
Chance or Chess? a BBC Sherlock Podcast
A Watsonian analysis of BBC Sherlock series 1-4. Why is series 4...like that? What is tjlc? Listen as we play the great game and discuss "the final problem" of understanding the show's deconstruction of the myth of Sherlock Holmes.
Latest episodes

Jan 25, 2023 • 2h 13min
The Hounds of Baskerville: "Sherlock's Bussin"
Guest Marcel, a special guest, joins for this hilarious podcast where they talk about topics like changes in episode titles, tension in the fandom, exploration of new interests, and the portrayal of wealth in media. They also discuss the episode 'The Hounds of Baskerville' and its atmosphere, love for the movie 'Clue', government conspiracies, and the authenticity of autistic characters in media.

Nov 2, 2022 • 2h 16min
A Scandal in Belgravia: "Masterclass in Misdirection"
Pour one out for Battersea! We're diving into ASIB, again with our special guest Erin. We quote just about every line of this episode, so buckle up. You can expect mirror character analysis, phone=heart and car metaphors, innuendos galore, and some gut wrenching scene readings.
Follow Erin here. Posts mentioned: Culverton, Topping, and John Mirrors.
Richard Siken poems mentioned: one and two
Find us at chanceorchesspod.tumblr.com
Have a question about series 4 or blog theory? Ask us!
All references and links can be found on our bibliography page
Email us at tjlcpodcast@gmail.com
Credits:
Original cover art by Kira
Music from "Who You Really Are" by David Arnold and Michael Price

Dec 21, 2021 • 2h 6min
The Great Game: "The Clue is in the Name"
Finally finishing Series 1 with E3: The Great Game. We discuss this episode's post S4 significance, first in-show conversation about the blog, and our introduction to the main antagonist. Topics include: the Blog post for A Study in Pink, Sherlock and John's little domestic, the Five Pips, Mary the American, Janus Cars, Trains, Stars symbolism, Doyle's The Parasite, and the Pool Scene.
Mentioned posts on The Parasite here and here.
Find us at chanceorchesspod.tumblr.com
Have a question about series 4 or blog theory? Ask us! Don't be shy
All references and links can be found on our bibliography page
Email us at tjlcpodcast@gmail.com
Credits:
Original cover art by Kira
Music from "Who You Really Are" by David Arnold and Michael Price

Nov 24, 2021 • 1h 13min
The Blind Banker: "No One On Nothing A Year"
It's our shortest episode yet (and possibly ever)! S1 E2: The Blind Banker. It's everyone's least favorite episode, but fear not. We focus on the episode's highlights, how it establishes character dynamics, and its relevance to series 4 and 5. Topics include: teapots/drink code, Brecht, character mirrors, John the unlucky dog, and Mary's love of cats.
Find us at chanceorchesspod.tumblr.com
Have a question about series 4 or blog theory? Ask us!
All references and links can be found on our bibliography page
Email us at tjlcpodcast@gmail.com
Credits:
Original cover art by Kira
Music from "Who You Really Are" by David Arnold and Michael Price

Sep 6, 2021 • 1h 53min
The Unaired Pilot: "Comic Sans Snax 'n' Sarnies"
Kira and Hannah are joined by special guest Miranda to briefly relive the dark times post series 4. We tackle blog theory, alibi theory, and how will series 5 work after series 4? In the second half we get into the unaired pilot's two dollar budget, overt gay vibes, and differences to the aired episode (plus a Culverton tangent so beware!).
Follow Miranda here and listen to her supernatural podcast Ramble On.
Find us at chanceorchesspod.tumblr.com
Have a question about series 4 or blog theory? Ask us! Don't be shy
All references and links can be found on our bibliography page
Email us at tjlcpodcast@gmail.com
Credits:
Original cover art by Kira
Music from "Who You Really Are" by David Arnold and Michael Price

Aug 6, 2021 • 1h 59min
Historical Context: "Be Gay Solve Crime"
Before diving into the show proper, we discuss a couple sources on the homosexual subculture of London in the late-Victorian era up to the trial of Oscar Wilde. Prepare yourselves for the unavoidable Mary Discourse, known scandals, the Gay West End, the trial of Oscar Wilde, the inherent queerness of amateur sleuths, and more. Special Guest: the ghost of Oscar Wilde possessing Hannah's cat (coincidentally named Oscar, in fact, after the legend himself).
*Content Warning* for many mentions of historic instances of homophobia. We don't go into disturbing details of violence, but we do mention it and briefly discuss death, violence, and blackmail. We also quote examples of homophobic public opinion during this era that may be upsetting to some.
Check out our blog chanceorchesspod.tumblr.com to see a picture of Oscar the fancy tuxedo cat.
All references and links can be found on our bibliography page
Email us at tjlcpodcast@gmail.com
Credits:
Original cover art by Kira
Music from "Who You Really Are" by David Arnold and Michael Price