The Opinions

David French, a political commentator focused on law and culture, joins Jamelle Bouie, a New York Times columnist with sharp insights into foreign policy. They discuss Trump’s military actions against Iran, unraveling the blend of legality and presidential power. The duo critiques Congress’s role in war declarations, highlighting the historical erosion of these protocols. They also analyze the complex motivations behind Trump's foreign policy, suggesting ambition often trumps strategy in his decision-making.

In a fiery discussion, Bret Stephens, an opinion columnist, advocates for U.S. military action against Iran, believing it may force the regime to reconsider its stance. Meanwhile, Rosemary Kelanic, director of the Middle East program at Defense Priorities, cautions against such strikes, warning of the repercussions for regional stability and Iran's nuclear ambitions. They delve into contrasting perceptions of the Iranian threat, explore intelligence discrepancies, and propose alternative diplomatic strategies to address U.S.-Iran relations.

Nick Kristof, a New York Times columnist and seasoned Iran observer, discusses the precarious aftermath of the U.S. bombing of Iran. He warns that Trump’s optimism might be misplaced, as Iran has its own agenda. The conversation dives into Iran's potential retaliation and its effects on regional stability, particularly around critical locations like the Strait of Hormuz. Kristof also sheds light on the complex feelings of everyday Iranians towards both their government and Americans, illustrating the divide between regime rhetoric and civilian sentiment.

Jamelle Bouie, a political and cultural commentator for the New York Times, joins fellow columnist David French to dissect the evolving dynamics of Trump's immigration strategy and its impact on his support base. They explore how public perception of ICE raids has soured, potentially alienating voters. The discussion shifts to the divisive nature of rhetoric in politics, the implications for Democrats in redefining their approach, and the structural challenges that hinder effective governance. This thought-provoking conversation unpacks the complexities of today's political landscape.

Tom Friedman, a renowned New York Times columnist known for his insights on foreign affairs, shares his perspective on the escalating tensions between Iran and Israel. He discusses the complex military goals of Israel regarding Iran and warns against the chaos that could arise from regime change. The conversation highlights contrasting strategies and internal divisions within Iran, analyzing how these factors influence U.S. policy and regional stability. Friedman advocates for diplomacy as a key element in addressing Iran’s nuclear ambitions.

Arlie Russell Hochschild, an esteemed sociologist known for her insights into the Great Paradox, discusses the enduring support for Trump among Appalachia voters despite broken promises. She delves into the socio-economic changes in Eastern Kentucky's 5th congressional district, capturing the emotional turmoil of its residents amid the decline of the coal industry. Hochschild highlights how political narratives manipulate feelings of loss, and the challenges both parties face in reconnecting with these voters, underlining the need for respectful communication in today's political landscape.

In this engaging conversation, opinion columnists David French and Tressie McMillan Cottom delve into the recent protests in Los Angeles, examining President Trump's deployment of military forces and its implications for civil liberties. They discuss the manipulation of political power and the historical significance of civil disobedience in face of escalating state control. With insights on upcoming legislation affecting AI regulation and education, the dialogue highlights the challenges to democracy and social safety nets amid a politically charged environment.

Liat Beinin Atzili, a Holocaust educator and former hostage in Gaza, shares her harrowing experience of being held for 54 days after a traumatic abduction. She discusses the deep emotional journey of coping with grief following her husband's murder, emphasizing her choice to reject revenge. Liat reflects on the bonds formed during captivity and her commitment to dialogue through the Parents Circle, promoting peace between Palestinians and Israelis. Her story highlights resilience, the complexities of grief, and the quest for hope amid conflict.

Masha Gessen, a renowned columnist for The New York Times, delves into the human tendency to seek normalcy amid chaos. They discuss the unsettling parallels between autocracy in Russia and rising authoritarianism in the U.S., emphasizing the dangers of desensitization to political repression. Gessen highlights innovative strategies needed to confront authoritarianism and the importance of maintaining optimism in political leadership. The conversation urges vigilance and active engagement to protect democracy against creeping tyranny.

Megan Stack, a contributing opinion writer for The New York Times and former Moscow bureau chief for The Los Angeles Times, shares her insights on the ongoing conflict in Ukraine. She discusses the grim realities of the war and the challenges in negotiating peace between Ukraine and Russia. The conversation also delves into how the situation reflects broader shifts in global power dynamics and U.S. foreign policy. Stack highlights the complexities of Russian leadership and the pressing need for ethical considerations regarding military support.