

College Matters from The Chronicle
The Chronicle of Higher Education
Higher education is at the center of the biggest stories in the country today, and College Matters is here to make sense of it all. This podcast is a production of The Chronicle of Higher Education, the nation's leading independent newsroom covering colleges.
Episodes
Mentioned books

Oct 29, 2025 • 31min
Is ‘Intellectual Diversity’ a Trap?
Lately, calls for “intellectual diversity” are all the rage. From President Trump, to right-wing think tanks, to college presidents, arguments abound for adding more conservative voices to the professoriate. But are these arguments being made in good faith? How liberal are faculty, really? And what does a push for a narrowed, classics-driven curriculum mean for the canon-expanding courses that some colleges now offer on subjects as diverse as the Grateful Dead and Taylor Swift?Related Reading:
Higher Education Needs to Embrace a Diversity of Beliefs (Fox News/ Gordon Gee)
Viewpoint Diversity is a MAGA Plot (The Review / Lisa Siraganian)
How One State’s 'Intellectual Diversity' Law Has Changed Professors’ Teaching (The Chronicle)
GuestBrock Read, deputy managing editor of The Chronicle of Higher Education
For more on today’s episode, visit chronicle.com/collegematters. We aim to make transcripts available within a day of an episode’s publication.

Oct 22, 2025 • 41min
Policing Antisemitism
The pro-Palestinian protests that erupted on many college campuses in the spring of 2024 gave rise to a surge of complaints about antisemitism at colleges across the United States. Under pressure to respond, Columbia and Harvard Universities have both in the past year adopted into policy a common definition of antisemitism, using the text as a guide in discrimination investigations. But defining the line between legitimate criticism of Israeli policy and antisemitism has long bedeviled scholars, and refereeing such cases invites concerns about free speech and academic freedom. The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's working definition of antisemitism, upon which Columbia and Harvard now rely, wasn’t ever intended to be a speech code and shouldn’t be used as such, says Kenneth Stern, who helped to draft the text about two decades ago. But how, then, should colleges respond to concerns about hatred and prejudice aimed at Jewish people?
Colleges Use His Antisemitism Definition to Censor. He Calls It a ‘Travesty.’ (The Chronicle)
The Great Antisemitism Debate (The Chronicle)
Why Anti-Jewish Discrimination on Campuses Might Not Violate Title VI (The Chronicle)
UC Berkeley Hands Over 160 Names to the Federal Government for ‘Potential Connection’ to Antisemitism. (The Chronicle)
GuestKenneth S. Stern, director of the Center for the Study of Hate at Bard College.
For more on today’s episode, visit chronicle.com/collegematters. We aim to make transcripts available within a day of an episode’s publication.

Oct 15, 2025 • 31min
Obama to Colleges: WTF
In this discussion, Andy Thomason, assistant managing editor at The Chronicle of Higher Education, delves into Barack Obama's call for college leaders to prioritize academic independence. They explore the potential impacts of the Trump administration's 'Compact for Academic Excellence,' which conditions funding on compliance with strict policies. The conversation examines how institutions like MIT resist political pressure while others, such as Columbia, yield under financial duress. The balancing act between personal risk and institutional survival takes center stage as they highlight the future of academic integrity.

Oct 8, 2025 • 40min
Trump’s ‘Compact’ Is Freaking People Out
After months of skirmishes with colleges, the Trump administration has proposed a treaty of sorts with nine high-profile institutions. By signing the “Compact for Academic Excellence in Higher Education,” participating colleges would essentially co-sign the president’s sprawling higher-education agenda. Under a draft agreement, signatories would explicitly ban considerations of race in admissions or in the awarding of scholarships, abolish departments that “belittle” conservative views, and strictly limit the percentage of international students enrolled in undergraduate programs. Many higher-education associations and analysts rushed to blast the proposal, which has been described as “horrifying” and reminiscent of a Mafia-style ultimatum. But what does this compact say about the historic relationship between the federal government and higher education, and how might that relationship be changing no matter what?Related Reading
Trump’s Proposed ‘Compact’ Asks Colleges to Show They’re ‘Pursuing Federal Priorities’ (The Chronicle)
Trump Says Signing a New ‘Compact’ Will Benefit Colleges’ Finances. It Could Also Do the Opposite. (The Chronicle)
Trump’s Imperfect Compact Is a Perfect Opportunity (The Chronicle Review)
A Deal That Would End Universities’ Independence (The Atlantic)
GuestSarah Brown, senior editor at The Chronicle of Higher Education

Oct 1, 2025 • 41min
Princeton President Talks Kirk, Trump, ‘Civic Crisis’
As president of Princeton University, Christopher Eisgruber is among the highest-profile college leaders to publicly criticize the Trump administration for its attacks on higher education. He is a defender of the sector, arguing that colleges are far better at upholding free speech and more welcoming of diverse viewpoints than critics would suggest. The recent killing of Charlie Kirk, a conservative activist, has energized a national debate about the state of free speech on college campuses — both for conservatives like Kirk, and for faculty who have been sanctioned for speaking ill of Kirk in the wake of his death. None of this, though, changes Eisgruber’s fundamental view that colleges, for the most part, are actually quite good at facilitating tough conversations at a particularly polarized moment. It’s an argument Eisgruber lays out methodically in a new book, Terms of Respect: How Colleges Get Free Speech Right.Related Reading
Terms of Respect: How Colleges Get Free Speech Right, by Christopher Eisgruber (Basic Books)
With Charlie Kirk’s Killing, a New Chapter of the Campus Speech Wars Has Begun (The Chronicle)
The Elite-University Presidents Who Despise One Another (The Atlantic)
At Yale, Painful Rifts Emerge Over Diversity and Free Speech (The Chronicle)

Sep 24, 2025 • 35min
The Research Trump Hates
Stephanie M. Lee, a senior writer at The Chronicle of Higher Education, delves into the Trump administration's drastic cuts to federal research funding. She discusses the impact on vital studies in vaccine hesitancy, gender identity, and climate change, revealing how politicized funding is reshaping the research landscape. Lee highlights the economic repercussions for communities, the practical harms of halted research, and the long-term fears among scientists regarding career stability and U.S. scientific leadership. This conversation uncovers the precarious future of academic research.

Sep 17, 2025 • 59min
Chris Rufo Floats Calling in ‘Troops’
Christopher F. Rufo, a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, shares his journey from left-leaning beliefs to conservative activism. He discusses his successful campaigns against diversity, equity, and inclusion programs, arguing they serve elite interests. Rufo dives into race and admissions, advocating for colorblind standards while recognizing race's social context. He reflects on high-profile controversies, including Claudine Gay's resignation, and reveals his influence on government policies aimed at reshaping higher education.

Sep 11, 2025 • 27min
The Meaning of Charlie Kirk
The fatal shooting of Charlie Kirk, whose political movement targeted liberal faculty and pushed the boundaries of free speech, immediately took on powerful symbolic resonance as a pivotal event in higher education’s long-running culture wars. Kirk, who founded Turning Point USA, a provocative right-leaning group popular on college campuses, was killed on Wednesday during a campus speaking engagement at Utah Valley University. His death shocked the country, lending a dark gravity to already-contentious debates about political polarization, intolerance, and free expression on college campuses.Related Reading Making of a Martyr: Charlie Kirk’s Killing Silences a Conservative Voice. His Movement Could Grow Louder. (The Chronicle)
Inside a Stealth Plan for Political Influence (The Chronicle)
Was an Instructor's Firing a Violation Academic Freedom? Or an Example of 'Academic Responsibility' (The Chronicle)
Charlie Kirk Was Practicing Politics the Right Way (The New York Times)
GuestNell Gluckman, senior reporter at The Chronicle of Higher Education
For more on today’s episode, visit chronicle.com/collegematters. We aim to make transcripts available within a day of an episode’s publication.

Sep 3, 2025 • 2min
College Matters Is Back
Higher education is at the center of the biggest stories in the country today, and College Matters is back to make sense of it all. Tune in for new weekly episodes starting on September 11.
Catch up on previous popular episodes:
Is Reading Over for Gen Z Students?
Why Faculty Hate Teaching Evaluations
Mr. Varsity Blues Claps Back
For more on today’s episode, visit chronicle.com/collegematters.

Aug 5, 2025 • 31min
Course Catalog: Bruce Springsteen’s American Vision
For decades, Bruce Springsteen’s songs about fast cars, working-class dreamers, and loves lost and found have helped to define a quintessentially American notion of freedom and rebellion. But do the music and lyrics of “The Boss” speak to the college students of Gen Z? Louis P. Masur, a distinguished professor of American studies and history at Rutgers University, thinks they do. After years of teaching a course titled “Springsteen’s American Vision,” Masur says he is as convinced as ever that the rock icon’s songs are as timeless as Huck Finn and as durable as a “big old Buick.”
Guest: Louis P. Masur, distinguished professor of American studies and history at Rutgers UniversityRelated reading
Runaway Dream: Born to Run and Bruce Springsteen’s American Vision (Louis P. Masur)
The Boss in the Classroom (Chronicle)
For more on today’s episode, visit chronicle.com/collegematters. We aim to make transcripts available within a day of an episode’s publication.


