender quotas, transparency in appointments remains lacking.
