Moving Beyond Syntax: Lessons from 20 Years of Blocks Programming in AgentSheets by Alexander Repenning
Future of Coding
Challenging Accessibility Fuels Engagement
Children are often motivated by challenges and hard tasks, rather than merely seeking instant gratification. The true essence of engagement lies in balancing accessibility with difficulty, suggesting that presenting challenges can foster a deeper connection and interest among kids. Clarity in messaging is essential; defining accessibility and challenge as opposing forces enhances understanding and encourages a richer experience.
Alexander Repenning created AgentSheets, an environment to help kids develop computational thinking skills. It wrapped an unusual computational model with an even more unusual user interface. The result was divisive. It inspired so many other projects, whilst being rejected at every turn and failing to catch on the way Scratch later did. So in 2017, Repenning published this obit of a paper, Moving Beyond Syntax: Lessons from 20 Years of Blocks Programming in AgentSheets, which covers his findings over the years as AgentSheets evolved and transformed, and gives perspective on block-based programming, programming-by-example, agents / rule / rewrite systems, automata, and more.
This is probably the most "normal" episode we've done in a while — we stay close to the text and un-clam many a thought-tickling pearl. I'm saying that sincerely now to throw you off our scent the next time we get totally lost in the weeds. I hear a clock ticking.
Links
$ Do you want to move beyond syntax? Frustrated by a lack of syntactic, semantic, or pragmatic support? Join our Patreon! Choose the tier that best reflects your personal vision of the future of coding. Get (frequently unhinged) monthly bonus content. Most of all: let us know that you enjoy this thing we do, and help us keep doing it for years to come.
- Argos, for our non-UK listeners. They were acquired by future TodePond sponsor, Sainsbury's.
- Once again, I am asking for your Marcel Goethals makes a lot of cool weird stuff and is a choice follow.
- Scratch isn't baby programming. Also, you should try this bizarre game Ivan programmed in 3 blocks of Scratch.
- Sandspiel Studio is a delightful block-based sand programming simulator automata environment. Here's a video of Lu and Max introducing it.
- Simple Made Easy, a seminal talk by Rich Hickey. Still hits, all these years later.
- Someday we'll do an episode on speech acts.
- Rewrite rules are one example of rewriting in computing.
- Lu's talk —and I quote— "at Cellpond", was actually at SPLASH, about Cellpond, and it's a good talk, about —and I quote— "actually, what if they didn't give up on rewrite rules at this point in history and what if they went further?"
- Oh yeah — Cellpond is cool. Here's a video showing you how it works. And here's a video studying how that video works. And here's a secret third thingthat bends into a half-dimension.
- Here's Repenning's "rule-bending" paper: Bending the Rules: Steps Toward Semantically Enriched Graphical Rewrite Rules
- I don't need to link to SimCity, right? You all know SimCity? Will Wright is, arguably, the #1 name in simulation games. Well, you might not have caught the fantastic article Model Metropolis that unpacks the (inadvertently?) libertarian ideology embodied within the design of its systems. I'd also be remiss not to link to Polygon's video (and the corresponding write-up), which lend a little more colour to the history.
- Couldn't find a good link to Blox Pascal, which appears in the paper Towards "Second Generation" Interactive, Graphical Programming Environments by Ephraim P. Glinert, which I also couldn't find a good link to.
- Projectional / Structural Editor. Here's a good one.
- Baba is You
- Vernacular Programmers
- Filling Typed Holes with Live GUIs is, AFAIK, the most current canonical reference for livelits.
- I'm not linking to Minecraft. But I will link to the Repeater
- 32 Checkboxes
- Wiremod is a… you know what, just watch this.
- Chomsky Hierarchy
- The Witness
- Ivan wrote a colorful Mastodon thread surveying the history of the Connection Machine.
- Harder Drive is a must-watch video by the inimitable Tom7.
- Also couldn't find a good link for TORTIS. :/
- Programming by Example (PbE)
- Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo
- Alex Warth, one of the most lovely humans Ivan knows, is a real champion of "this, because that".
- Ivan's magnetic field simulations — Magnets! How do they work?
- Amit Patel's Red Blob Games, fantastic (fantastic!) explorable explanations that help you study various algorithms and techniques used in game development.
- Collaborative diffusion — "This article has multiple issues."
- Shaun Lebron, who you might know as the creator of Parinfer, made a game that interactively teaches you how the ghost AI works in Pac-Man. It's fun!
- Maxwell's Equations — specifically Gauss's law, which states that magnetic fields are solenoidal, meaning they have zero divergence at all points.
- University of Colorado Boulder has a collection of simulations called PhET. They're… mid, at least when compared to building your own simulation. For instance.
Music featured in this episode:
! Send us email, share your ideas in the Slack, and catch us at these normal places:
See you in the future!
https://futureofcoding.org/episodes/073
Support us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/futureofcoding
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
