Adopting a hardline stance on immigration as a strategic move can backfire politically. The attempt to appeal to Republicans by taking on their border agenda disconnects from the potential of achieving comprehensive immigration reform and citizenship paths. Polling shows that support for higher immigration is declining, contrasting with the previous era under Trump, suggesting that embracing Republican framing can lead to diminished popularity among voters. This phenomenon is not unique to the U.S.; similar political moves in Europe by center-left parties during migration surges led to their near extinction. The narrative indicates that trying to appear tough on immigration without aligning with the humane aspects can alienate rather than attract supporters.