Critics at Large | The New Yorker

The podcast explores how musicians shape their own legacies, referencing Usher's Super Bowl performance and the impact of high-profile appearances. They discuss the Bob Marley biopic, the role of the Super Bowl halftime show in building a performer's legacy, and the complexities of artists seeking validation at the Grammy Awards. They explore conflicting feelings about artists shaping their own legacies, highlighting Beyoncé's Super Bowl performance. The enduring power of music is celebrated through standout Grammy performances by Tracy Chapman and Joni Mitchell, emphasizing its timeless impact.

Explore the allure of wretched love stories and their emotional impact. Delve into iconic examples like 'Romeo and Juliet' and explore the theme of separation and regret in love stories. Discuss the intense desire and impossibility of love in 'Desire' by Frank Bader. Discover why stories of wretched love resonate with people and how societal changes have reshaped the definition of taboo love affairs. Delve into the concept of the abject and its connection to love, highlighting the enduring presence of wretched love stories and the longing to reconnect with intense emotions.

The podcast explores the portrayal and fascination with mean girls in popular culture, from films like 'Mean Girls' to TV shows like 'Real Housewives of Salt Lake City'. The hosts discuss the evolution of the mean girl archetype and its impact on society, highlighting the enduring appeal of these characters. They also delve into the complexities of their portrayal and the role of choice feminism in perpetuating anti-feminist ideals.

Heidi Blake, a New Yorker staff writer, joins Madeleine Baran in the podcast to tell the story of the Dubai ruler's runaway princesses. The podcast explores the luxurious lives of the women in Sheikh Mohammed's family, their attempts to escape, and the astonishing courage and cruelty behind palace walls.

Examining Dave Chappelle's controversial Netflix special and the evolving role of comedians in society; analyzing the impact of comedy on identity and relatability; discussing the history of comedic censorship; unveiling the hidden secret of Dr. Serhat and exploring the significance of comedy in bridging societal divisions; exploring the challenges of comedy in building communities and catering to different preferences.

The podcast features staff writers Vinson Cunningham, Naomi Fry, and Alexandra Schwartz discussing the art and purpose of criticism. They reflect on the work of legendary practitioner Joan Acocella and explore their own formative influences. They discuss the challenges of arts journalism and the role of a critic in making elevated material relatable. The speakers also explore the impact of criticism in providing comfort and connection. They discuss the current crisis in criticism, the decline of arts criticism, and the rise of online platforms. The importance of supporting the artistic ecosystem through professional criticism is emphasized.

Exploring the rise of 'slowness culture' and its potential for better living. Discussing Jenny Odell's work, reclaiming time, and the implications of an individual's commitment to leisure on the collective level. Exploring the paradox of slowness in a fast-paced world and the concept of public napping. Delving into the historical perspective of attention and critique of modernity. Connecting slowness to the labor movement and the importance of reclaiming humanness.

In this episode, the hosts discuss films that subvert cliched portrayals of artists and explore the complexities of the creative process. They examine movies like 'Maestro' and 'May December' that delve into the tension between an artist's private and public life. The hosts analyze Todd Haynes' film 'May December' and its exploration of method acting. They also discuss the challenges and dualities of an artist's life, including economic realities and the integration into artistic communities.

After six decades as an icon in country music, it’s hard to imagine Dolly Parton had anything to prove.  But when she was inducted into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, in 2022, she admitted to feeling uneasy.  A result of that feeling is “Rockstar,” the 77-year-old’s first foray into rock music.  “I wanted the rock people to be proud of me, let’s put it that way,” Parton tells the contributor Emily Lordi. “I wanted them to say, ‘Did you hear Dolly’s rock album? Man, she killed it.’ ” For this album, which is largely comprised of covers of classic rock songs like “Freebird” along with originals like the title track, Parton channeled the likes of Joan Jett and Melissa Etheridge (who also both appear on the album).  She didn’t want to make a countryfied rock album, but even at a full roar, her voice is unmistakable Dolly. “It’s a voice you know when you hear it, whether you like it or not,” Parton says. The artist is known for avoiding comment on political subjects, but she describes the volatile state of the culture in her song “World on Fire.” “The only way I know how to fight back is to write songs to say how I feel,” Parton says. “It’s just me trying to throw some light on some dark subjects these days.” Learn about your ad choices: dovetail.prx.org/ad-choices

The podcast explores the theme of the 'Year of the Doll' in popular culture, discussing movies like Barbie and Poor Things, Sofia Coppola's film Priscilla, and Emma Cline's novel The Guest. The hosts examine the doll-like aesthetic and its connection to women's bodily autonomy, beauty standards, and political backsliding. They also discuss the visual appeal and symbolism of 'Priscilla', the trapped doll concept, and the awakening of white women to these issues. The episode ends with an interview with Dolly and a break announcement for the new year.