Christian Nationalism Ain't Christian: With Andrew Whitehead
Oct 30, 2023
auto_awesome
"Data Over Dogma" welcomes Dr. Andrew Whitehead, Associate Professor of Sociology at IUPUI and author of "American Idolatry". They discuss the rise of racist power-seekers in American Christianity and if Bible verses support their arguments. The podcast explores the impact of Christian nationalism on society, including perceptions of America, immigration, and democratic processes. They also expose the generic language used by Christian nationalists to hide racism and discuss countering its influence on democracy.
Christian nationalism promotes exclusionary beliefs and undermines diversity in a pluralistic society.
Christian nationalism is a global phenomenon, intertwining religion and politics to maintain dominance.
Christian nationalism prioritizes gaining and maintaining power, even if it means disregarding moral principles and perpetuating an us-versus-them mentality.
Deep dives
Christian Nationalism and the Quest for Power
Christian nationalism is a political and religious ideology that seeks to elevate a particular expression of Christianity as the privileged religion in public life. It aims to preserve and protect this framework as the basis for organizing the United States. This ideology is associated with a desire for strict moral hierarchies, with preferences for gender and sexuality playing a central role. It also promotes rigid ethno-racial boundaries, viewing the nation as built and made for white Christians. Christian nationalism is comfortable with authoritarian social control and often portrays a sense of victimization and persecution. This ideology leads to conspiratorial thinking and resistance to pluralistic, democratic values. It is not unique to Christianity or the United States, but similar ideologies can be found in other religious and national contexts.
The Impact of Christian Nationalism on Society
Christian nationalism has significant consequences for society. It is associated with a fear of losing access to power and privilege, often pushing for policies that marginalize and oppress certain groups. It undermines the principles of a pluralistic and democratic society, hindering the flourishing of diverse individuals and communities. Christian nationalism promotes specific visions of morality and social order, rooted in subjective interpretations of religious texts. While its adherents may appeal to verses like Romans 13-1 to justify their actions, it is important to understand that such passages are historically contingent and cannot be universally applied. It is essential for individuals to critically examine the cultural baggage and biases inherent in their religious beliefs and engage in open dialogue to promote greater inclusivity and social justice.
Christian Nationalism as a Global Phenomenon
Christian nationalism is not limited to the United States or any specific religion. Similar ideologies exist worldwide, intertwining religious and political power in an effort to maintain dominance. Just as American Christian nationalism emerged as a response to cultural shifts in the 60s and 70s, other nations and religious groups have experienced similar reactions to societal changes. The rhetoric and mechanisms of Christian nationalism resonate with those seeking power, serving as a tool to mobilize individuals on a cultural and political level. It is vital to recognize the inherent dangers in privileging one specific religious expression or ethnicity over others and to challenge and confront ideologies that perpetuate exclusion and division.
Power and Access in Christian Nationalism
Christian nationalism is about gaining and maintaining power and access to privileged political power within the culture. This was evident in the embrace of Donald Trump, who didn't align with Christian piety or morality, but promised power to the Christian nationalist group. This shift in priorities was highlighted by the flip in white evangelicals' views on the importance of moral leadership. Trump's ascent revealed that Christian nationalism is focused on securing power to shape the world in accordance with their interpretation of the Bible, even if it means denying access and power to others. This poses a threat to democracy and perpetuates an us-versus-them mentality.
Negotiating the Bible in Christian Nationalism
Christian nationalists selectively use and interpret Bible verses to support their ideology. One frequently cited verse is 2 Chronicles 7:14, which talks about humbling oneself, prayer, seeking God's face, and turning from wicked ways to receive forgiveness and healing for the land. However, contextualizing the verse within the post-exilic period reveals its original meaning related to droughts and punishment. Andrew Whitehead, a biblical scholar, emphasizes that biblical texts have no inherent meaning and are subject to negotiation. He highlights the need to disentangle Christianity from Christian nationalism and engage in deeper discussions about the diverse interpretations and expressions of Christianity.
This week Data Over Dogma gets political as we welcome Dr. Andrew Whitehead. Dr. Whitehead is an Associate Professor of Sociology at IUPUI, director of the Association of Religion Data Archives, and author of the incredibly timely book American Idolatry: How Christian Nationalism Betrays the Gospel and Threatens the Church.
As a sociologist, Whitehead is bringing receipts as he discusses the current rise of racist, xenophobic power-seekers within American Christianity, and why that rise is... you know... bad. Bad for the country and democracy, but also very possibly bad for Christianity.
We'll also discuss some of the Bible verses that have been used by Christian Nationalists, and figure out if those verses actually support the arguments they're making.
For more Andrew:
https://andrewwhitehead.substack.com
Also look out for the American Idols podcast series.
For an ad-free version of the show, exclusive content, and an opportunity to support our work, please consider becoming a monthly patron at: