Who Benefits from Rigid vs Flexible Plans

Most retirees want to spend as much as they can without having to worry about running out of money. Morningstar’s State of Retirement Income research analyzes retirement spending strategies to determine the highest safe starting withdrawal rate for new retirees in 2026. Christine Benz, Morningstar’s director of personal finance and retirement planning and co-host of The Long View podcast, breaks down the research and shares some ideas about how you can boost your retirement spending.

What’s a Safe Retirement Withdrawal Rate for 2026?

On this episode:

00:00:00 Welcome

00:00:46 Each year, you and your colleagues producethis really comprehensive research about retirement income. And as part of that research, you try toidentify what a safe withdrawal rate will be for the year ahead. 

00:01:59 What is that safe withdrawal percentage, and how did you arrive at that conclusion?

00:02:41 The 4% rule often comes up in the conversation around retirement spending. How does that compare to your base case?

00:03:30 I know there are some misperceptions about your retirement income research and what that safe withdrawal percentage means. What are they? 

00:03:28 So, how should retirees use this research?

00:04:51 The safe starting withdrawal rate that you found in your base case might feel a little low for some retirees. Are there other strategies that retirees can use to boost their spending?

00:07:02 So, flexible strategies are best suited for retirees that are focused on maximizing their spending. 

00:08:52 What kind of retiree would benefit from a more rigid strategy, like the fixed inflation-adjusted spending approach that you use in your base case?

00:09:26 How does asset allocation come into play? Would a stock-heavy portfolio support a higher withdrawal rate in retirement?

00:10:36 So far, we’ve focused on portfolio income strategies, but you also looked at nonportfolio income sources like annuities and Social Security. What did you find?

00:13:34 It seems like there’s some more nuance to the suggestion of delaying Social Security. Can you talk about that? 

00:14:50 How about annuities? Can you discuss some of the key considerations that income-centric retirees should bear in mind?

00:16:07 Studies have found that retirees don’t actually spend the same amount over the course of their retirement. What does actual retirement spending tend to look like, and how might that affect a retiree’s plans?

00:17:59Let’s talk about some scenarios that can throw off a retiree’s plan. One might be a market downturn early in retirement. What kind of impact could that have on spending? 

00:18:56 Another scenario might be retiring earlier than expected. What kind of implications would that have for safe withdrawals?

00:20:26 What is one final takeaway from the research that you want retirees to come away with?

Watch more from Morningstar:
How ETFs Help You Cut Your Tax Bill

Tax-Loss Harvesting Isn’t Just for Downturns. Here’s Why

Bond ETFs Are Surging in Popularity in 2025. Here Are 5 of the Best

Follow Morningstar on social:

Facebook https://www.facebook.com/MorningstarInc/

X https://x.com/MorningstarInc

Instagram https://www.instagram.com/morningstarinc/?hl=en

LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/company/morningstar/posts/?feedView=all

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.