
The Movie Proposal
Hosted by Skye Jethani and friend (and former Big Idea employee a long, long time ago) Josh Lindsay, "The Movie Proposal" is a deep dive into movies from two thoughtful Christian guys. Check it out and tell us what you think!
Latest episodes

Sep 24, 2020 • 1h 7min
Episode 91: Faith Based with Luke Barnett
Something Old: Josh’s: Waiting for Guffman (1996) Skye’s: Speed (1994) Luke’s: Monty Python’s Life of Brian (1979) Something New: Faith Based (2020) Something Blew: Josh’s: Unorthodox Skye’s: The Social Dilemma Luke’s: PEN15 Jason’s: The Mandalorian Season 2 Trailer & the WandaVision Trailer Follow Luke On Twitter

Sep 11, 2020 • 48min
Episode 90: Bill & Ted Face the Music
Something Old: Josh’s: The Big Lebowski Skye’s: Karate Kid Something New: Bill & Ted Face the Music Josh’s Proposal: Bill & Ted Face the Music is a must see for all fathers from Generation X. Skye’s Proposal: Bill & Ted Face the Music epitomizes the decadence of American society and how far we have fallen. Something Borrowed: ‘Bill & Ted Face the Music’ Review: Be Adequate to Each Other Something Blew: Josh’s: Dune & Tenet Skye’s: Dune Jason’s: Class Action Park

Aug 13, 2020 • 42min
Episode 89: Greyhound
TMP89: Something Old: Josh’s: Saving Private Ryan (1998) Skye’s: Good Fellas (1990) Something New: Greyhound (2020) Josh’s Proposal: Greyhound is a good film that unfortunately suffers from trusting it’s audience too much. Skye’s Proposal: Greyhound is the perfect Dad movie. Jason’s Proposal: Greyhound proves how influential Christopher Nolan is, particularly when he’s paired with Hans Zimmer. Something Borrowed: The History behind the Greyhound movie Something Blew: Josh’s: The Stunt Double & Sister Skye’s: Yellowstone Jason’s: The Great Escape

Jul 30, 2020 • 57min
Episode 88: Animal Crackers with Tony Bancroft
TMP 88: Something Old Josh’s: The Greatest Show on Earth (1951) Skye’s: Short Circuit (1986) Tom’s: Tombstone (1993) Something New: Animal Crackers (2017) Something Blew: Tony’s: The Incredibles (2004) Josh’s: Devs (2020) Skye’s: The Patriot (2000) Jason’s: Act One Tv Writing Program

Jul 16, 2020 • 60min
Episode 87: Hamilton
Something Old: Kevin’s: Glory (1989) Josh’s: Romancing the Stone (1984) Skye’s: The Last of the Mohicans (1992) Something New: Hamilton (2020) Josh’s Proposal: Hamilton has taught me a life lesson of seizing the moment. Skye’s Proposal: Hamilton says as much about America’s present, as it does about America’s past. Something Borrowed: Kevin’s Youtube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/saygoodnightkevin/ Something Blew: Skye’s: Crash Course Josh’s: Space Force Kevin’s: The Death of Stalin Jason’s: Imagine: A vision for Christians in the Arts

Jul 3, 2020 • 52min
Episode 86: Da 5 Bloods
TMP 86: Something Old: Josh’s: Good Morning, Vietnam (1987) Skye’s: Forrest Gump (1994) Something New: Da 5 Bloods Josh’s Proposal: You better know your history in order to fully appreciate Da 5 Bloods Skye’s Proposal: Like a lot of spike lee movies, this one is very preachy, the problem I have is that he violates one of the core tenants of communication, Keep it Simple Stupid. Something Borrowed: Josh’s Vietnam Game Something Blew: Josh’s: This Much I Know is True Skye’s: Star Wars! I guess? Kind of. Jason’s: The best Magnum P.I. scene of all time Jeffrey Lieber’s break down of the Magnum P.I. Scene What if Jesus was Serious?

Jun 11, 2020 • 46min
Episode 85: The Vast of Night
Something Old: Josh’s: Gattaca (1997) Skye’s: Jaws (1975) Something New: The Vast of Night (2019) Josh’s Proposal: The Vast of Night is a great alternative to the mainstream for real movie lovers. Skye’s Proposal: Something Borrowed: The Vast of Night director was 'the last person to know' about his DIY sci-fi film's success Something Blew: Josh’s: The Amazing Johnathan & Never Surrender: A Galaxy Quest Documentary Skye’s: The Volume & What if Jesus was Serious? & Ducks Vs Locusts Jason’s: Watchmen (2019) & The Official Watchmen Podcast

May 15, 2020 • 49min
Episode 84: Extraction
Something Old: Josh’s: Lethal Weapon 2 (1989) Skye’s: Commando (1985) Something New: Extraction (2020) Josh’s Proposal: Extraction is a decent action film, with good old fashioned male bravado redemption. Skye’s Proposal: Extraction is the 2020’s version of the classic 80’s genre. Something Borrowed Something Blew: Josh’s: Dead to Me & Contagion Skye’s: The Last Dance & Star Wars News Jason’s: The Big Sick

May 1, 2020 • 45min
Episode 83: The Gentlemen
TMP: 83 Something Old: Josh’s: The Shawshank Redemption Skye’s: A Fish Called Wanda Something New: The Gentlemen Josh’s Proposal: The Gentleman is a morality tale that sends mixed messages about morality. Skye’s Proposal: The Gentlemen proves why Guy Ritchie should stick to making comedy crime movies with an ensemble cast. (Like Aladdin) Something Borrowed: The Best Movies to Watch in Quarantine According to Famous Directors Something Blew: Josh’s: Assassin 33 A.D., Greater & Leave No Trace Skye’s: McMillions, The Mandalorian Behind the Scenes on May 4th & Hail, Caesar! Jason’s: Barry & Bad Education

Apr 16, 2020 • 44min
Episode 82: Onward
Something Old: Josh’s: Paper Moon (1973) Skye’s: Dr. No (1962) Something New: Onward (2020) Josh’s Proposal: Pixar movies fall in one of three categories: Great, Just OK, or Sequel. Skye’s Proposal: Of all the PIXAR Films, Onward has one of the most emotionally impactful endings, but overall, it was just mediocre. Something Borrowed: Onward Is Already Getting A Prequel, But Not How You Think Something Blew: Josh’s: Once Upon a Time in the West & Molly’s Game Skye’s: Leadership in Turbulent Times & The Roosevelts Jason’s: The Nice Guys