The popularity of private detective fiction contributes to the prevailing view of law enforcement as incompetent.
Law enforcement relies on talented outsiders, like Sherlock Holmes, to catch bad guys.
Inspector Lester of Scotland Yard is honest and hardworking but lacks imagination.
Scotland Yard acknowledges that Sherlock Holmes is better at crime-solving than they are.
The pipe-smoking detective from Baker Street is crucial in keeping London's criminals under control.
Today, another episode from the Revisionist History Live universe. It's an old fashioned lecture, recorded at the New Orleans Book Festival at Tulane University. Malcolm talks about a totally real thing he made up—a taxonomy of the modern mystery story—with a focus on murder mysteries and police procedurals. From Dragnet, to John Grisham, to Sherlock Holmes, it's all in there...and all connected to how we view real policing.