
Illegitimate Scholar
Our culture is in crisis and I don’t trust woke universities and authoritarian governments to give us the solution. I examine modern culture through history and anthropology, as well as other sources like indigenous knowledge and common sense. This is a show for those who love academics but hate academia, and want to learn about social studies without the constraining limits of woke universities. Reach me on Discord, https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj and other sites: https://pod.link/1650280020, If you have any thoughts you'd like to share please email me: IllegitimateScholar@gmail.com
Latest episodes

24 snips
Apr 27, 2025 • 1h 37min
078 - Christian Mysticism is the Solution to Modern Problems
Scott Manion, a former Australian filmmaker, dives deep into Christian Mysticism and its potential to address modern societal issues. He discusses his departure from Hollywood, driven by a desire for deeper values amid cultural corruption. The conversation contrasts Christian Mysticism with Evangelical beliefs and explores the intersections of spirituality, technology, and political theory. Manion suggests that a Christian theocracy might be a way to navigate today's challenges, emphasizing the importance of inner guidance and authentic spiritual engagement.

4 snips
Mar 27, 2025 • 1h 30min
077 - Uncovering European Origins | Yamnaya, Celts, Vikings w/ Survive the Jive
Tom Rowsell, the mind behind the YouTube channel 'Survive the Jive,' dives into the pre-Christian history of Europe. He unpacks the significance of horse domestication and its impact on societal structures. The discussion includes ancient practices like bride stealing and the clash of agricultural and pastoral cultures. Tom also reflects on his personal heritage and the complexities of identity in the British Isles, analyzing how historical migrations shaped cultural narratives. This engaging conversation blends history, culture, and personal insights.

Mar 11, 2025 • 1h 18min
076 - The Psychology of Group Interactions
Exploring Group Dynamics and Organizational Culture with Brent Elwood and Aan MooreBrent Elwood, and Aodhan Moore join me on Illegitimate Scholar Podcast episode 76 to discuss group dynamics, organizational culture, and the influence of mythic archetypes on human interactions. They discuss their book, 'God Heroes and Groups Relational Dynamics Through Mythic Archetypes,' and the impact of Carl Jung's, Joseph Campbell's, and other thinkers' work on their studies. The conversation touches on projection, empathy, crisis compulsion in organizations, and how recognizing these dynamics can transform leadership and group interventions. This insightful episode is essential for anyone interested in the deeper psychological and cultural aspects of group interactions.Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar $5/MONTH Axios Fitness: https://axios-remote-fitness-coaching.ck.page/scholarhttps://www.groupdynamicslab.com/"Gods, Heroes and Groups: Relational Dynamics through Mythic Archetypes" Book: https://firingthemind.com/product/9781800132870/Aodhán Moran X: https://x.com/aodhanpmoranBrant Elwood X: https://x.com/TheGroupLens00:00 Brent Evans01:12 Aodhan Moore01:51 'God, Heroes, and Groups'03:54 Group Relations Examples05:30 The Role of Archetypes in Modern Culture13:32 Religion, Culture, and Archetypes18:37 The Decline of Religious Practice and Its Consequences27:23 Group Dynamics and Social Justice38:25 Franz De Waal's Work38:56 Bonobo Society and Infanticide40:16 Human Monogamy and DNA Testing41:50 Leadership and Power in Groups44:15 The Influence of Small Groups in Politics47:55 Group Dynamics in Conferences49:03 The Mythic Application in Leadership55:51 Coursework and Practical Applications01:10:25 The Crisis Compulsion in OrganizationsDiscord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6JjPatreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholarYoutube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

Mar 1, 2025 • 1h 15min
075 - Anthropologist Exposes How Activists took over Anthropology
Patreon:https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholarDr Weiss's Book (On the Warpath: My Battles With Indians, Pretendians, and Woke Warriors): https://amzn.to/3EZktCfDr Weiss on X: https://x.com/eweissunburiedControversy in Anthropology: Elizabeth Weiss on Repatriation, Academic Freedom, and Identity PoliticsIn this episode, Elizabeth Weiss, a physical anthropologist and Professor Emeritus at San Jose State University, discusses her experiences with academic freedom, repatriation laws, and the impact of woke ideology on anthropology. She details her legal battle with her university based on her research and statements. Those statements about sex differences in skeletons and views on repatriation under NAGPRA were once acceptable but became not. Weiss provides insights into the ethical and scientific challenges posed by the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA). She explores how current identity politics are influencing the field of Anthropology and gives examples. The discussion also touches on the controversy surrounding the Kennewick Man and other paleo-Indian remains. Weiss shares her views on the importance of preserving academic freedom and scientific integrity in anthropology.00:00 075 Elizabeth Weiss00:41 Dr. Elizabeth Weiss01:53 NAGPRA04:07 Repatriation Ideology13:47 The Kennewick Man Case26:27 Race & Gender by Skeletal Remains34:43 Skull Measuring Then vs Now39:54 Political Leanings in Anthropology42:28 Academic Freedom & Risk46:07 Consequences of Lawsuit50:08 Repatriation Law Changes 202452:57 Dealing with the SAA57:38 Issues with Modern Anthropology01:03:48 Use of Skeletal Remains ChangingDiscord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6JjPatreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholarYoutube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

Feb 12, 2025 • 2h 55min
074 - Red Tail Hawk - Ancient Knowledge
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar $5/MONTH Axios Fitness: https://axios-remote-fitness-coaching.ck.page/scholarRed Tail Hawk Talks Reincarnation, Ancient Apocalypse, and Serpent Symbolism | Illegitimate Scholar PodcastIn Episode 74 of the Illegitimate Scholar Podcast, Red Tail Hawk shares his profound journey that began with an encounter with a Pascua Yaqui medicine man. He delves into the significance of his name, his experiences in 2018, and the powerful phenomenon he encountered. The conversation explores the Pascua Yaqui culture, reincarnation research, and Case Study evidence from the University of Virginia. Red Tail Hawk discusses spiritual awakening, the interconnectedness of ancient wisdom traditions, and the symbolism of serpents across cultures. The episode also examines geomagnetic pole shifts, ancient lost civilizations like Mu, and the fascinating theories surrounding megastructures and megaliths. This comprehensive discussion intertwines ancient philosophies, esoteric knowledge, and modern scientific findings.00:00 Introduction to Red Tail Hawk00:08 Pascua Yaqui Medicine Man05:39 Journey Through Different Faiths14:11 Reincarnation Research and Case Studies33:59 Ancient Civilizations and Cataclysmic Events58:10 Magnetic Forces and Polar Shifts59:13 Galactic Current Sheet Impact01:03:04 Cataclysmic Floods and Evolution01:18:53 Genesis and Cataclysmic Events01:35:51 Lost Civilizations and Ancient Languages01:59:31 Exploring Qi Energy Centers02:00:24 Medicine Man and the Aura02:03:06 Ancient Energy Healing Traditions02:07:13 Kundalini and Chakra Activation02:12:10 Serpent Symbolism Across Cultures02:46:30 Megaliths and GeopolymersDiscord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6JjPatreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholarYoutube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

Jan 6, 2025 • 2h 60min
073 - Central European History, Academia, & the Modern World
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar ONLY $2/MONTH Axios Fitness: https://axios-remote-fitness-coaching.ck.page/scholarCentral-European History, Academia, and a Personal Postcard CollectionStephan Sander-Faes X: https://x.com/sksanderfaesPostcard Collection Substack: https://espc.substack.com/A Deep Dive into Central-European History, Academia, and a Personal Postcard CollectionIn this episode of the Illegitimate Scholar Podcast, I am joined by Stephan, a historian of European history, currently a tenured associate professor at the University of Bergen, Norway. We explore a wide range of topics including the performative absurdities in academia, the historical intricacies of the Balkans, and how language shapes identity. We also delve into Stefan's unique personal project of preserving vintage postcards from his grandfather's collection, covering places and eras now lost to time. This episode offers a deep, multifaceted look into European history, academic culture, and the personal stories carried through generations.00:00 Clips01:13 Intro02:04 Geographical and Cultural Comparisons04:21 Academic and Professional Journeys09:02 Historical Insights and Naval History11:59 Tourism and Cultural Reflections34:46 Cruise Tours and Scenic Journeys35:46 Norwegian Commutes and Waterborne Transport41:15 Historical Reflections and Academic Tributes47:33 Religious Conflicts and Cultural Preservation01:25:09 The Rise of the Austrian Institute of Science and Technology01:26:35 Gaming the Academic System01:27:05 University Rankings and Funding01:30:27 Personal Anecdotes and Academic Experiences01:38:41 The Lost Art of Postcards and Family History02:11:00 Discussing Grandfather's Surrender and POW Camps02:13:09 Grandfather's Post-War Life and Career02:15:35 Reflections on Sharing War Experiences02:20:38 Academic Career and Historical Research02:25:48 Cultural and Political ObservationsDiscord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6JjPatreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholarYoutube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

5 snips
Dec 14, 2024 • 1h 38min
072 - Graham Hancock: Ancient Civilizations & Academia
Graham Hancock, an acclaimed author and researcher known for his provocative ideas about ancient civilizations, joins the discussion. He critiques the control mainstream archaeology holds over historical narratives. Hancock emphasizes the potential for a lost advanced civilization and the significance of shamanistic practices, linking modern psychedelics to ancient wisdom. He also calls for a reevaluation of archaeological evidence, challenging established narratives to foster a richer understanding of our shared past. Prepare for a mind-expanding journey that rethinks history!

Nov 17, 2024 • 1h 58min
071 - How We Decide What is True about Ancient Human History
Exploring Human Beliefs, Civilization Origins, and Racism - A Deep DiveRebirth's Twitter: https://x.com/rebirthofthewo1Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar ONLY $2/MONTH Axios Fitness: https://axios-remote-fitness-coaching.ck.page/scholarJoin me with rebirth of the Word to discuss the varying concepts of racism, and why people hold certain beliefs. We discuss the works and critiques of figures like Graham Hancock and Flint Dibble, the evolution of human thought, and the intersection of religion and mythology. This episode also covers diverse topics such as the Big Bang Theory, ancient civilizations, and the impact of modern technology on our lives. The complexities of human history and social constructs.00:00 Rebirth of the Word02:23 Understanding Beliefs and Sources08:13 Racism and Historical Contexts40:40 Questioning Ancient Civilizations44:29 Ad Read45:50 The Complexity of Human Ancestry and Skin Color48:36 Debating Historical Theories and Evidence55:02 The Role of Academia and Public Discourse01:18:12 Ancient Civilizations and the Origin of Pottery01:19:07 Misconceptions and Corrections in Historical Knowledge01:22:24 Defining Civilization and Its Early Indicators01:28:55 Slavery and Class Structures01:37:16 Future Plans and Reflections on Knowledge SharingDiscord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6JjPatreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholarYoutube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

Oct 25, 2024 • 1h 31min
070 - The Most Misunderstood Philosopher in History
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar ONLY $2/MONTH Axios Fitness: https://axios-remote-fitness-coaching.ck.page/scholarAmanda: https://x.com/AjaxtheGriffDecoding Machiavelli: Insights, Influences, and Political LegacyJoin us for an exploration into the life, works, and enduring influence of Niccolò Machiavelli. Delve into his intriguing journey from diplomat to philosopher against the backdrop of Renaissance Florence, his exile, and the writing of 'The Prince'. Uncover the intellectual and linguistic nuances that shaped his thoughts, from Jewish mystical texts and Ecstatic Kabbalah to Greek and Roman philosophy. Discover Machiavelli's radical views on innovation, liberty, and political theory, his criticisms of mercenaries, and his vision of a citizen militia. Through engaging discussions on translation effects, political context, and interpretations over the centuries, we challenge mainstream perceptions and highlight Machiavelli's lasting impact on modern political thought.00:00 Intro00:37 Amanda's Educational Background01:45 Language06:36 Machiavelli08:54 Machiavelli's Early Life and Influences16:42 Political Turmoil and Exile33:51 Machiavelli's Return 39:08 Machiavelli's Legacy 40:10 Protestant Reformation and Machiavelli43:48 Machiavelli's Views on Religion45:17 Machiavelli's Influence on English and French Thought47:43 Mistraslation of "Ends Justify the Means" 55:42 Machiavelli's Concept of Fortuna01:18:18 Technology and Political Order01:21:50 Marx Machiavelli Comparedd01:29:53 The One Big TakeawayAxios Fitness: https://axios-remote-fitness-coaching.ck.page/scholarhttps://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar ONLY $2/MONTH Discord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6JjPatreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholarYoutube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

Oct 8, 2024 • 1h 36min
069 - The Search for Civilizations Among the Stars
Alien Archaeology.I am joined by Aelthemplaer, not Luthemplaer. He tells me about how to find life or civilizations on other planets. What signs scientists look for and what conditions are best. What scientific methods are used, how we would know. The differences in possible life forms like silicon versus carbon. He tells me about some strange anomalies that are not yet understood. https://x.com/Aelthemplaer00:00 IS Athemplaer02:47 Architecture and Bioengineering05:21 Exoplanets and Light Spectroscopy07:27 The Science of Exoplanetary Atmospheres09:35 Challenges in Detecting Exoplanetary Life19:06 The Search for Extraterrestrial Civilizations20:11 The Complexity of Exoplanetary Atmospheres39:34 The Possibility of Alien Life42:14 Synthetic Life47:14 Interstellar Archaeoloy50:45 Theoretical Warp Drives55:04 The Enigma of Magnetars01:28:01 Cultural and Archaeological Insights01:29:38 Native American Architecture01:33:29 The Haida and Their Unique IronworksDiscord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6JjPatreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholarYoutube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw