Reason and Theology Show – REASON & THEOLOGY

In this episode, I examine a critical issue at the heart of Protestant theology: the preservation of Scripture. Drawing on the scholarship of Dr. Daniel Wallace and Dr. Emanuel Tov—two of the most respected textual critics—I explore whether the Old Testament has truly been preserved in the way Sola Scriptura requires. Both Wallace and Tov offer positions that, when taken seriously, present major challenges to the Protestant principle of Scripture alone. If the text of the Old Testament hasn’t been reliably preserved, can Sola Scriptura still stand as a viable theological foundation? I contrast this with the Catholic view on the preservation of the Word of God, which does not rely solely on the text but includes Sacred Tradition and the Magisterium. Join me as I unpack the implications of modern textual criticism for Protestantism and make the case for the Catholic understanding of divine revelation.

The Vatican has quietly removed the artwork of Fr. Marko Rupnik from its official website — a move many see as long overdue. But what they haven’t done is even more shocking. In this episode, we dive into the full story: the abuse allegations, the Vatican’s selective response, and what this reveals about the Church’s priorities. Is justice really being served? Or is this just damage control?

The Dead Sea Scrolls are often mentioned in passing—but rarely explained. In this episode, we uncover what you were never told about these ancient manuscripts and why they matter more than you think.

The Old Testament is at the heart of the Christian faith — but how close is your Bible to what was originally written? In this episode, we dive deep into the complex history of the Old Testament text. We explore the major manuscript traditions — the Masoretic Text, the Dead Sea Scrolls, and the Septuagint — and uncover the surprising differences between them. What do these ancient sources reveal? How much has the text changed over time? And can we really know what the original authors wrote? If you’ve never looked under the hood of your Bible, prepare to see the Old Testament in a whole new light.

A petition has been launched calling on Pope Leo XIV to remove Cardinal Rainer Maria Woelki, a prominent figure in the German Catholic Church. In this episode, I break down the reasons behind this growing demand—from his handling of abuse cases to broader concerns about leadership and accountability. But this issue goes far beyond one cardinal. Many German bishops continue to publicly promote teachings that are in clear contradiction with Catholic doctrine. I explain why this moment will be a critical test for Pope Leo XIV’s pontificate. Will he act decisively to defend the faith and discipline those undermining it from within? Or will silence signal that the papacy is unwilling—or unable—to uphold what it claims to teach? This isn’t just about Germany. It’s about whether the Church is serious about orthodoxy and reform. Don’t miss this important commentary.

Elon vs Trump Just Got Nasty—Epstein Name Dropped!

The Origins of Yahweh Worship: History, Archaeology & Theology w/ Dr. Justin Sledge

In this episode, I take a deep dive into Fr. James Martin’s recent article advocating that Catholics should celebrate Pride Month. Join me as I respectfully examine his claims, highlight key theological concerns, and discuss what authentic compassion and truth look like when it comes to this complex issue. Whether you agree or disagree, this is a conversation we need to have. Don’t forget to like, comment, and subscribe for more Catholic commentary and cultural analysis.

What if I told you there was a Jewish temple in Egypt—outside of Jerusalem—dedicated to Yahweh, where female priests served, other gods were worshipped alongside Him, and some believe the Ark of the Covenant may have once rested there? In this episode, we explore the remarkable temple at Elephantine Island, a 7th-century BCE site that challenges our assumptions about ancient Jewish worship. We’ll dive into the archaeological evidence, the connection to the Book of Nehemiah, and what this means for understanding early Yahweh devotion. Don’t miss this fascinating look at a forgotten chapter of biblical history!

BREAKING: N.T. Wright Defends Abortion for Limited Cases | My Critique