

Radio Rental
Tenderfoot TV & Audacy
Discover real-life horror stories, from bizarre crimes to paranormal activity. These true stories are set inside the fictional world of Radio Rental, an 80's video rental shop. This imaginative, cult classic-inspired horror brand blurs the lines of reality, with cutting-edge documentary storytelling and a splash of comedy. From the mind of Payne Lindsey— this is Radio Rental.
Episodes
Mentioned books

6 snips
Oct 31, 2025 • 35min
Episode 94
Prepare for chills with a tale of a late-night encounter with a devil mask that leaves a lasting scare. Dive into the eerie story of a couple facing unsettling phenomena linked to a seemingly innocent dress, creating tension in their relationship. As paranormal activity escalates, they attempt rituals to banish the negativity, leading to a dramatic confrontation. Witness the strange transformation of their home from chaos back to calm after a fiery resolution. Happy Halloween vibes mixed with true stories make for a thrilling listen!

Oct 24, 2025 • 29min
Episode 93
This week features two gripping storytellers. The first shares a chilling night in a Virginia City hotel, where the sounds of miners fighting outside their room blur the lines between past and present. The second recounts a harrowing experience in southern Oregon, where a large, roaring creature stalked them near a cabin, complete with eerie audio proof. Each tale invites listeners to confront their fears of the unknown, leaving you to wonder what truly lurks in the dark.

8 snips
Oct 17, 2025 • 30min
Episode 92
In this captivating installment, the Triangular Craft storyteller shares her 2012 close encounter with a silent UFO, where three orange lights hovered ominously near her home. She later found validation from a fellow eyewitness, providing a thrilling twist. Meanwhile, the Airball storyteller recounts her eerie childhood experience in the Appalachian Mountains, involving a hovering black saucer and a mysterious glowing basketball that compelled her to look up. Both narratives explore themes of fear, disbelief, and the lasting impact of UFO encounters.

7 snips
Oct 10, 2025 • 36min
Episode 91
A scientist shares eerie lab experiences, including a late-night encounter with a mysterious woman in a red sweater. The unsettling history of the wet lab adds to the tension, especially when morgue cabinets come into play. Meanwhile, a group of friends moving into a rental house face bizarre phenomena, from flickering lights to a terrifying, pixelated apparition. The recounting's chilling twist reveals a haunting past tied to the house. Ricky Lee humorously warns against fixer-uppers, urging listeners to trust their instincts about ghostly homes.

15 snips
Oct 3, 2025 • 40min
Episode 90
This episode features chilling accounts narrated by real-life storytellers. One story recounts how a mysterious pair of headlights led rescuers to a long-overdue accident. Another terrifying tale sees a night-shift security guard confronting a distressed man who claims he's being coerced to vomit by three eerie vans. With a mix of suspense and intrigue, these true ghost stories will leave listeners pondering the unknown!

Sep 26, 2025 • 1min
Open for Business in October
Rainn Wilson sets a spooky tone for the season with chilling tales. One gripping story recounts a terrifying encounter with an unearthly presence in a home, highlighting the essence of fear and isolation. Listeners can anticipate new stories dropping every Friday, making it a thrilling addition to their podcast lineup. Wilson encourages fans to embrace the suspense and leave complaints behind as the journey into the unknown begins.

14 snips
Sep 5, 2025 • 27min
Episode 89
Comedian Jeff Foxworthy, renowned for his iconic redneck humor, takes the helm as guest host, bringing his unique perspective to the chilling tales at the rental shop. He delves into the emotional aftermath of a burglary, exploring themes of violation and the quest to reclaim safety. With witty insights, Foxworthy connects laughter to fear, providing levity amidst the dark stories. Additionally, his celestial guidance offers a humorous twist as he navigates the complexities of personal trauma and the importance of healing, making for an enthralling visit.

18 snips
Aug 29, 2025 • 41min
Episode 88
Join Ricky Lee Bagley, an astrological advisor played by Jeff Foxworthy, as he brings cosmic wisdom and humor to this eerie gathering. He presents a week of chilling tales while debating Bigfoot's astrological sign. Meanwhile, Justin Finley narrates his heart-pounding encounter with a large, hairy creature while mountain biking in Oklahoma. Mysterious noises and feelings of being watched add to the tension as these spine-tingling stories merge reality with the supernatural, promising chills and laughs in equal measure.

14 snips
Aug 22, 2025 • 30min
Episode 87
Josh Radnor, known for his iconic role in How I Met Your Mother, takes the reins as a quirky stand-in host. He navigates a mysterious video rental shop filled with real-life scary stories that blend humor with suspense. Listeners are engaged by tales of eerie voicemails and a chaotic traffic stop that reveals unexpected family connections. The conversation shifts to whimsical anecdotes about summer adventures and language learning tips, all while maintaining an undercurrent of thrilling mystery.

27 snips
Aug 15, 2025 • 29min
Episode 86
Discover tales from a mysterious video rental shop that delve into generational curses and family traumas. One story unfolds a haunting legacy marked by tragic deaths. Another recounts an eerie family outing that takes a chilling turn. Meanwhile, the librarian faces her own challenges as she juggles unsettling tales with her quest to find a missing colleague. Expect a mix of humor and horror, along with playful ghostly banter that brings a unique twist to these spine-tingling narratives.


