Assess a city's success by how quickly it integrates migrants into its economy.
Integration Timeframe: A key indicator of a city's effectiveness is the time it takes for migrants, especially those with initially limited skills, to become fully integrated and economically productive.
Varied Integration Rates: Integration times vary drastically across cities. Some cities see full integration within a couple of years (e.g., Hong Kong in the 60s/70s), while others may take two to three generations.
Lengthy Adaptation: Until migrants adapt, they don't fully benefit from the city's advantages and may face rejection or discrimination.
Economic Citizenship: The ultimate goal is for migrants to achieve full economic citizenship, contributing and participating fully in the city's economy.
Alain Bertaud is an urbanist and a senior research scholar at the NYU Marron Institute of Urban Management. He is the author of a book about urban planning that is titled Order Without Design: How Markets Shape Cities. He has worked as an urban planner in a multitude of cities around the world.
Today, we talk about his view of a city and what he’s observed as an urban planner. He gives us examples and draws connections between how culture and regulation shape cities --- he means literally; cities shaped by regulation are shaped like donuts. We discuss the problems with central planning from old Soviet cities to today's urban sprawl caused by zoning regulation. He explains how being a "free market urban planner" is not a contradiction and shares personal stories about how he came to this career.