The Street Epistemology Podcast

On January 25th at 10am Central, 4pm, UTC, Join the Street Epistemology Town Hall here: https://streamyard.com/5k25zcuwin What happens when we stop trying to win conversations—and start examining how we know what we think we know? Learn more at https://navigatingbeliefs.com In this long-form conversation, I’m joined by Anthony Magnabosco, Executive Director of Street Epistemology International, to explore Street Epistemology (SE): a conversational approach designed to help people reflect on the quality of their reasoning—especially around deeply held, emotionally charged beliefs. We discuss: ✅ What Street Epistemology is (and what it is not) ✅ SE vs. debate, deliberation, and dialogue ✅ Persuasion, advocacy, and ethical boundaries ✅ Cognitive biases like confirmation bias and cognitive dissonance ✅ The “outsider test” and other reflection-triggering techniques ✅ Belief, identity, tribalism, and polarization ✅ Intellectual humility and critical self-reflection ✅ Whether SE can be a tool for healing—not just reasoning ✅ Why calm, curiosity-driven conversations struggle in the modern attention economy This episode is for anyone interested in better conversations, critical thinking, and navigating disagreement without coercion, ridicule, or performative outrage. 🎧 Ideal for educators, students, dialogue practitioners, skeptics, and anyone trying to make sense of belief, belonging, and truth in a polarized world. Original Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ejbe766vW_s

What happens when a deeply held religious belief is grounded not in doctrine alone, but in lived experience, trauma, healing, and profound personal transformation? In this long-form spoken-word dialogue, we practice Street Epistemology—a respectful, curiosity-driven method for exploring how people arrive at their beliefs rather than arguing what they should believe. A stranger approaches us in a public park and shares a powerful story of near-death experiences, loss, spiritual encounters, and absolute certainty that Jesus is God. Rather than debate, this conversation explores: ✅ How personal experiences shape confidence ✅ Whether peace, identity, and meaning depend on belief ✅ How people evaluate truth when experiences feel undeniable ✅ The role of trauma, healing, and interpretation ✅ What it means to be “open to truth,” even when certainty feels complete This episode moves slowly and carefully, prioritizing psychological safety, consent, and mutual respect—especially when beliefs are closely tied to identity and well-being. 🎧 This is not a debate. It’s an invitation to reflect on belief, confidence, and how we decide what’s real. 👉 Comments are welcome: At what moment would you have asked a different question? Watch video here: youtu.be/TWfoaSNxC-k Learn more about Street Epistemology here: linktr.ee/StreetEpistemology Music provided by Jim Rhodes, with Dan Harris on lap steel. 00:00 – Context, Setup, and Intent Why this conversation begins informally, pacing choices, and psychological safety considerations. 02:31 – The Core Claim “I believe Jesus is God” — the belief that frames the entire dialogue. 04:41 – What Is Street Epistemology? How this conversational method explores how beliefs are formed rather than debating conclusions. 11:46 – Life History and the Search for Meaning Family background, trauma, therapy, education, and early belief formation. 14:21 – Near-Death Experience and Its Impact A medical crisis and how it reshaped interpretation of life and meaning. 18:33 – Trauma, Loss, and Spiritual Seeking Grief, relationship collapse, and an intense period of searching for God. 19:29 – Transformative Spiritual Experience Receiving the Holy Spirit and the moment belief becomes absolute. 24:37 – Miracles, Healing, and Reinforcement Extraordinary experiences used to strengthen confidence in the belief. 26:22 – Identity Without the Belief (Thought Experiment) Would peace, joy, and meaning survive if the belief were removed? 35:39 – Confidence, Truth, and Certainty Placing belief and truth-seeking on a confidence scale. 41:17 – Reliability of Experience Can others use experiences to reach opposite conclusions? 59:05 – Alternative Explanations and Closing Reflections Psychological and social explanations considered, ending with mutual respect.

Members of Street Epistemology International’s Board of Directors provide a candid progress update and answer questions from the community during the 4th SEI Town Hall. https://www.streetepistemology.com https://www.streetepistemologyinternational.org https://www.navigatingbeliefs.com https://linktr.ee/StreetEpistemology

Delve into the complexities of belief systems as experts tackle relativism and dogmatism. Explore why people hold onto unfounded beliefs, using extreme examples like crystal healing. The discussion introduces techniques like the 'outsider test' to encourage self-reflection. Learn the value of questioning over assertion in challenging conversations and the detrimental effects of dogmatism on personal growth. Emphasis is placed on fostering curiosity and creating supportive environments for open-minded dialogue.

In this episode, Pierce Watkins engages with a witchcraft practitioner who shares insights into their six-year practice, discussing divination methods like tarot, pendulums, and charm casting. Pierce explores the practices through a skeptical yet curious lens, participating in a pendulum reading, which leads to a candid discussion on accuracy, belief, and personal resonance. Watch video here: https://youtu.be/ly6BEcZt8OY Learn more about Street Epistemology here: https://linktr.ee/StreetEpistemology Music provided by Jim Rhodes, with Dan Harris on lap steel. The intro and outro of this episode was narrated by Elliott.

This podcast dives into the debate over rebranding Street Epistemology as 'Navigating Beliefs.' It weighs the potential benefits of attracting a wider audience against the risks of alienating existing practitioners. The discussion highlights the importance of transforming confrontational debates into collaborative conversations that foster empathy. Additionally, it emphasizes the need for a balance between accessibility and analytical rigor while maintaining ethical practices for productive dialogue. Tune in to explore how new names can reshape perceptions!

This episode features Hilton and Jeff. They use Street Epistemology to explore Hilton's confidence that karma is real Watch video here: https://youtu.be/npO9hM_xCn4 Learn more about Street Epistemology here: https://linktr.ee/StreetEpistemology Music provided by Jim Rhodes, with Dan Harris on lap steel. The intro and outro of this episode was narrated by Elliott.

This AI generated episode traces the evolution of Street Epistemology from its beginnings in questioning religious beliefs to a global movement fostering thoughtful dialogue on topics like politics and personal values. It highlights how curiosity, connection, and critical thinking drive its growth and broaden its impact. Want more Rational Ruminations? https://futureofthought.substack.com/ https://www.youtube.com/@rational_ruminations_se Learn more about Street Epistemology here: https://linktr.ee/StreetEpistemology Music provided by Jim Rhodes, with Dan Harris on lap steel. The intro and outro of this episode was narrated by Elliott.

This Episode features Sofia as she discusses her thoughts on Deism. Watch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=74PvqiSnR8I Learn more about Street Epistemology here: https://linktr.ee/StreetEpistemology Music provided by Jim Rhodes, with Dan Harris on lap steel. The intro and outro of this episode was narrated by Elliott.

In part 2 of this AI generated Episode, we continue the exploration of Deep Canvassing and Street Epistemology. Can a blend of the two be more impactful than each method alone? Want more Rational Ruminations? https://futureofthought.substack.com/ https://www.youtube.com/@rational_ruminations_se Watch video here: https://youtu.be/-G5CFNGYchs?si=WQ9vDGfUHuocmS63 Learn more about Street Epistemology here: https://linktr.ee/StreetEpistemology Music provided by Jim Rhodes, with Dan Harris on lap steel. The intro and outro of this episode was narrated by Elliott.