Church History Matters

Discover the tumultuous journey of Zion's Camp and the forced exodus of church members from Missouri. Delve into the complex dynamics of violence and faith within the Latter-day Saints community. Unravel the trials faced by members, including internal conflicts and divine revelations during their march. Explore how 19th-century church members interpreted the Civil War as a prophetic fulfillment and the moral implications of their actions. Ultimately, reflect on the sacrifices and spiritual lessons from this pivotal period, emphasizing peace amidst chaos.

The podcast delves into the tumultuous settling of Latter-day Saints in 19th-century Missouri. It highlights the immediate tensions and escalating violence they faced from local residents beginning in 1831. Eyewitness accounts of the violent expulsion in 1833 capture the fear and chaos experienced by families. The discussion also touches on theological dilemmas around self-defense versus non-retaliation, and the community's resilience while striving for peace amidst persecution. Revelations received by church leaders in response to this turmoil are also examined.

The discussion kicks off with Jon Krakauer's provocative book, suggesting that religion is inherently violent. It then delves into the complex history of Latter-day Saints, addressing themes of peace amid violence. A critical look at the adaptation of Krakauer's work raises questions about historical accuracy. The tragic Lafferty case highlights the dangers of generalizing faith and violence. Lastly, it explores the early persecution faced by Joseph Smith, illuminating the struggles and resilience of a faith community under attack.

Dr. Christopher Blythe, an assistant professor of English at Brigham Young University and an expert on Latter-day Saint literature, dives deep into the nuances of divine guidance across various Restoration branches. He explores how the Henrickites and Cutlerites honor the Book of Mormon, challenging the belief that only The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has God's notice. The conversation highlights personal faith experiences, emphasizing that sincere belief can connect individuals to God, regardless of church affiliation.

Brian Hales, an expert in Mormon fundamentalism, shares insights about its intriguing history and key figures. He discusses the impact of early church manifestos on plural marriage and the emergence of dissenting groups. Hales delves into the complex relationship between mainstream Latter-day Saints and fundamentalist sects, exploring the pivotal 1886 revelation on marriage. The conversation also touches on the struggle against government pressures and ongoing practices of polygamy among certain factions, offering a nuanced view of a movement that defies conventional boundaries.

Andrew Bolton, a member of the Community of Christ and former Council of Twelve Apostles member, dives deep into the church's unique leadership succession. He discusses the transformative 1860 moment when Joseph Smith III was ordained, contrasting its governance with that of the Utah-based church. The conversation explores evolving roles, including the potential for female leadership and volunteer ministers, while also examining historical trauma and scriptural interpretations, such as LGBTQ inclusion and the significance of communal practices.

Josh Gehly, an ordained Evangelist in The Church of Jesus Christ, delves into the Bickertonite Movement and its roots in early church history. He discusses Sidney Rigdon's claim to leadership following the deaths of Joseph and Hyrum Smith, highlighting his establishment of a separate church in Pittsburgh. Gehly also explores the church's global outreach, leadership structure, and unique ordinances like foot washing. The conversation reveals the commitment to diversity and evolving practices that define the Bickertonites today.

In this engaging discussion, Dr. Kyle Beshears, a specialist in the LDS Strangite Movement, unpacks the perplexing legacy of James J. Strang. He explores Strang's magnetic yet controversial leadership, contrasting his initial resistance to polygamy with Brigham Young’s approach. The significance of the Vori plates in supporting prophetic claims is examined, as well as the mysterious Kinderhook plates and their disputed authenticity. Dr. Beshears also highlights Strang’s establishment of the Halcyon Order and the enduring impact of his movement on Latter-day Saint history.

After the 1844 succession crisis, not all Latter-day Saints followed Brigham Young, leading to the formation of diverse groups. The podcast dives into the Strangites, Josephites, and Bickertonites, exploring their unique leadership and theological differences. Strang's controversial reign and the challenges of leadership succession created turbulence within these movements. Listeners will learn about the historical context of these branches and the complexities of their evolution over the past 180 years.

Dr. Daniel C. Peterson, an expert on apostolic succession, tackles the intriguing question of what would happen if all Church leaders died at once. He explores how authority might shift and the potential loss of keys to the kingdom. The conversation dives into the process of calling apostles and whether personal witness of Christ is necessary for apostleship. With historical context and hypothetical scenarios, Peterson reveals the complexities and nuances surrounding Church governance and the importance of strong arguments in faith.