The Fifth Column

Abby Phillip, CNN anchor and author of 'A Dream Deferred,' joins the conversation, bringing her Trinidadian roots and insights on race and politics. She discusses the significance of Jesse Jackson's influence on Black political power and how he's shaped contemporary movements. The dialogue also dives into modern media's obsession with conspiracy theories and the challenges of maintaining civil discourse in heated debates. Abby shares her strategies for moderating discussions, emphasizing the importance of diverse perspectives on television.

In this discussion, Shadi Hamid, a Senior Fellow at Georgetown and a columnist for The Washington Post, makes a compelling case for American power in his recent book. He describes it as a love letter to America, urging progressives to embrace its ideals while navigating its flaws. Shadi argues for seeking power to enact change, rather than maintaining moral purity. He emphasizes the importance of reclaiming national pride and discusses the significance of hyphenated identities in fostering unity.

Jessica Tarlov, a Fox News contributor and co-host of Raging Moderates, dives into the complexities of New York politics and moderate Democratic strategies. She discusses why moderate candidates have overperformed in recent elections and the impact of populism on governance. Tarlov also shares insights on moderating contentious topics like transgender sports and the challenges posed by online intimidation. Additionally, she highlights the significant real-world consequences of the SNAP disruptions, emphasizing the need for bipartisan solutions.

Jon Lovett, a former Obama speechwriter and co-founder of Crooked Media, dives deep into the quirks of Democratic politics. He humorously critiques the perception of party control while discussing the fine line between inspirational campaigning and actual governance. Lovett explores the implications of political identity, the challenges of translating progressive promises into effective policies, and reflects on Mamdani's potential in New York politics. His insights on political evolution make for a captivating conversation.

The hosts dive into the chaos of the government shutdown and blame games among parties. They explore the buzz around the NYC mayoral race, dissecting Mamdani's unique political style and contentious promises. There's a lively discussion about the thrill of loving charismatic politicians amidst evolving party dynamics. The conversation also touches on NBA gambling scandals, the commercialization of sports, and how recent controversies affect fandom. Expect sharp commentary on identity politics and a bit of humor along the way!

Michael McFaul, former U.S. Ambassador to Russia and Stanford professor, dives into the complexities of U.S.-Russia relations. He discusses Trump's shifting views on Putin and how these changes have influenced American politics. McFaul also explores the deep-rooted ideology behind Putin's actions, questioning whether recent conflicts were truly American-instigated. He addresses the surprising lack of protest among Russians despite heavy casualties and dissects how modern surveillance fuels public silence.

Jeffrey Toobin, an experienced legal analyst and author known for his insights into high-profile cases, joins to dissect crucial legal topics. He shares captivating stories about Patty Hearst and the infamous F. Lee Bailey. The discussion delves into rising right-wing extremism, ideological violence, and the implications of Donald Trump’s pardons. Toobin also critiques media overreach during investigations like Russiagate and reflects on the O.J. Simpson trial's cultural impact. Expect a thought-provoking blend of history, law, and current events!

The discussion kicks off with complaints about romanticizing left-wing violence in a recent film. Car chases reminiscent of classic cinema receive high praise, igniting thrilling debates. Sean Penn's cartoonish performance faces criticism, contrasting sharply with a standout supporting actor’s authentic portrayal. Jim Downey's legacy in SNL adds a nostalgic touch. Themes of left-wing terrorism echo throughout the film, raising provocative questions about politics in cinema.

Delve into the intriguing world of Japanese culture with a literacy test that surprises. Jake Adelstein shares insights from the world of the Yakuza, including their unexpected Halloween parties and even their unique pension plans. The conversation raises eyebrows with humorous takes on drinking in journalism school and the bizarre allure of penis enlargement ads. Plus, there's a playful nod to the modern entertainment industry with the 'Ansel Elgortification' of certain personalities.

Mary Katharine Ham, a political commentator and journalist, dives into the evolving landscape of U.S. foreign policy and Trump-era dynamics. They discuss the dramatic impact of Trump's Knesset speech and the emotional return of Israeli hostages. Exploring the shift in party attitudes towards Israel, Ham critiques political messaging and the influencer model in politics. The conversation also touches on the complexities of a potential second Trump administration and what could come next for the GOP. Expect sharp insights and lively banter!