Reason and Theology Show – REASON & THEOLOGY

Vatican Releases Document on Polygamy – Here’s What You Need To Know!

In today’s episode, we take a close look at the recent document calling Christians to “move beyond outdated theological disputes” and to leave behind controversies that are believed to have lost their purpose. But what does that actually mean? I walk through the text, its key claims, and the implications many Catholics, Orthodox, and Protestants are now wrestling with. Along the way, I highlight why certain theological controversies mattered in the first place, why some remain unresolved even centuries later, and the real cost of walking away from questions that define the Christian faith. Whether you agree or disagree with the document’s approach, this is a conversation Christians cannot afford to ignore. Join me as we examine the document, weigh its claims, and consider what this means for the life of the Church today.

In this episode, we break down Pope Leo XIV’s new comments on U.S. immigration and the ongoing open-borders debate. What exactly did the Holy Father say? How does it compare with the recent statements from the U.S. bishops? And why has JD Vance—one of the most prominent Catholic politicians in America—remained silent on the issue?

Did Ireland Really Have a Woman Bishop? Fact or Myth?

The Synod’s Study Groups have released their Interim Reports, and some of the most controversial topics are sparking intense debate: homosexuality, polygamy, and the question of women deacons. In this episode, I break down what the Church is actually saying in these reports, what’s being proposed, and the hot-button controversies these topics are generating. From pastoral care for polygamous unions to the ongoing discussion about women in the diaconate, and the Church’s approach to homosexuality, I give a clear, no-nonsense look at what’s happening and what it could mean for the future of the Church. If you want an honest, focused update on the Synod’s most talked-about issues, this episode is for you.

St. Peter’s Basilica has just installed a “Listening Kiosk” — a new station designed for spiritual dialogue, personal reflection, and pastoral outreach. But what exactly is this kiosk? Who is it for? And why is the Vatican introducing it now? In this video, I break down what the kiosk actually does, how it fits into the broader pastoral vision of Pope Leo XIV, and why many Catholics are raising questions about its purpose and potential impact.

In 2009, Patriarch Bartholomew of Constantinople gifted a Quran to a Muslim leader — and many Christians are still asking: Why would an Orthodox patriarch do that? And it’s not an isolated example. In recent decades we’ve seen a growing list of gestures and statements from major Christian leaders that seem totally at odds with what many Christians online would expect: A pope kissing the Quran The former Patriarch of Alexandria calling Muhammad a “true prophet of God” Patriarch Kirill saying Muslims and Christians worship the same God Patriarch Bartholomew claiming all religions worship God Meanwhile, online Christian discourse often takes a very hardline approach toward other religions — sometimes even hostile or vitriolic. So what’s behind this massive gap between: 1) Online Christian rhetoric 2) The tone of popes, patriarchs, and bishops? In this video, I examine: Whether Catholics doing this is different because of papal infallibility Whether the internet and institutional leaders inhabit two totally different “worlds” Watch now and let me know what you think in the comments.

After the recent plenary assembly of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales, the Vatican’s nuncio in Britain confirmed that Pope Leo XIV does not intend to overturn Pope Francis’ limits on the traditional Latin Mass. That means “Traditionis Custodes” remains in effect, but with one small caveat: bishops who request it can receive a two-year, renewable exemption to allow the older Mass in certain locations. This isn’t exactly new — it’s basically a continuation of the practice already in place since 2021. In this video, I’ll break down: What this decision actually means for the faithful who love the pre-Vatican II Mass Why the exemptions don’t change the core restrictions Why this matters for the unity of the Church and the future of the Latin Mass If you’ve been following the Latin Mass debate, you’ll want to see the real story behind the headlines — and why Pope Leo XIV’s decision may shock some traditional Catholics.

In this episode, I cover the growing controversy after a priest — with the involvement of Fr. James Martin — confirmed an openly gay man living in a same-sex relationship, with his partner serving as his sponsor. Bishop Joseph Strickland raised this serious concern during the annual meeting of the U.S. bishops, but the conference reportedly took no action. What does this say about the current state of the Church? How did the bishops respond to Strickland’s challenge? And does this mean homosexuality is no longer viewed as a sin within the Church’s hierarchy? Join me as I break down what happened, explore the reactions, and discuss the deeper spiritual and doctrinal implications for Catholics today.

Openly Gay ABC Anchor Joins Catholic Church with Partner as Sponsor