

The Dollop with Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds
All Things Comedy
Comedians Dave Anthony and Gareth Reynolds picks a subject from history and examine it.
Episodes
Mentioned books

Nov 18, 2025 • 1h 33min
710 - Johnny Appleseed - live
Comedians explore the quirky life of Johnny Appleseed, who was not just a planter of trees but a fervent advocate of Swedenborgian beliefs. They delve into his unique planting style and his role in supplying cider for frontier festivities. From his barefoot lifestyle and eccentric attire to his compassion for animals, Johnny's character shines through. His relationships with settlers and Native Americans, along with tales of his midnight heroics during the War of 1812, paint a complex picture of this legendary figure.

Nov 14, 2025 • 1h 14min
151 - The Past Times with Jenny Tian
Jenny Tian, a comedian and touring performer, discusses her experiences performing at the iconic Sydney Opera House versus a tent in Adelaide. The trio dives into amusing stories from an 1891 newspaper, including a humorous editorial about pigs disturbing a newsroom and a bizarre foot race for a bride. They also explore cheese culture in Wisconsin, compare food norms in the U.S. and Australia, and touch on unusual historical fads like thumb ring fashion among men. Get ready for laughs and a trip down memory lane!

9 snips
Nov 11, 2025 • 1h 25min
709 - Butter vs Margarine - live
Discover the hilarious history of butter vs. margarine in Wisconsin! From Napoleon's search for butter substitutes to the absurd color laws that mandated pink margarine, this tale is ripe with political battles and moral panics. Explore how propaganda painted margarine as a villain, leading to bizarre court rulings and black market trading. Unravel the strange alliances, celebrity endorsements, and the lasting effects of the margarine wars on food politics and state identity. It's a culinary showdown you didn't know you needed!

Nov 7, 2025 • 1h 4min
150 - The Past Times with Mike Bridenstine
Stand-up comedian Mike Bridenstine shares wild stories from his new book, Kansas City Comedy, revealing shocking anecdotes like a fake FBI sting and a performer feigning paralysis. He recounts a chaotic open-mic night involving a rotting possum and a vacuum. The hosts dig into quirky news from 1927, including an alderman's kiss with a robber. From a Colorado ruling on drinking at home to a bizarre Oklahoma biscuit bill, the conversation is filled with humor and absurdity. They also discuss the humor in modern theater and share heartwarming tales like a 93-year-old's second marriage.

Nov 4, 2025 • 1h 49min
708 - Joh Bjelke-Petersen - live with Damien Power and Chris Ryan
Damien Power, an Australian comedian and podcaster, joins the discussion to dive into the life of Joh Bjelke-Petersen, who rose from humble beginnings to become Queensland's controversial premier. They humorously explore Bjelke-Petersen's peculiar moral crusades, his manipulation of police and politics, and notorious propaganda strategies like 'The Joe Show.' The conversation touches on scandalous allegations of corruption, authoritarian tactics, and the chaotic fallout of his regime, leaving listeners both entertained and enlightened about this complex figure.

Oct 31, 2025 • 1h 1min
149 - The Past Times with Matt Cobos
Joining the conversation is Matt Cobos, a stand-up comedian and podcaster known for Kobo's Patrick Podcast. The trio dives into humorous historical newspaper articles from 1925, laughing over courtroom antics, bizarre legal disputes, and culinary fads like boiling salad dressing. They banter about a near-naked man found in a barn and a young boy's wild runaway adventure. The hosts also riff on the absurdity of moral panics over dancing and exaggerated obituary tales, keeping the humor lively throughout.

4 snips
Oct 28, 2025 • 1h 40min
707 - Mike Lindell - part 2
Dave and Gareth dive into the wild journey of Mike Lindell, from his obsession with pillows to hitting rock bottom due to addiction. They explore how gambling funded his early pillow production and led to both business triumphs at state fairs and devastating financial losses. Lindell's transformation from a success story to a controversial figure deeply entwined in political claims and legal battles is dissected. The hosts also critique his media ventures and the strange legitimacy bestowed upon his platforms by unexpected endorsements.

Oct 24, 2025 • 1h 6min
148 - The Past Times with Ariel Elias
Ariel Elias, a vibrant stand-up comedian with a special titled 'A Jewish Star', joins the fun to dive into a historical newspaper. She shares a hilarious story about a beer thrown at her during a gig, and the trio explores quirky tales from 1893, including explosive fishing antics and a wild wedding among circus performers. They laugh over a local lawn party mishap and an absurd baseball game, while also discussing an unusual burial stunt. Ariel's comedic insights add a delightful twist to these bizarre historical snippets.

Oct 21, 2025 • 1h 21min
706 - Mike Lindell - Part One
Dive into the turbulent life of Mike Lindell, starting from his quirky trailer park childhood and struggles with social anxiety. Explore his wild transition from friendly bets to serious gambling debts, mob threats, and his subsequent run-ins with the law. Witness his chaotic attempts at recovery, issues with substance abuse, and the unexpected inspiration that led to his pillow invention. The hosts reflect on Lindell's current public persona, revealing the contradictions in his self-narrative and the challenges he continues to face.

Oct 17, 2025 • 1h 10min
147 - The Past Times with Alex Pearlman
Comedian Alex Pearlman, known for his viral political videos and co-hosting the Too Many Tabs podcast, joins to dive into quirky historical newspaper tales. The trio explores the bizarre account of American airmen freed from China, and a strange Toledo story about jury selection through pedestrian grabs. They also discuss an intriguing proposal to paint LA streets pastel for aesthetic and climate benefits. With humor at every turn, Alex shares insights on his rise in social media and his stand-up journey.


