MinistryWatch Podcast

On today’s MinistryWatch EXTRA episode, Warren Smith shares a review he wrote for “The Dispatch” of Megan Basham’s new book Shepherds For Sale: How Evangelical Leaders Traded The Truth for a Leftist Agenda. The fundamental flaw of the book is that it fails to note that the real problem in evangelicalism is that pastors have succumbed to the populist right in far greater numbers than they have to the progressive left, and the consequences for the Gospel and the purity of the church have been far more consequential. Warren unpacks these ideas in this week’s EXTRA episode. To read the complete article, in The Dispatch, click here. The producer of today’s episode is Jeff McIntosh. Until next time, may God bless you.

On today’s program, Liberty University reaches a settlement with former president Jerry Falwell Jr. after years of back-and-forth lawsuits between the two parties. Now, they say they are putting the past behind them. We’ll have details. A small university in North Carolina is beating the odds…while other Christian colleges face closure, this school is thriving. We take a look at what they’re doing. Also, Steven Furtick’s Elevation Church released its annual report—the Charlotte-area church saw revenue of more than $108-million in 2023. The leadership at Gateway Church continues its shakeup following revelations that its founding pastor Robert Morris abused a minor in the 1980s. The producer for today’s program is Jeff McIntosh.  We get database and other technical support from Stephen DuBarry, Rod Pitzer, and Casey Sudduth. Writers who contributed to today’s program include Jessica Eturralde, Kim Roberts, Shannon Cuthrell, Yonat Shimron, Brittany Smith, and Christina Darnell. Until next time, may God bless you.   COMPLETE MANUSCRIPT BELOW:   FIRST SEGMENT Warren: Hello everybody. I’m Warren Smith, coming to you from Charlotte, North Carolina. Natasha: And I’m Natasha Cowden, coming to you from Denver, Colorado. And we’d like to welcome you to the MinistryWatch podcast. Warren: On today’s program, Liberty University reaches a settlement with former president Jerry Falwell Jr. after years of back-and-forth lawsuits between the two parties. Now, they say they are putting the past behind them. We’ll have details. And, a small university in North Carolina is beating the odds…while other Christian colleges face closure, this school is thriving. We take a look at what they’re doing. Also, Steven Furtick’s Elevation Church released its annual report—the Charlotte-area church saw revenue of more than $108-million in 2023. Natasha: But first, the leadership at Gateway Church continues its shakeup following revelations that its founding pastor Robert Morris abused a minor in the 1980s. Warren: Seven weeks after Robert Morris resigned from Gateway Church after Cindy Clemishire publicly claimed he abused her when she was 12 years old, Gateway has announced that Morris’ son, James Morris, is stepping away from the church. James Morris was slated to take over church leadership after his father’s impending retirement in 2025. But after Clemishire’s claims went public, Robert Morris admitted “moral failure” with a “young lady” before resigning as the Texas megachurch’s lead pastor. Weeks later, James Morris and three other elders announced they would temporarily step down to allow room for a third-party investigation. But last week, in a special announcement to the congregation, Gateway elder Tra Willbanks announced that James Morris and his wife, Bridgette Morris, had decided to permanently relinquish their positions at Gateway. Natasha:  How did the congregation take that? Warren: Church attendees gave them a standing ovation. Then Willbanks said Gateway elders support James and Bridgette Morris’ desire to establish a church in the future. I should mention that James and Bridgette Morris are not the only ones to have left in the fallout of Robert Morris’ resignation. According to the leadership pages on its website, Gateway has made additional changes to its staff and elder board. It removed former-felon-turned-Prison Ministry Campus Pastor Stephen Wilson after Wilson’s past sex charges from 2002 involving a minor became public. Natasha: Who is going to minister as the church moves forward? Warren: Willbanks informed congregants that Max Lucado, a popular author and teaching minister at Oak Hills Church in San Antonio, and Swedish pastor Joakim Lundqvist, will be filling leadership roles at the church. Lucado will become the interim teaching pastor, preaching at Gateway about twice a month. Lundqvist will share preaching duties with Lucado and take on a pastoral role with staff. Natasha: Next, a Texas Pastor has stepped down due to “inappropriate” conduct, without being specific about the concerns. Warren: On Sunday, July 28, Cross Timbers Church in Argyle, about 30 miles north of Fort Worth, announced that its lead pastor Josiah Anthony would resign due to “inappropriate and hurtful” actions, WFAA reported. The church clarified on Monday that the conduct “does not include any children, physical or sexual interactions or any illegal activity to our knowledge.” Apparently, the church elders asked Anthony to resign and he agreed. Natasha: Is there any hint as to why he resigned? Warren: During the service, Cross Timbers elder John Chalk read a statement about Anthony’s resignation. “Josiah has been in a prolonged and sustained season of struggle with his emotional and mental health which has been very painful for him and those around him,Throughout this struggle, some of Josiah’s decisions and actions were inappropriate and hurtful to current and former members of the [Cross Timbers] family and staff.” Natasha: Who will fill Anthony’s roll as pastor? Warren: Byron Copeland will serve as interim lead pastor. Before taking a position of executive pastor at Cross Timbers, Copeland worked at nearby Gateway Church. Natasha: There have been quite a few situations like this lately, one of course being the Morris story we just discussed what are some others? Warren: On July 7, Stonebriar Community Church, founded by Chuck Swindoll, dismissed former Associate Pastor Tony Cammarota, who “confessed to church leadership of a moral failure” according to an email obtained by the Dallas Morning News. Stonebriar did not provide details of the moral failure. In June, well-known Dallas megachurch pastor Tony Evans stepped away from leading Oak Cliff Bible Fellowship due to “sin” he committed years ago. Evans, 74, was not specific about his actions but said they were not criminal. He will be “submitting to a healing and restoration process established by the elders.” Natasha: Next, the latest between Liberty University and Jerry Falwell Jr. Warren: Liberty University and its former president Jerry Falwell Jr. have reached an agreement to settle all outstanding disputes and lawsuits between the two parties. While specifics of the agreement were not released, the statement said the two reached a mutual understanding about the retirement and severance Liberty will pay to Falwell. In March 2023, Falwell sued the university for $8.5 million in retirement benefits he claimed they owed him. The agreement also authorizes Liberty to use the name, image, and likeness of its founder, Jerry Falwell Sr. Natasha: There’s been a lot going on between the two- can you remind us of some of the recent history here. Warren: Last July, Falwell Jr. sued the university, accusing it of misappropriating “for itself” the name and image of Falwell Sr., the conservative Christian evangelist who co-founded the evangelical university in 1971. In September, Falwell Jr. amended his complaint against Liberty, claiming the university’s board overlooked sexual misconduct by former leaders, including an unnamed former president, only to turn on Falwell Jr. when his life fell apart. Following allegations that he and his wife had a years-long sexual relationship with a business associate, Falwell Jr. resigned from his post as Liberty’s president in August 2020. Neither Falwell nor the university plan to answer any further questions about the settlement. In the MinistryWatch database, Liberty University has a 2-star financial efficiency rating, a C transparency grade, and a donor confidence score of only 34, meaning donors should withhold giving. Natasha: Warren, let’s take a quick break. When we return, the rise of Carolina University—how a 79-year-old institution rebooted itself. I’m Natasha Cowden, along with my co-host Warren Smith, and we’ll have that story and much more, after this short break.   BREAK   SECOND SEGMENT Natasha: Welcome back.  I’m Natasha Cowden, along with my co-host Warren Smith, and you’re listening to the MinistryWatch podcast. Next, the story we promised before the break, while many Christian colleges are failing, one small school in North Carolina appears to be beating the odds. Warren: A 79-year-old private institution in North Carolina appears to be an anomaly to the many Christian colleges forced to close recently. Carolina University’s enrollment has surged 29% this year, rising from 826 to 1,068 students. Its multilingual offerings and global recruitment have attracted scores of international students, who now make up about half of the student body. The university is also seeing success with its new career-oriented programs, including master’s degrees in data science and innovation, along with undergrad courses covering machine learning, artificial intelligence, esports and cybersecurity. Natasha: How’d they get to this place? Warren: Our full story goes into detail about their financial turn around but beyond that they’ve also had years of steady enrollment growth With long history of mergers. Since its founding in 1945, the school has absorbed seven colleges headed by Methodists, Moravians, Baptists, Anglicans, and Mennonites. Each merger brought a surge in students, faculty/staff, flagship programs, and financial resources, enabling Carolina University to sell campuses for far more than the obligations owed. Natasha: The school also focuses on what they call “Jobs of the Future” Warren: Years ago, the school made the call to only offer new degrees leading to a stable job market and high-paying salaries. Focusing on degrees that lead to jobs starting at $100,000 a year. The school is already seeing success with this strategy, with data science rising the ranks as its fastest-growing program. Other longstanding programs, such as engineering and business, also maintain strong enrollment. Carolina University’s legacy theology programs aren’t slowing down either. President Petitt said, “We’re training more pastors right now than we have at any other time in our history, even when we were a Bible college.” Natasha: That’s amazing! What are their goals for the future? Warren: They hope to expand enrollment to 1,500 over the next academic year. Their long-term target is 7,000 main-campus students and 70,000 online. Natasha: Next, a Historic Miami Church saved From Foreclosure Warren: Nearly a year ago, MinistryWatch reported that one of Miami’s oldest black churches had just weeks to repay a $1.6-million mortgage that its former pastor had taken out in the church’s name. St. John Institutional Missionary Baptist Church in Miami’s Overtown neighborhood, has roots dating back to 1906. But last year, the church announced that parts of the historic church could “close forever” unless they were to raise enough money to pay off a mountain of debt incurred under its former pastor. Natasha: So what changed things? Warren: Three days before the church’s historic property was to be sold in foreclosure, the Southeast Overtown/Park West Community Redevelopment Agency (SEOPW CRA) purchased it, allowing the loan to be paid off and granting repurchase rights to the church. The CRA secured the auxiliary buildings, parking area, and fellowship hall roughly 72 hours before the property’s scheduled auction. The agreement allowed the church to lease those buildings for $1 each year. St. John’s Baptist Church, according to the city’s historic preservation website, is one of the only Art Deco-style religious buildings in Miami-Dade County and a rare example of the style in Overtown, the heart of Miami’s historic African-American community. Natasha: Our next story comes from my home state of Colorado. Warren: The Rock church in Castle Rock, Colo., succeeded in obtaining a preliminary injunction that will allow it to operate an “on-site temporary shelter ministry” consistent with its religious beliefs. On July 19, U.S. District Judge Daniel Domenico issued the preliminary injunction in favor of the church after the city charged the church with zoning violations because the temporary shelters were not an allowed use. According to court documents, two shelters, a trailer, and an RV are parked over 400 feet from the neighboring residential areas and have been used as temporary shelters since 2018. Natasha: How did the decision come down? Warren: The court found The Rock was entitled to an injunction because of the protection afforded it under the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA), which prohibits a city from enforcing land use regulations in a way that impose a “substantial burden” on the religious exercise of a church. During the time that The Rock has been prohibited from using its temporary shelters, it has had to turn away homeless families in need.  On the contrary, “The [t]own has not argued at this time that it would suffer any actual, material harm by allowing families to stay in the [c]hurch’s two mobile homes,” the order reads. The church noted—and the city did not dispute—that it “has never experienced any public-safety or other related issues while carrying out this ministry, even as it has temporarily housed numerous individuals and small families.” Natasha: Next, the latest for the Church of the Nazarenes Warren: A Church of the Nazarene court has found one of its most prominent theologians guilty of affirming and advocating for the approval and inclusion of members who openly identify as LGBTQ, contrary to the church’s teachings. After delivering the verdict on Saturday evening (July 28) against the Rev. Thomas Jay Oord of Nampa, Idaho, the court stripped Oord of his preaching credentials and expelled him from membership in the 2.5-million-member global denomination. Natasha: Can you explain why Oord was expelled? Warren: In its decision, the church court cited a book Oord wrote with his daughter Alexa Oord, who identifies herself as bisexual, titled, “Why the Church of the Nazarene Should Be Fully LGBTQ+ Affirming,” in which they affirm gay sex, which the court found particularly egregious. The court also objected to Oord’s behavior in defying church rules, including multiple requests that he either quit advocating for approval of LGBTQ lifestyles or give up his preaching credentials. Oord now directs doctor of ministry students at Northwind Theological Seminary, an online-only school that is not affiliated with the Church of the Nazarene. He will be able to keep his job, but he will no longer be allowed to publish with the Nazarene-owned publishing house, the Foundry, or preach or hold membership in any of its churches. Natasha: Warren, we’re going to take another break.  When we return, our lightning round of ministry news of the week. I’m Natasha Cowden, with my co-host Warren Smith. More in a moment.   BREAK   THIRD SEGMENT Natasha: Welcome back.  I’m Natasha Cowden, with my co-host Warren Smith and you’re listening to the MinistryWatch podcast. Warren, we like to use this last segment as a sort of lightning round of shorter news briefs. What’s up first? Warren: Elevation Church, the megachurch based in Charlotte, North Carolina, and led by Steven Furtick, took in over $100 million in tithes and offerings in 2023, according to its Annual Report. In its financial breakdown for 2023, the church reported that the largest portion of the revenue —34% or $34 million—went to personnel expenses. Central operations and ministries was the second highest category for expenditures at 25%. Another $13 million went toward outreach efforts. Elevation Church reported a weekly in-person attendance of 17,091, an increase of 21% from the previous year. According to its website, Elevation Church has 19 locations, as well as online streaming. According to the Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability (ECFA), of which Elevation Church is a member, the church had assets totaling $319 million at the end of Fiscal Year 2023. Net assets increased by $41 million from the previous year. Last July, Elevation Church separated from the Southern Baptist Convention. While it gave no specific reason for the departure, the letter sent to the denomination stated, “You will find that our Statement of Beliefs on our website is very much in line with the Baptist Faith and Message — we have no intention of changing those core beliefs.” Natasha: What’s next? Warren: In June, the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA) General Assembly voted to investigate the teachings of the best-selling book “Jesus Calling,” written by the late author Sarah Young. Now, the pastor who originally sent the overture to the General Assembly is transferring his membership to another denomination, but The PCA maintains that the overture is still valid. Teaching Elder Benjamin Inman was a pastor in the PCA for 24 years, but has now transferred his credentials to the Reformed Presbyterian Church of North America (RPCNA). Natasha: What was the overture? Warren: The amended overture requested reports from Mission to the World and the Committee on Discipleship Ministries (CDM) concerning their relationship with the book and its author, the reasons it was removed from CDM inventory, and “assess[ing] the book’s appropriateness for Christians in general and PCA members and congregations in particular with special regard for its doctrine and method.” In a statement provided to byFaith, Inman explained his reasoning behind the overture: “The ‘Jesus Calling’ overture was purely an act of repentance for my failure to pursue the issue in 2013. I learned in 2023 that the book had sold 42 million copies, and I was ashamed of my inaction. I’m encouraged that my delinquent and meager attempt has been taken up by the General Assembly.” Before her death, Young was a member of the PCA and had a degree from the denominational seminary, Covenant Theological Seminary in St. Louis. She and her husband Steve were Mission to the World missionaries in Japan and Australia. Natasha: Who is in our Ministry Spotlight this week? Warren: Childcare Worldwide’s Donor Confidence Score recently dropped from a 90 to an 85, still ranking it in the “Give with Confidence” designation. It also now has a 1-star efficiency rating. The organization, founded in 1981, is based in Lynden, Wash. It is a sponsorship organization that supports children in Africa, Asia, and South America. Their Life Centers are community centers that provide medical care, education, food and clean water, and school supplies. The organization ranks 88th out of 92 for Fund Acquisition within the Relief and Development sector and has a 1-star rating. In 2020, 12% of Childcare Worldwide’s expenses were spent on fundraising, and in 2023 the amount jumped to 20%. The sector median is 6%. Childcare Worldwide’s Resource Allocation ranking is also 1-star. In order to have a high score in the Resource Allocation Rating category, MinistryWatch requires organizations to have 80-85% of its funding go towards programming. Currently, Childcare Worldwide only spends about 70% of its expenses on programming. In 2023, the organization’s total revenue was $3.3 million and its total expenses were $4 million. It also has $1.1 million in net assets. Natasha: And who did Christina highlight in her roundup of Ministries Making a Difference? Warren: A ‘Network Member’ in Thailand partnered with Atlas Free, an anti-trafficking nonprofit, to offer a free baking class in the red light district for women in the sex trade. Because of the class, 30 survivors were impacted, one of whom went on to open her own business. Atlas Free has 5 stars, an “A” transparency grade, and a donor confidence score of 100 in the MinistryWatch database—the highest ratings in each category. After learning their Colorado community had no support group for young mothers and their children, women from a local church started one of their own. Thanks to local grants and funds from a Blessing Our Community initiative, Cortez Church of the Nazarene provides childcare twice a month while inviting moms to enjoy snacks, coffee, door prizes, community and mentorship. Davar Audio Bibles is recording a full audio Bible in Azeri, the official language of Azerbaijan. It will be the ministry’s first audio Bible for the Muslim-majority country of over 10 million, located along the border between West Asia and Eastern Europe. Davar Audio Bibles has 3 stars and an “A” transparency grade in the MinistryWatch database, and a donor confidence score of 97. Hand2Hand pairs churches in West Michigan with local schools to pray for students and pack and deliver food on weekends. This school year, it is partnering with 145 churches to serve 45 school districts. It also operates a store that sells wholesale food at reduced cost for community partners. The ministry estimates the store has saved partners more than $150,000 since it opened last fall. Hand2Hand has 3 stars and an “A” transparency grade in the MinistryWatch database, and a donor confidence score of 100. Natasha: Warren, any final thoughts before we go? Warren: Ad lib:  California, Colorado, New Mexico Shepherds for Sale — Dispatch Natasha: The producer for today’s program is Jeff McIntosh.  We get database and other technical support from Stephen DuBarry, Rod Pitzer, and Casey Sudduth. Writers who contributed to today’s program include Jessica Eturralde, Kim Roberts, Shannon Cuthrell, Yonat Shimron, Brittany Smith, and Christina Darnell. I’m Natasha Cowden, in Denver, Colorado. Warren: And I’m Warren Smith in Charlotte, North Carolina. Natasha: You’ve been listening to the MinistryWatch podcast.  Until next time, may God bless you.

You may have heard the term ex-vangelical. An ex-vangelical is someone who formerly identified as an evangelical, but no longer does so. The phenomenon has created a sub-genre of books from memoirs – such as those by Josh Harris, Rachel Held Evans, and others — to more journalistic accounts, such as Sarah McCammon’s “The Ex-Vangelicals.” But is there really a groundswell of people leaving evangelicalism? Are these books fair representations of evangelicalism? Is the rejection of the ex-vangelicals really a rejection of Christianity, or a rejection of a certain brand of evangelicalism defined more by culture and politics than theology? These are questions Miles Smith set out to answer. He read many of the ex-vangelical books and wrote a helpful article about it called “Reading The Exvangelicals” for Mere Orthodoxy. Miles Smith is a historian by training. He attended university at the College of Charleston in Charleston, South Carolina, and got a Ph.D. from Texas Christian University in Fort Worth, Texas. He now teaches at Hillsdale College. But he has come on strong in recent years as a public intellectual. I have found his commentaries helpful and highly readable. In addition to  Mere Orthodoxy, he has written for The Gospel Coalition, Public Discourse, The Federalist, and The University Bookman. The producer for today’s program is Jeff McIntosh. We get database, editorial, and other support from Christina Darnell, Kim Roberts, Casey Suddeth, and Stephen Dubarry. Please join me on Friday for our round up of the week’s news, with my co-host Natasha Cowden. Until then, may God bless you.

The 2024 Summer Olympics are about to begin in Paris, and that event should be of interest even to those who don’t much care about sports. For one thing, it’s the 100th anniversary of the 1924 Olympics, also held in Paris, in which Christian missionary Eric Liddell won a gold medal. That story was famously recounted in the Academy Award winning movie “Chariots of Fire,” and the story and that movie has become a part of the lore of the modern evangelical movement. Another story unfolded 48 years ago, at the Montreal Games, in 1976. It was that year, at the height of the Cold War, that the American women’s swim team, a team many called the strongest in the world at that time, went up against the East German women’s team. Though the American team brought home a lot of hardware from those games, many sports historians and others believe the women of that team were robbed of their place in Olympic history by the aggressive doping program of the East Germans. Swimming World Magazine has called those Olympics “Doping’s Darkest Hour.” The East German doping program eventually led to reforms in the Olympic movement. That said, if you have been following this year’s Olympics coverage, you may know that a new doping scandal, involving Chinese athletes, threatens to taint this year’s games. So this story of the 1976 games, which has elements of heroism, courage, leadership, and character is as relevant today as ever. And there’s no better person to tell this story than Casey Converse. His book is “Munich to Montreal: Women’s Olympic Swimming in a Tarnished Golden Era.” Casey had a front row seat to the controversy. He was a member of the USA Olympic Swim Team at the Montreal Olympics. He was also an American record holder in the 1650. From there, he coached at the United States Air Force Academy for 28 seasons. He was recently selected as one of the top 100 college swim coaches in the last 100 years by the College Swimming & Diving Coaches of America. He also served as a consultant for the documentary “The Last Gold,” which is a film account of the story we’ll talk about today. Also, if I might insert a personal note here: Casey is a friend. My son Cole swam for the Air Force Academy’s men’s team during his time there, and I got to know Casey a bit. I was personally inspired by his mentorship of generations of young swimmers and future Air Force officers, including my son. I should also add that he is now battling a very serious form of cancer, and I’ve been able to see his character and his faith shine brightly as he faces this new challenge. It’s an honor to know him, and an honor to have him on the program. The producer for today’s program is Jeff McIntosh. Until next time, may God bless you.

On today’s program, the Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission—the public policy arm of the Southern Baptist Convention—fired its president Brent Leatherwood this week…then less than 12 hours later reversed course and said he was NOT fired. We’ll have details. Also, Life Surge wealth conferences draw big audiences with its celebrity speaker lineup and wealth-building tools…we’re taking a closer look to see if it’s delivering on its promises. And, New York Theological Seminary closed its doors earlier this month—famous alumni include religious broadcaster Pat Robertson and author of the Message, Eugene Peterson. But first, the historic sanctuary of First Baptist Dallas, was engulfed in flames last week. The producer for today’s program is Jeff McIntosh.  We get database and other technical support from Stephen DuBarry, Rod Pitzer, and Casey Sudduth. Writers who contributed to today’s program include Bob Smietana, John Stonestreet, Timothy Padgett, Kim Roberts, Aaron Earls, Brittany Smith, and Christina Darnell. A special thanks to Breakpoint and Lifeway Research for contributing material for this week’s podcast. Until next time, may God bless you. COMPLETE MANUSCRIPT BELOW: FIRST SEGMENT   Warren Hello everybody. I’m Warren Smith, coming to you from Charlotte, North Carolina. Natasha  And I’m Natasha Cowden, coming to you from Denver, Colorado. And we’d like to welcome you to the MinistryWatch podcast. Warren On today’s program, the Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission—the public policy arm of the Southern Baptist Convention—fired its president Brent Leatherwood this week…then less than 12 hours later reversed course and said he was NOT fired. We’ll have details. Also, Life Surge wealth conferences draw big audiences with its celebrity speaker lineup and wealth-building tools…we’re taking a closer look to see if it’s delivering on its promises. And, New York Theological Seminary closed its doors earlier this month—famous alumni include religious broadcaster Pat Robertson and author of the Message, Eugene Peterson. Natasha But first, the historic sanctuary of First Baptist Dallas, was engulfed in flames last week. Warren: A fire all but destroyed the historic church sanctuary at First Baptist Dallas, thankfully there were no deaths or injuries. The fire in the Texas Historic Landmark, church built in 1890, was reported about 6:30 p.m. Friday, and contained about three hours later. Natasha: Do we know what started the fire? Warren: Interim Fire Chief Justin Ball said the fire started in the basement, but until they do an investigation we won’t know. Senior Pastor Robert Jeffress said, “We are grateful that no one was injured…We just had 2,000 children and volunteers on campus for Vacation Bible School earlier in the day.” “We thank the Dallas Fire Department and Dallas Police Department for their quick action, courage, and ongoing aid,” Jeffress added. Natasha: Next, the SBC reverses course. Warren: In a head-scratching turn of events, the executive board of the Southern Baptist Convention’s public policy arm now says its leader has not been fired. On Monday evening (July 22), the SBC Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission announced Brent Leatherwood, the group’s president, had been fired — a day after he praised President Joe Biden for ending his reelection bid. Less than 12 hours later, the ERLC’s executive committee issued a new statement on Tuesday, saying Leatherwood would remain in leadership. Natasha: What happened? Warren: The committee said ERLC board chair Kevin Smith had acted on his own in announcing that Leatherwood was fired. Smith, a former seminary professor and denominational administrator who currently pastors a church in Florida, has resigned as ERLC chair, according to the statement. “There was not an authorized meeting, vote, or action taken by the Executive Committee,” the executive committee’s statement said. Smith, who has served on the ERLC board since 2018, was elected chair last fall. Natasha: Do we know any why this happened? Warren: Not specifically. Leatherwood has been criticized for opposing legislation backed by Ascol and other members of the abortion abolition movement that would have jailed women who have abortions. More recently, Leatherwood criticized the GOP for dropping pro-life language from its 2024 platform. Leatherwood also called for gun law reforms after a shooting in March 2023 at a Nashville Christian school where his children were students. He did not respond to requests for comment.  Leatherwood did post his thanks on social media. “I deeply appreciate everyone who has reached out, especially our trustees who were absolutely bewildered at what took place yesterday and jumped in to set the record straight,” Leatherwood wrote Tuesday morning on X. Natasha Let’s move on to our next story. Warren: A major American denomination could soon make “affirming” LGBTQ ideology mandatory for clergy. The General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church in the United States of America (PCUSA) voted nearly two to one to effectively require candidates for ministry to endorse homosexuality and related practices if they wish to be ordained. Though the motion still must be approved by the various presbyteries around the nation, given the strong showing at the national level and the denomination’s high marks from pro-LGBTQ groups, it will likely be made official. Natasha: This story has some really interesting background we can’t get into here, but can you briefly explain how we got here? Warren: To paraphrase Archbishop Charles Chaput, progressivism preaches tolerance until it is dominant, then it tries to silence orthodoxy. Lacking fixed standards by which to judge truth, other than an ill-defined sense of relevance and progress, the rootless ideologies of postmodernism inevitably lock in on suppressing dissent. Natasha Warren, let’s take a quick break. When we return, Life Surge wealth conferences promise tools to build wealth for kingdom impact…but is it delivering on those promises? I’m Natasha Cowden, along with my co-host Warren Smith, and we’ll have that story and much more, after this short break. BREAK SECOND SEGMENT Natasha Welcome back.  I’m Natasha Cowden, along with my co-host Warren Smith, and you’re listening to the MinistryWatch podcast. Next, the story we promised before the break, thousands of Christians are attending Life Surge events across the country, drawn in by its featured Christian speakers and musical artists, such as Priscilla Shirer, Tim Tebow, and Chris Tomlin. Warren: Besides faith leaders, attendees may be drawn by a well-known lineup of TV personalities, including Robert Herjavec from Shark Tank and Marcus Lemonis from The Profit. Life Surge is a Christian wealth conference headquartered in Palmetto, Fla. It is not a ministry, but a for-profit limited liability company. It advertises itself as an event where attendees can “learn why and how to create and multiply financial resources for kingdom impact.” Natasha: Is it doing that successfully? Warren: About the conference he attended at Church on the Rock in St. Peters, Missouri, in August 2023, Adam S. said he did not “believe the intent of the conference was [to] teach financial principles” but instead to draw attendees in as a “sales funnel” for other classes and products related to stock options trading and real estate investing. The classes were offered for an extra price of $97, according to Adam. Natasha: Why does Life Surge do what they do? Warren: Life Surge was founded by Joe Johnson, who calls himself a serial entrepreneur. He told Startup Magazine that “there’s the biblical commandment to be fruitful and multiply, fill the Earth, but we use that in a business setting that we want to be fruitful as individuals. Life Surge did not respond to multiple emails requesting more information about the purpose of the conferences, its growth, and its benefits to those who attend. Nor did it reply to a phone message before time of publication. Natasha: Our next story involves a small Christian College in South Carolina. Warren: Erskine College is associated with the Associate Reformed Presbyterian denomination. It’s faced financial challenges in recent years, and has filed a lawsuit in a South Carolina state court against Icelaven Development Group for failing to repay a $1 million loan. According to reporting by The Herald, Icelaven is the parent company of Reason and Republic, a for-profit charter school management company in South Carolina founded in 2017. Icelaven defaulted on payments it should have made on the promissory note, according to the lawsuit. The lawsuit did not state the purpose of the loan. Natasha: What’s the history behind this? Warren: In 2017, Erskine College founded the Charter Institute at Erskine to authorize charter schools. According to the Charter Institute’s website, it has authorized 25 schools. Until recently, Reason and Republic operated three of those charter schools Since 2022, Erskine has faced accreditation issues due to financial concerns. According to the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools (SACS), Erskine College is still accredited but was denied reaffirmation of its accreditation and placed on warning due to issues with financial resources and financial responsibility. Natasha: What did the school have to say about that? Warren: About the accreditation warning, Erskine told MinistryWatch it “has demonstrated improvement in fiscal oversight, financial management, and availability of financial resources.” In an open letter, Erskine President Steven Adamson said the school projected finishing the 2023-24 school year with the “most robust combined financial results in over 25 years.” He said the college expected to see an operational surplus for the first time in 10 years and an increase in revenue of 17% from the previous year, even with no tuition increase. According to its most recent IRS Form 990 for fiscal year ending in June 2023, Erskine College showed $3 million more in expenses than in revenue. Natasha: What about the lawsuit? Warren: The college declined to comment about the lawsuit against Icelaven, but said it is not related to the accreditation issues. In the MinistryWatch database, Erskine College earns a five-star financial efficiency rating, a “C” transparency grade, and a donor confidence score of 70. Natasha: Next, a church has closed in Illinois. Warren: In its 156 years of existence,  First Baptist Church survived a tornado, church schisms and a pair of worldwide pandemics in its more than a century and a half of ministry in this small Southern Illinois town, about an hour east of St. Louis. Ryan Burge, pastor of First Baptist, told his congregation on Sunday (July 21) as they gathered for the church’s final worship service, reading from the book of Ecclesiastes. ““There is a time for everything, A time for birth and a time for death. A time to build up and a time to tear down.” Natasha: Why is the church closing? Warren: It was a decision that followed years of slow decline. In the late 1990s, the church had about 170 members, down from more than 600 members in the 1960s. By the mid-aughts, when Burge arrived as a 20-something pastor, the church had about 50 members. At closing, there were fewer than 20. Gail Farnham, who as moderator at First Baptist led the meeting’s vote, said small churches like First Baptist are stuck in a dilemma. They can’t attract people with the same kinds of programs that larger churches offer. As a congregation ages, most of the people they know, if they are interested in going to church, already have a place to worship. Natasha: This trend will impact many other churches. Warren: That’s right. Tens of thousands of local congregations like First Baptist are likely to close over the next few decades if current trends continue. Their passing will go unnoticed, said Burge, a political science professor at Eastern Illinois University who studies the changing religious landscape. In his last sermon, Burge recounted when a friend told him that First Baptist was lucky to have him as pastor. But his friend was wrong, said Burge, adding that he and his family had received more than they gave in the love and kindness of church members. Natasha Warren, we’re going to take another break.  When we return, our lightning round of ministry news of the week. I’m Natasha Cowden, with my co-host Warren Smith. More in a moment. BREAK THIRD SEGMENT Natasha Welcome back.  I’m Natasha Cowden, with my co-host Warren Smith and you’re listening to the MinistryWatch Podcast. Warren, we like to use this last segment as a sort of lightning round of shorter news briefs. What’s up first? Warren New York Theological Seminary (NYTS) in Manhattan has closed its doors, effective July 1, 2024. According to the New York State Education Department, the seminary’s board of trustees voted to close the institution on February 22, 2024. Instruction ended in June and transcript requests can be processed through the end of July. NYTS began in 1900 in New Jersey as Bible Teacher’s College, but it moved to New York City two years later. In 1965, it took the name it bore until its closing. Natasha Well-known alumni include pastor and Message author Eugene Peterson and religious broadcaster Pat Robertson. The school’s accreditation was withdrawn as of June 21, 2024, according to a letter written by the Association of Theological Schools (ATS) Commission in Accrediting because they didn’t have sufficient and stable financial resources to achieve its mission with educational quality and financial sustainability.” Natasha: What’s next? Warren: According to the 2023 Annual Church Profile (ACP), Almost 3 in 5 congregations affiliated with the Southern Baptist Convention (58%) use background checks. More than a third (36%) are trained in reporting sexual abuse, while 16% are trained in caring for survivors. Since 2023, churches conducting background checks through Lifeway One Source have performed more than 36,000 screenings, 12% of which returned some type of crime. Most (53%) were misdemeanors, but 35% included felonies. Natasha: What about Abuse training? Warren: Around a third (36%) say their congregation has been trained on how to report sexual abuse. The largest congregations, those with 250 or more in worship services, are the most likely to say they’ve been trained (70%), while the smallest, those with 50 or fewer, are the least likely (24%). Natasha Who is in our Ministry Spotlight this week? Warren The Evangelical Council for Financial Accountability’s (ECFA) Donor Confidence Score has fallen to 43 in the MinistryWatch database—a “Give with Caution” designation. The organization, which offers accreditation and resources to churches and ministries, no longer files its Form 990 with the IRS. In 2019, the ECFA set a new example for its members. It joined a growing number of organizations and ministries that have petitioned the IRS to be reclassified as an “association of churches.” Under a “church” classification, a ministry is not required to file or post its Form 990s. The forms provide important information for donors, including: top employee salaries, yearly revenue and the amount of money an organization spends on its core programming. While the ECFA does voluntarily prepare the form and make its Form 990s available on its website, many of its member organizations with the same distinction do not, and are not required to. That means accountability groups like ProPublica and MinistryWatch are not notified of yearly financial changes within the organization. According to its 2023 990, the ECFA had a total revenue of $7.7 million, and its total expenses were $5.5 million. Natasha And who did Christina highlight in her roundup of Ministries Making a Difference? Warren Hope Bargain Center Eau Claire, Hope Gospel Mission’s flagship thrift store in west central Wisconsin, has become a destination shopping spot with its cleverly designed displays that feature everything from an Esteban/Chevy guitar, Timberland shoes, and old west themes to Fourth of July and summer hats. Proceeds from its sales benefit the Mission, which provides food, shelter and clothes to homeless people and facilitates addiction recovery programs. Hope Gospel Mission has 4 stars and an “A” transparency grade in the MinistryWatch database, and a donor confidence score of 98. The Council for Christian Colleges and Universities (CCCU) has announced its 8th president, Dr. David A. Hoag. “Dr. Hoag brings 35+ years of experience serving & leading #ChristianHigherEd institutions. We are humbled & honored that the Lord has called him to be our next president,” CCCU said on X, formerly Twitter. CCCU has 1 star and an “A” transparency grade in the MinistryWatch database, and a donor confidence score of 70. Natasha Warren, any final thoughts before we go? Warren Ad Lib Year-End Giving RESULTS. California, Colorado, New Mexico Natasha The producer for today’s program is Jeff McIntosh.  We get database and other technical support from Stephen DuBarry, Rod Pitzer, and Casey Sudduth. Writers who contributed to today’s program include Bob Smietana, John Stonestreet, Timothy Padgett, Kim Roberts, Aaron Earls, Brittany Smith, and Christina Darnell. A special thanks to Breakpoint and Lifeway Research for contributing material for this week’s podcast. I’m Natasha Cowden, in Denver, Colorado. Warren And I’m Warren Smith in Charlotte, North Carolina. Natasha You’ve been listening to the MinistryWatch podcast.  Until next time, may God bless you.

Carlos Campo has one of the most interesting biographies I know about. His parents were entertainers who had hit records and a national profile in the 1940s and 50s. Carlos Campo’s mother was Betty Clooney, who with her sister Rosemary rose to the top of the music industry. That also makes Carlos Campo a part of a family that some consider entertainment royalty, a family that includes actor George Clooney, journalist and TV host Nick Clooney, and actor and voice over artist Miguel Ferrar. Campo was born in Las Vegas, where his parents performed. Though he received an undergraduate degree in theatre, his master’s and Ph.D. were in English, and he pursued a career in academia. He has served as president of two significant Christian institutions: Regent University and – most recently – Ashland University. However, after a nine-year tenure at Ashland, he recently resigned to become the new president of the Museum of the Bible. I’ve known Carlos Campo for a decade or more, and every time I get to visit with him is a treat. I know you’ll enjoy this conversation that ranges from his career in higher education to his decision to make a career pivot to lead the Museum of the Bible – along with some life and leadership lessons he has learned along the way. The producer for today’s program is Jeff McIntosh. We get database, editorial, and other support from Christina Darnell, Kim Roberts, Casey Suddeth, and Stephen Dubarry. Please join me on Friday for our round up of the week’s news, with my co-host Natasha Cowden. Until then, may God bless you.

On today’s program, Village Church Pastor Matt Chandler is under fire after his church hired a man who, in the past, was convicted of child sexual abuse. That man was his father. We’ll take a look. Also, Robert Morris—the Gateway Church pastor accused of abusing a young girl starting when she was 12 years old—is having his radio and tv programs canceled…and is receiving no severance after resigning from his posts. We’ll have details. And, the closure of another Christian college—the Florida campus of Johnson University is shutting down after low enrollment made it no longer sustainable. But first, former Christian billionaire Bill Hwang—once one of the wealthiest evangelicals in the U.S., celebrated as part of a “new evangelical donor-class”—he now faces the possibility of life behind bars. The producer for today’s program is Jeff McIntosh.  We get database and other technical support from Stephen DuBarry, Rod Pitzer, and Casey Sudduth. Writers who contributed to today’s program include Tony Mator, Kathryn Post, Kim Roberts, Bob Smietana, Jessica Eturralde, Daniel Ritchie, and Christina Darnell. A special thanks to Baptist Press for contributing material for this week’s podcast. Until next time, may God bless you.

For the past 100 years, radio has proven to be a persistent medium. Television, podcasts, and other digital media have taken their slices of the market, but radio has not gone away. In some ways it is as strong today as ever.  About eight in 10 Americans over the age of 12 listen to terrestrial radio in a given week. And as long as there has been radio, there has been Christian radio. In fact, Reginald Fessenden, a radio pioneer who held hundreds of patents, claims to have made the first radio broadcast, in 1906. And it was arguably a Christian radio program. He broadcast on Christmas Eve. Fessenden the carol O Holy Night on the violin. He closed the broadcast with a biblical passage: “Glory to God in the highest and on earth peace to men of good will” (Luke 2:14). Today, radio ministries are among the largest ministries on the MinistryWatch 1000 list. Even those ministries that are not radio ministries often have a radio component. Relief and development ministries such as World Vision, Compassion International, and Samaritan’s Purse use radio as part of their marketing, communications, and fundraising efforts. A new book looks at two pioneers of Christian radio: Fulton Sheen and Walter Maier. Sheen, a Catholic, and Maier, a Missouri Synod Lutheran, were unlikely prospects to become the biggest radio personalities in America, but that’s what happened, and the techniques they pioneered in the 1940s and 50s are still being used today. A new book examines these men, and provides a fascinating history of the rise of Christian radio. The book is Ministers of a New Medium, and it’s written by Kirk Farney. Farney is the vice president for advancement, vocation and alumni engagement – as well as a member of the faculty – at Wheaton College. We had this conversation via zoom. The producer for today’s program is Jeff McIntosh. We get technical, database, and other support from Christina Darnell, Casey Sudduth, Heidi Allums, and Stephen Dubarry. I’m your host, Warren Smith. Until Friday, may God bless you.

On today’s program, a South Carolina church is facing fallout after it became known that its pastor is a registered sex offender for abusing a minor. Leaders knew when they hired him, but didn’t alert members. We’ll have details. And, years ago a handful of Dallas-area churches that started as multi-site campuses of The Village Church transitioned to becoming independent churches as part of a church-planting initiative. We checked in to see how they are doing. Plus, another Christian university is shuttering its doors due to financial hardship. We’ll take a look. But first, a technology company has acquired two sister websites from Christianity Today. Gloo, a technology company that is behind the famous “He Gets Us” campaign has acquired two sister news sites from Christianity Today: Church Law & Tax and ChurchSalary. The producer for today’s program is Jeff McIntosh.  We get database and other technical support from Stephen DuBarry, Rod Pitzer, and Casey Sudduth. Writers who contributed to today’s program include Kim Roberts, Daniel Ritchie, Bob Smietana, Samuel Heard, Jessica Eturralde, Brittany Smith, and Christina Darnell. A special thanks to the Biblical Recorder for contributing material for this week’s podcast. Until next time, may God bless you.

We live in a polarized time. People with whom we disagree are not just wrong, but evil – or so we (and they) often think. John Inazu thinks that posture towards those with whom we disagree is neither helpful nor biblical. He thinks empathy, curiosity, and love – both loving our neighbors but also loving our enemies – is both a biblical approach, and an approach that is more likely to change hearts and minds. John Inazu is the Sally D. Danforth Distinguished Professor of Law and Religion at Washington University in St. Louis. His latest book, the one we’re discussing today, is Learning to Disagree: The Surprising Path to Navigating Differences with Empathy and Respect (Zondervan, 2024). Inazu is also the author of Liberty’s Refuge: The Forgotten Freedom of Assembly (Yale University Press, 2012) and Confident Pluralism: Surviving and Thriving Through Deep Difference (University of Chicago Press, 2016). He is co-editor (with Tim Keller) of Uncommon Ground: Living Faithfully in a World of Difference (Thomas Nelson, 2020). Inazu is the founder of The Carver Project and the Legal Vocation Fellowship, a Senior Fellow with the Trinity Forum, and a Senior Fellow with Interfaith America, where he co-directs (with Eboo Patel) the Newbigin Fellows. The producer for today’s program is Jeff McIntosh. Until next time, may God bless you.