

The Dollop with Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds
All Things Comedy
Comedians Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds picks a subject from history and examine it.
Episodes
Mentioned books

Dec 19, 2025 • 1h 9min
155 - The Past Times with Josh Androsky
In this engaging discussion, comedian and writer Josh Androsky shares his experiences in comedy and research, promoting his comic, Year Zero. The trio hilariously debates hard-boiled versus runny eggs after diving into a wacky 1938 court case about a husband's egg demand. They riff on historical figures like Ulysses S. Grant and explore curious tales, including a couple living like animals in the mountains. With plenty of absurd humor and insightful banter, the conversation weaves through both lighthearted and serious topics.

24 snips
Dec 16, 2025 • 1h 28min
713 - HenryHudson - part two
Dive into the wild world of Henry Hudson, where gnome legends meet crew mutinies! Explore Hudson's dubious decision to return to England and the shocking thefts aboard his ship. Tensions rise as the crew battles starvation, fights for survival, and indulges in questionable meals like frogs and moss. The drama escalates with a mutiny that leaves Hudson and his loyalists stranded. Discover the legacy of Hudson's maps that fueled colonization, all wrapped in humor and unexpected twists.

Dec 12, 2025 • 1h 9min
154 -The Past Times with Francesca Fiorentini
Francesca Fiorentini, a dynamic journalist and host of The Bitchuation Room, joins the hosts for a lively discussion. She shares her fascinating experiences with media bookings, including her time on Piers Morgan. The conversation includes amusing stories, like a skunk shipped as an 'explosive' and wives filming drunk husbands for shaming. They also explore zany historical anecdotes, from a 'wild man' attacking beachgoers to a taxidermied owl gracing a mayor’s desk. The banter is sharp, and laughter is guaranteed!

11 snips
Dec 9, 2025 • 1h 14min
712 - Henry Hudson - part one
Comedians delve into the life of explorer Henry Hudson, tracing his humble beginnings and rise from cabin boy to captain. They discuss his confusing routes and the fears of mutiny among his crew, showcasing his struggles with leadership. The tale includes Hudson's obsession with finding new passages and his deceptive tactics to keep morale high. Sailors' ridiculous mermaid sightings and Hudson mapping the future river that bears his name add humor to their narrative. Their exploration also touches on the dark sides of trade and indigenous encounters.

9 snips
Dec 5, 2025 • 58min
153- The Past Times with Marc Maron
Stand-up comedian and podcaster Marc Maron joins the fun for a wild ride through quirky history. They dive into a hilarious 1930 courtroom saga involving a drunken driving mischief-maker, and a smallpox placard scam that leads to unexpected twists. The trio explores outrageous tree-sitting competitions and the absurdity of adult pole-sitting challenges with their sanitation woes. A ludicrous duel in Mexico City reveals just how far chaos can go. It's a charming mix of humor and oddball history that keeps everyone in stitches.

Dec 2, 2025 • 1h 39min
711 - Early Baseball Mascots
Dive into the quirky world of early baseball mascots! Discover how the term 'mascotte' emerged from a French opera and led to the rise of animal and boy mascots. Enjoy tales of unique creatures and kids who served as lucky charms, and the seriousness with which teams treated these figures. Hear about Ulysses Harrison, a mascot caught in racial dynamics, and the superstitions surrounding players like Ty Cobb. With discussions on exploitation and the evolution of mascots, this journey reveals the bizarre and often heartfelt side of baseball's history.

10 snips
Nov 21, 2025 • 1h 23min
152 - The Past Times with Knowledge Fight
Dan Friesen and Jordan Holmes, co-hosts of the Knowledge Fight podcast, join the fun with hosts Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds. They dive into bizarre historical newspaper stories, from a man attempting to float by inflating his body to a ghost sighting that captures community intrigue. The group tackles an absurd devil-summoning manual and debates a strange pigeon murder, all while weaving in humor about 1896 life. Their comedic commentary reflects on the oddities of both past and present, making for an entertaining retrospective.

Nov 18, 2025 • 1h 33min
710 - Johnny Appleseed - live
Comedians explore the quirky life of Johnny Appleseed, who was not just a planter of trees but a fervent advocate of Swedenborgian beliefs. They delve into his unique planting style and his role in supplying cider for frontier festivities. From his barefoot lifestyle and eccentric attire to his compassion for animals, Johnny's character shines through. His relationships with settlers and Native Americans, along with tales of his midnight heroics during the War of 1812, paint a complex picture of this legendary figure.

Nov 14, 2025 • 1h 14min
151 - The Past Times with Jenny Tian
Jenny Tian, a comedian and touring performer, discusses her experiences performing at the iconic Sydney Opera House versus a tent in Adelaide. The trio dives into amusing stories from an 1891 newspaper, including a humorous editorial about pigs disturbing a newsroom and a bizarre foot race for a bride. They also explore cheese culture in Wisconsin, compare food norms in the U.S. and Australia, and touch on unusual historical fads like thumb ring fashion among men. Get ready for laughs and a trip down memory lane!

9 snips
Nov 11, 2025 • 1h 25min
709 - Butter vs Margarine - live
Discover the hilarious history of butter vs. margarine in Wisconsin! From Napoleon's search for butter substitutes to the absurd color laws that mandated pink margarine, this tale is ripe with political battles and moral panics. Explore how propaganda painted margarine as a villain, leading to bizarre court rulings and black market trading. Unravel the strange alliances, celebrity endorsements, and the lasting effects of the margarine wars on food politics and state identity. It's a culinary showdown you didn't know you needed!


