
Recovering Fundamentalist Podcast
Join the conversation as three pastors who are recovering fundamentalists talk about life, ministry, and their journeys.
Latest episodes

Apr 21, 2025 • 40min
Episode #189 - "Church planting & pastoring in a post-pandemic era"
In this episode Host JC Groves welcomes Joey Presutti — a church planter and pastor who’s helping reshape the way we think about starting new churches in a post-COVID world.
As two new church planters ( Joey @ the Gather Church - 4 months old. Me @ Hope Church - 2 years old) we talk about the new challenges, the unexpected opportunities, and what’s still worth fighting for as we move forward.
If you’re thinking about planting a church, leading one, or just wondering how to engage this cultural moment post-pandemic — this episode is for you.
Hope Church Resedency: JC@hopechurchcatoosa.com
HopeChurchCatoosa.com
Sponsors Mission.edu
barzonDESIGN.com
Tyndale.com

Apr 16, 2025 • 1h 35min
Episode #188 "Redeemed from a broken identity. God’s Redemption Story"
"REDEEMED FROM A BROKEN IDENTITY - GODS REDEMPTION STORY” Because for so many of us, recovery isn’t just about what we’ve walked away from—it’s about what we’re walking toward. Healing. Wholeness. Freedom. And not just living in recovery, but moving forward as someone who’s been recovered.
I’m joined today by Sam Jones—a longtime listener of the show who’s now stepping behind the mic to share his story.(His voice however should come as no surprise. As He is the voice of our intro) And let me tell you—it’s powerful. It’s honest. And it’s proof that even after the damage of fundamentalism, there’s hope on the other side.
So wherever you are on your own road to recovery, I hope this episode reminds you that you're not alone… and that there is life ahead.

Apr 10, 2025 • 1h 15min
Episode #187 - The Pain of Betrayal / The Power of Redemption – Part 2 (with Jacob Kesling)
Episode Title: The Pain of Betrayal / The Power of Redemption – Part 2 (with Jacob Kesling)
In Part 2 of our conversation, Jacob Kesling joins host JC Groves to unpack the deep wounds of betrayal and the relentless hope found in redemption. From the raw realities of failure to the beauty of restoration, Jacob shares his journey with honesty, grace, and hard-won wisdom. Whether you're walking through your own season of brokenness or standing on the other side of healing, this episode is a reminder that no story is beyond the reach of grace.
Listen in as we explore what it means to be truly known, deeply hurt, and ultimately, fully redeemed.
RecoveringFundamentalist.org

Mar 31, 2025 • 46min
Episode #186 - This Is My Story
Episode #186 we’re diving into a topic that’s at the core of what we do here—the power of storytelling. We all know that stories have a way of breaking down barriers, making truth relatable, and reminding us that we’re not alone in our experiences.
And we’ve got a great guest with us today—Tommy from This is My Story. If you’ve ever wondered about the impact a personal testimony can have, this episode is for you!
Miracle Matt Film https://thisismystory.org/films/miracle-matt/Donate to TIMS https://thisismystory.org/support/This Is My Story Website https://thisismystory.org/This Is My Story Youtube https://www.youtube.com/@ThisIsMyStoryPODCASTAlternative Halftime Show Website https://www.althalftimeshow.com/

Mar 19, 2025 • 57min
Episode #185 - The Pain Of Betrayal / The Power Of Redemption.
Episode #185: The Pain of Betrayal
This is part one of a two part conversation. Part one is a deeply personal episode, as we explore the profound impact of betrayal on our lives. Through candid story and heartfelt reflections, JC takes us on a journey of his life and ministry over the last 20 years. Together we delve into the raw emotions and challenges faced when trust is broken. But also how to not stay there and allow bitters and hurt to hinder us from moving forward! In this epiosde we are reminded that God is always at work. Many times when we can't see it... But one day we benifit from it!
Join us as we navigate the complexities of forgiveness, healing, and finding hope after betrayal.

Mar 6, 2025 • 46min
184 - “Peace”
JC, Matt, and Nate are all back together for a new episode in a new year! This episode focuses on the Peace of God which passes all understanding. Peace is the fruit of the Spirit that defines the life of the believer. Jesus, the Prince of Peace, is leading His church into His will for us and He gives His peace to those who follow Him. Is our local church a place of peace? Is our home a place of Peace? Do I have peace in the storm?
What does the future of the RFP look like?
We deal with all of these questions and more on the first episode in 2025!

Dec 24, 2024 • 20min
183 - Christmas Eve special 2024
Join host JC Groves and Matt Dudley for our RFP 6th anual Christmas Eve speial.
Special Music by Chosen Road.

Nov 10, 2024 • 45min
182 - Pray For The Comeback
Our friend, brother and co host of the Recovering Fundamentalist Podcast, Nathan Cravatt, recently returned home from a mission trip to the country of Nepal. Several days after returning home he became very ill. He has only gotten worse.Many of you have asked how you can help. Right now, other than prayer for Nathans healing, financial support to cover the incoming medical bills is the greatest need.

Oct 12, 2024 • 1h 14min
181 - Legalism Doesn't Work
Disclaimer: There is a lot of sensitive information in this episode that is not suitable for young children.
In this episode, the guys confront a very sinister attack against the ministry God has called them to do. Sometimes all you have to do is wait and those who oppose the truth of Scripture will fall into their own traps. We should never celebrate when men fall, but we do not need to fail to observe what led them to their fate. Legalism is an old attack against the Gospel and it just does not work. This episode is a powerful illustration of that fact.

Sep 1, 2024 • 1h 21min
180 - Election Year 2024
JC, Matt, and Nathan discuss the division in our country that comes from politics. It's Election Year and we are called to live in a way that extends grace and displays the love of Christ for our enemies without sacrificing the truth. Join us for an honest look at the difficulty of navigating the political conversation in 2024.