How We Made Your Mother
Audacy & Josh Radnor and Craig Thomas
HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER, a groundbreaking sitcom that ran for 208 episodes on CBS from 2005-2014, unfolds entirely as a flashback, using a time-bending narrative structure that spotlights the lives of five friends navigating love, friendship, dating, careers, failure, and success in New York City. The show has remained vibrantly alive in our collective pop culture memory, with fans around the world still sharing stories of how HIMYM is not just a hilarious comedy but also medicine for the soul in hard times. Now, JOSH RADNOR (who played “Ted Mosby”) has teamed up with series co-creator CRAIG THOMAS to explore, episode-by-episode, the mystery at the heart of what has made this show so durable and beloved. It’s time – much like the older, wiser narrator Ted does in the show – to look back on this adventure that occupied a pivotal decade of their lives: how the show changed them, how it changed its fans, and how it changed the culture. With plenty of special guests joining us along the way, this podcast will use HIMYM’s trenchant themes as jumping-off points for larger discussions about life, loss, and love. This is HOW WE MADE YOUR MOTHER: A flashback podcast for a flashback show.
Episodes
Mentioned books
4 snips
Jun 2, 2025 • 1h 12min
How We Chose a Pineapple [with co-creator Carter Bays] | S1E10 "The Pineapple Incident"
Carter Bays, co-creator of How I Met Your Mother, joins the conversation to unpack the beloved 'Pineapple Incident.' He reveals how this episode's origins predate the writers' room and discusses the impact of mystery in storytelling. Bays also shares the true inspiration behind the iconic 'vomit-free since ’93' line, reflecting on character dynamics and network challenges. The podcast takes a heartfelt turn as they read a listener's touching letter about the show’s role in navigating grief, highlighting the deep emotional connections it fosters.
May 29, 2025 • 30min
General Questions | S1E9 "Belly Full of Turkey"
The hosts dive into the magic of constructing multiple sets overnight, revealing the challenges and creativity behind the scenes. They explore the origins of Marshall's Minnesota roots, highlighted by the comedic energy Jason Segel brought to the role. Hear the amusing tale of last-minute casting decisions, including how Bill Fagerbakke became the perfect choice for Marshall's dad. Additionally, the origin story of the infamous Thanks-tini and a quirky seven-layer salad recipe are discussed, leaving listeners with laughs and behind-the-scenes insights.
May 26, 2025 • 55min
How We Birthed a Turkey | S1E9 "Belly Full of Turkey"
Thanksgiving takes a comedic turn as Lily navigates the chaos of Marshall's giant family. Ted and Robin's unexpected adventure at a food shelter adds to the hilarity, particularly with Barney's surprising presence. The podcast explores emotional themes of identity, partnership, and family dynamics. Alyson Hannigan's standout performance shines through, particularly in her heartfelt moments. Listeners are treated to behind-the-scenes insights and a touching letter reflecting the show's impact on family bonds.
May 19, 2025 • 1h 18min
How We Met Cobie Smulders
Cobie Smulders, beloved for her role as Robin Scherbatsky, shares fascinating insights about creating this iconic character. She reveals how real-life quirks influenced Robin's evolution and reflects on the show's enduring legacy. Cobie reminisces about her early auditions, memorable on-set antics, and the camaraderie among the cast. The hosts discuss the unique blend of comedy and emotional depth in the series, and Cobie hints at more Robin Sparkles stories to come!
May 15, 2025 • 33min
General Questions | S1E8 "The Duel"
Hosts reminisce about the emotional weight of spaces we inhabit. They explore the legacy of iconic show websites and how they engaged fans. The discussion includes how props, like swords, represent deeper themes of friendship and nostalgia. They share personal stories about their first apartments and the sense of loss tied to moving. Stage combat insights reveal the playful yet serious nature of the show's duel, emphasizing the connection between home, people, and cherished memories.
4 snips
May 12, 2025 • 58min
How We Stabbed Lily | S1E8 "The Duel"
Josh and Craig tackle the emotional rollercoaster of growing up in 'The Duel.' They explore nostalgia and the struggle to keep friendships alive as life changes. The iconic sword fight is spotlighted, alongside Barney's Lemon Law introduction. They delve into how post-9/11 New York influenced character motivations and discuss the significance of objects like Shockey the coffee maker, revealing how they embody memory and identity. Lastly, they highlight the characters' journey towards embracing change and its rewards.
May 8, 2025 • 25min
General Questions | S1E7 "Matchmaker"
Alec Lev, the producer and moderator for listener questions, joins Josh and Craig to explore fascinating behind-the-scenes stories inspired by 'Matchmaker'. They share humorous anecdotes about life on set, from forgotten script pages to the notorious candy cart. The trio discusses how Robin's reporting made New York feel like a cozy small town and the origins of the matchmaking plot tied to real-life experiences. They also delve into the phrase 'Tedding out' and reveal their strategies for avoiding spoilers, all while reflecting on the show's enduring charm.
May 5, 2025 • 57min
How We Met Our Match | S1E7 "Matchmaker"
Hosts dive into the classic HIMYM matchmaker storyline, examining how Ted's romantic optimism clashes with practical matchmaking. They explore the quirky cockamouse subplot, inspired by real-life city living. The conversation also touches on the themes of fate versus data in dating, reflecting on how these ideas resonate today. With insights into character dynamics and memorable guest stars, the discussion balances humor and nostalgia, painting a picture of a pre-app romance era.
May 1, 2025 • 26min
General Questions | S1E6 "The Slutty Pumpkin"
Hosts explore the beloved "Slutty Pumpkin" episode, delving into the origins of its quirky name and the appeal of holiday-themed storytelling. They discuss fan-favorite gags, like Marshall's dance moves and iconic moments showcasing cast chemistry. Personal insights reveal how Ted's optimism contrasts with real-life experiences and emotional resilience. Listeners learn about the show's writing dynamics and how certain references, like the rooftop scene, have shaped character development. Behind-the-scenes tidbits add more flavor to this nostalgic journey.
Apr 28, 2025 • 51min
How We Stayed Up All Night | S1E6 "The Slutty Pumpkin"
Discover the layers behind a beloved episode featuring Ted's hilarious quest for the Slutty Pumpkin. Explore how Ted's optimism contrasts with Robin's fear of losing independence, revealing deep character dynamics. Unpack the emotional weight of the iconic rooftop scene and why some bits became fan favorites. Dive into the quirky behind-the-scenes stories, including costume inspirations and the show’s early musical choices. Plus, hear reflections on how the show dealt with dating vulnerabilities and gender expectations.
