Exploring Perceptions of Finite Resources and competing Interests in AI Ethics

The perception of finite resources such as money or attention in AI ethics leads to concerns about the totalizing view on existential risks. While some believe that reducing existential risk is paramount, others emphasize the value of a pluralistic society with openness and competition. This dilemma often pits security benefits against societal values, creating conflicts within the AI ethics community. The challenge lies in balancing the interests of reducing risks and fostering an open scientific ecosystem. The X-risk community, although making significant contributions, can sometimes overlook alternative frameworks due to lack of diversity in its representation. Ultimately, resolving conflicts between different AI ethics perspectives is crucial for promoting collective interests and expanding solutions beyond pie splitting.