Ask Haviv Anything

Dan Schueftan, an Israeli national security scholar and advisor on the 2005 Gaza disengagement, shares his insights on the complex realities facing Israel and Gaza. He discusses the failures in Israeli strategy leading to recent conflicts, the cultural definitions of 'barbarism,' and the challenge of differentiating between moderate and radical Arab leaders. Schueftan emphasizes the need for military readiness alongside a pluralistic society and argues that true de-radicalization in Gaza is unlikely without local desire. He expresses skepticism about the feasibility of disarming Hamas and underscores the importance of Israeli security.

Rabbi Elhanan Miller, an Arabic-speaking educator and founder of the People of the Book project, engages in a compelling dialogue about bridging Jewish and Arab narratives. He shares his journey from journalism to rabbinic studies and the launch of his project, aimed at teaching Judaism in Arabic. Miller discusses the impact of social media on Jewish-Arab relations, his media presence during the Gaza war, and critiques Israeli policies to build credibility. He also explores political Islam, the need for new Palestinian strategies, and whether Hamas can be defeated.

Dara Horn, an award-winning novelist and scholar of Hebrew and Yiddish literature, discusses the complexities of Jewish narratives and the unsettling nature of antisemitism. She explores the fascination with stories of dead Jews versus living ones, emphasizing how society often prefers powerless portrayals. Horn also introduces the Tell Institute, aimed at reshaping Jewish education to combat ignorance. Through discussions on antisemitism and Jewish history, she highlights the urgent need for educational initiatives that empower current and future generations.

Coleman Hughes, a writer and podcaster known for his thoughtful insights on race, joins the discussion on pressing current issues. He delves into America’s quiet response to the Gaza ceasefire proposal, examining motives behind the silence. Coleman explores the rise of antisemitism in the U.S. and its roots in both far-right and left-wing ideologies. He also addresses the historical dynamics between the Black community and Jewish Americans, explaining how cultural narratives and economic perceptions influence contemporary relations. Can understanding bridge the gap?

A historic peace and hostage release deal has emerged, with significant implications for Gaza's future. The agreement offers rebuilding opportunities and prevents annexation, benefiting the region. Contrastingly, Hamas faces substantial challenges as it must disarm and cede authority. The podcast explores the shifting support from regional players and questions whether Hamas can adapt or survive. Analyzing the deal's potential for regional stability, it raises concerns about upcoming phases and the role of international forces. The moment presents a blend of hope and uncertainty.

Eli Sharabi is an Israeli author and former hostage who endured 491 days in Hamas captivity. In this gripping conversation, he recounts his harrowing abduction and the psychological struggles he faced underground. Eli shares profound insights about the dynamics among hostages, the illusions of their captors, and the brutal realities of life in Gaza. He highlights the importance of hope, resilience, and unity within the Jewish community, urging careful political messaging to avoid further jeopardizing hostages. His story is a tribute to his lost family and a call for reflection.

The podcast explores the poignant intersection of joy and sorrow as the anniversary of the October 7 tragedy coincides with Sukkot and Simchat Torah. It delves into how Jewish tradition teaches us to reconcile mourning and celebration, drawing on insights from the Talmud. The discussion examines themes of resilience, gratitude, and the impact of ongoing trauma on the Jewish community, highlighting the importance of acknowledging grief to find genuine joy. The episode concludes with an uplifting reminder that love for Jerusalem can coexist with mourning.

Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib, a Palestinian-American analyst and director at the Atlantic Council, shares his insights on the future of Gaza. He discusses the feasibility of Trump's Gaza plan, highlighting the potential for a regional stabilization force to succeed where others have failed. With personal ties to Gaza, he emphasizes the need for Palestinian-led governance to counter Hamas and the role of civil society in creating a new leadership. Alkhatib also explores how the current conflict might diminish Hamas's appeal among Gazans.

A fast-paced analysis unveils Trump's 20-point plan for Gaza, promising hostages' release and a new era of reconstruction. Strategic insights highlight Qatar's role in bolstering Hamas's dilemma. The discussion deep dives into whether the war's aims are destructive or aimed at removing Hamas entirely. With pressure mounting, will Hamas accept a deal or risk total loss? The plan intriguingly positions Netanyahu politically, balancing opposition and the promise of rebuilding. An optimistic outlook suggests we're closer to a disarmed Gaza.

David Horovitz, editor and founder of The Times of Israel, shares insights from his rare trip to Damascus. He describes the surreal VIP treatment he received, including exclusive meetings with Syrian officials eager to reconnect with their Jewish diaspora. Horovitz delves into the emotional impact of ancient Jewish artifacts he witnessed in the National Museum and discusses the urgent economic stabilization efforts of new Syrian leaders. He also reflects on friendly interactions while walking through the city, painting a complex picture of a changing Syria.