

Otherworld
Otherworld
Otherworld tells real stories of people who have experienced something paranormal or unexplainable. Host Jack Wagner takes an open minded and journalistic approach to the subject matter and aims to uncover some of the biggest mysteries of the world and how people react to it.
Episodes
Mentioned books

Aug 7, 2025 • 5min
Rick and Mike [Patreon Preview]
Rick shares a haunting childhood experience involving a UFO sighting with his friend Mike. The story takes a twist as Mike begins to joke about the incident, leading Rick to question his own memories and sanity. Their friendship is tested by this eerie event, blending humor with the tension of the unknown. The conversation dives into the lasting impact of shared mysteries and how playful teasing can unravel trust.

Aug 4, 2025 • 39min
Episode 131: Faceless Face
Karlina's move to a picturesque home in the Ozarks quickly spirals into a nightmare filled with strange knocking sounds and an overwhelming feeling of being watched. The tension escalates when she confronts a faceless figure lurking outside. In an emotional journey, she reflects on her hard upbringing and her mother's strength, intertwining themes of privilege and family. The story delves into the unsettling atmosphere of her new home, leaving listeners questioning the boundaries of reality and the paranormal.

Jul 28, 2025 • 1h 5min
Episode 130: The Void
Liz's unexpected journey into spiritual healing takes a fascinating turn when she enters an otherworldly void. Skepticism gives way to profound emotional revelations, including reconnecting with her deceased mother. The narrative delves deep into the complexities of grief, healing, and the impact of chronic pain. There's also a lighthearted discussion about sleep challenges and even a dog's surprising transformation during mindfulness sessions. It's a blend of mystical experiences and practical advice for enhancing everyday life.

Jul 21, 2025 • 39min
Episode 129: The Kitchen Gnome
In a surreal nighttime encounter, a resident discovers a grumpy, gnome-like figure in their kitchen. The narrative weaves together humor, folklore, and personal experiences from the music industry, exploring childhood superstitions and the fear of the unknown. Listeners are treated to tales of unsettling encounters with mysterious entities, protective folklore, and the emotional aftermath of such unusual experiences. The blend of curiosity and trepidation makes for an intriguing dive into the paranormal.

Jul 14, 2025 • 46min
Deep Research: Tartaria
In this engaging discussion, Joshua Citarella, a contemporary artist and researcher, dives into the enigmatic world of Tartaria, a lost civilization shrouded in conspiracy. He explores its advanced technologies and captivating architecture, challenging mainstream historical narratives. The episode also delves into the connections between Tartarian myths, forgotten inventions like Tesla coils, and the societal effects of conspiracy theories. Citarella emphasizes the importance of addressing social issues to counter these beliefs and invites listeners to rethink their understanding of history.

Jul 7, 2025 • 1h 6min
Episode 128: Patience
Ryan Van Uert, a documentary filmmaker, shares his harrowing experiences while documenting humanitarian efforts in Ukraine. He recounts a close brush with death when mortar fire struck his van during a civilian evacuation. Lost in the woods, Ryan describes feeling a guiding presence that led him to safety. He discusses the impact of fear versus bravery in conflict zones and reflects on the patience developed through his journey, drawing inspiration from memories of loved ones amidst chaos.

Jun 23, 2025 • 1h 14min
Interview with Susannah Cahalan
In this engaging discussion, Susannah Cahalan, an acclaimed journalist and author of works like Brain on Fire, shares her personal journey through severe autoimmune encephalitis. She highlights the chaos of psychosis and the resilience necessary for recovery. Susannah also delves into the lives of Timothy and Rosemary Leary, offering insights into their impact on the psychedelic movement. Throughout, she weaves connections between mental health, creativity, and the exploration of altered states, all while reflecting on the significance of personal experiences in shaping reality.

Jun 16, 2025 • 35min
Episode 127: Cattle Farm Creature
In a small Ohio town, a late-night drive leads to an encounter with a massive, cloaked creature that sparks curiosity and fear. The hosts reflect on their youth spent exploring rural roads, along with eerie visits to the historical Mud House Mansion. They dive into men's emotional struggles, advocating for vulnerability while intertwining thrilling supernatural experiences. Intriguing accounts of bizarre sightings on farm roads challenge perceptions of reality, leaving listeners considering the mysteries lurking in the unknown.

Jun 9, 2025 • 49min
Episode 126: Last Exit
Amy Pallon, a corporate chef from Half Moon Bay, shares an intriguing tale of a vivid dream that eerily predicted a real-life encounter with a dangerous stranger on a desolate road. The discussion dives into themes of intuition and the surreal connections between dreams and reality. Pallon's experience transcends mere coincidence, prompting reflections on how higher consciousness may guide us in perilous situations. The conversation invites listeners to ponder their own uncanny encounters and the mysteries of fate.

Jun 2, 2025 • 40min
Episode 125: The Light of Door County
Join John Murphy, who once experienced a mesmerizing light encounter in Door County, Wisconsin, alongside his then-girlfriend Susan. They share an unforgettable story about being engulfed by a blinding light during a routine drive. As John recounts this surreal experience, he dives into themes of memory confusion and the fear of the unknown. Listeners are pulled into a journey that blurs the lines between reality and the unexplained, leaving them pondering the powerful impact such encounters can have on their lives.


