

Radio Rental
Tenderfoot TV & Audacy
Discover real-life horror stories, from bizarre crimes to paranormal activity. These true stories are set inside the fictional world of Radio Rental, an 80’s video rental store run by an eccentric shopkeeper, Terry Carnation (Rainn Wilson). This imaginative, cult classic-inspired horror brand blurs the lines of reality, with cutting-edge documentary storytelling and a splash of comedy. From the mind of Payne Lindsey, this is Radio Rental.
Episodes
Mentioned books

Aug 29, 2025 • 41min
Episode 88
Join Ricky Lee Bagley, an astrological advisor played by Jeff Foxworthy, as he brings cosmic wisdom and humor to this eerie gathering. He presents a week of chilling tales while debating Bigfoot's astrological sign. Meanwhile, Justin Finley narrates his heart-pounding encounter with a large, hairy creature while mountain biking in Oklahoma. Mysterious noises and feelings of being watched add to the tension as these spine-tingling stories merge reality with the supernatural, promising chills and laughs in equal measure.

9 snips
Aug 22, 2025 • 30min
Episode 87
Josh Radnor, known for his iconic role in How I Met Your Mother, takes the reins as a quirky stand-in host. He navigates a mysterious video rental shop filled with real-life scary stories that blend humor with suspense. Listeners are engaged by tales of eerie voicemails and a chaotic traffic stop that reveals unexpected family connections. The conversation shifts to whimsical anecdotes about summer adventures and language learning tips, all while maintaining an undercurrent of thrilling mystery.

27 snips
Aug 15, 2025 • 29min
Episode 86
Discover tales from a mysterious video rental shop that delve into generational curses and family traumas. One story unfolds a haunting legacy marked by tragic deaths. Another recounts an eerie family outing that takes a chilling turn. Meanwhile, the librarian faces her own challenges as she juggles unsettling tales with her quest to find a missing colleague. Expect a mix of humor and horror, along with playful ghostly banter that brings a unique twist to these spine-tingling narratives.

12 snips
Aug 8, 2025 • 41min
Episode 85
Dive into a chilling collection of true horror stories that unfold in unexpected places. Hear tales of unsettling encounters in remote homes and a haunting photographer's experience at an estate sale. Get spooked by the mystery of a basement that shouldn't have a lock and a photographer confronted by an ominous presence. Amidst the fright, enjoy some quirky hypotheticals and meet a new librarian with a surprising side. It's a thrilling mix of suspense, mystery, and a touch of dark humor.

13 snips
Aug 1, 2025 • 43min
Episode 84
In a peculiar video rental shop, listeners are treated to true scary tales that blur reality and fear. A couple's new friendship leads to a bizarre encounter with missing time, while a gas station visit turns into a nightmarish time loop. Meanwhile, an unexpected former customer hilariously returns to host, adding an odd twist to the narrative. As tales of eerie camping trips and mysterious found phones unfold, the blend of anxiety and humor keeps the atmosphere both chilling and entertaining.

14 snips
Jul 25, 2025 • 40min
Episode 83
Haunted narratives unfold in a mysterious video rental shop, where a family’s peaceful vacation spirals into nightmare amid eerie encounters. A woman discovers the dark side of her aunt's boyfriend while Jeremy, an unsuspecting customer, stumbles into a chilling part-time gig at the store. Tales of tension transform leisurely camping trips into terrifying episodes, and reflections on heartache intertwine with unsettling memories. Dive into personal stories that blend fear, nostalgia, and an unusual mix of lighthearted moments.

4 snips
Jul 18, 2025 • 34min
Episode 82
Tig Notaro, a talented comedian and writer, brings her unique humor to the table as her character, Malachai, navigates the realm of 'Body Horror.' The podcast dives into chilling camping tales, where a group stumbles upon a bizarre campground owner and eerie abandoned amusement park. With laughs and gasps, Notaro also explores the absurdity of relying on mystical healings for warts, blending personal anecdotes with haunting revelations. Her comedic twist makes even the most grotesque stories engaging and entertaining.

11 snips
Jul 11, 2025 • 25min
Episode 81
Dive into eerie tales from a mysterious video shop! Experience the terror of creepy crawlies swarming beneath a dock, and confront the chilling secrets lurking at the bottom of a lake. Meanwhile, Malachi meets a witch who casts a quirky spell, giving him a funny new voice but leaving him without thumbs. The hosts celebrate their new merchandise and reflect on haunting summer camp memories filled with spiders and unexpected lake encounters, blending humor and horror throughout.

7 snips
Jul 4, 2025 • 35min
Episode 80
Dive into chilling true stories from a mysterious video rental shop. A quick pharmacy visit turns surreal as one parent faces eerie silence and disorientation. Meanwhile, a familiar walk becomes a dread-filled journey tangled in bizarre lights and unexplained phenomena. Humor meets horror with an entertaining take on alien encounters, summer fashion, and a massage therapist's curious shenanigans. Experience a rollercoaster of emotions as reality blurs into the supernatural in this spine-tingling collection.

10 snips
Jun 27, 2025 • 37min
Episode 79
Dive into eerie tales from a mystical video rental shop, where a punk band faces chaos at a tattoo parlor, chased by a mysterious vehicle after their unsettling performance. A reckless hike at the Grand Canyon turns into a night of unexpected challenges as friends encounter a peculiar figure from another time. Enjoy humorous anecdotes about childhood chills and a quirky massage therapist who brings levity amidst the spooky narratives. Each story intertwines humor and fear, making for a thrilling, entertaining experience.