Critics at Large | The New Yorker

“The Pitt,” which recently began streaming on Max, spans a single shift in the life of a doctor at an underfunded Pittsburgh hospital where, in the course of fifteen gruelling hours, he and his team struggle to keep up with a seemingly endless stream of patients. The show has been praised by lay-viewers and health-care professionals alike for its human drama and its true-to-life portrayal of structural issues that are rarely seen onscreen. On this episode of Critics at Large, Vinson Cunningham, Naomi Fry, and Alexandra Schwartz parse how “The Pitt” fits alongside beloved medical shows like “E.R.” and “Grey’s Anatomy.” While the new series upholds many of the tropes of the genre, it’s set apart by its emphasis on accuracy and on the daily struggles—and rewards—of laboring toward a collective goal. At the heart of “The Pitt” is a question that, in 2025, is top of mind for many of us: does the for-profit medical system actually allow for humane care? “Faith in these institutions has eroded,” Schwartz says. “At the low point of such faith and trust, what happens to build it back?”Read, watch, and listen with the critics:“The Pitt” (2025-)“E.R.” (1994-2009)“Grey’s Anatomy” (2005-)“This Is Going to Hurt” (2022)“House” (2004-12)“The Bear” (2022–)Doctor Mike’s YouTube channelSteveoie’s YouTube channelNew episodes drop every Thursday. Follow Critics at Large wherever you get your podcasts. Learn about your ad choices: dovetail.prx.org/ad-choices

The podcast dives into the intriguing theme of identity as portrayed in 'Severance,' where characters grapple with their split selves, dubbed 'innies' and 'outies.' It traces the historical roots of the double from classics like 'Jane Eyre' to modern cinema, revealing how the concept persists in our fractured lives. In a world of curated online identities, the discussion highlights how avatars can amplify feelings of alienation. With wit and depth, the hosts explore psychological implications and cultural reflections surrounding our search for wholeness.

Dive into the rich history of a beloved sketch comedy staple celebrating 50 years of laughter. The discussion spans unforgettable sketches and legendary cast members, while reflecting on how the show has shaped the comedic landscape. With a mix of nostalgia and critical analysis, the hosts ponder the balance between predictability and innovation. They also explore the show's cultural relevance and its ability to tackle current events, all while celebrating its continuous evolution and enduring impact on comedy.

Katy Waldman, a staff writer at The New Yorker and an expert on the romantasy genre, discusses the genre's explosive popularity post-pandemic. She highlights how works like Sarah J. Maas's series have captivated readers, especially on platforms like BookTok. Waldman reveals that romantasy taps into deep-seated desires for empowerment and intimacy, offering readers a comforting escape filled with wish fulfillment. The discussion also explores the evolving themes and tropes that resonate with younger audiences, shedding light on the intersection of fantasy and romance.

Dive into the mesmerizing world of David Lynch, where the mundane collides with the macabre. Explore his iconic films like 'Blue Velvet' and 'Mulholland Drive,' filled with surreal imagery and emotional depth. Discover the complex puzzles that his art presents, blurring the lines between reality and dreams. The conversation highlights the lingering influence of Lynch on contemporary culture and invites listeners to engage with his elusive narratives, celebrating the freedom of personal interpretation.

Discover the enduring legacy of David Attenborough as the discussion traces his journey from "Zoo Quest" to modern works like "Mammals." The conversation delves into the enchanting allure of nature documentaries that create emotional bonds with wildlife. Explore how these films have evolved to address urgent environmental issues while still captivating audiences. Hear personal anecdotes that highlight humanity’s relationship with nature, and reflect on the dual role of these visuals as sources of escapism and calls to action for conservation.

Discover the intricate world of modern Westerns as the conversation traces the genre's evolution. Explore iconic films and hit series like 'Yellowstone' that blend historical bravado with contemporary issues. Delve into themes of violence, land rights, and family dynamics that resonate through modern narratives. The discussion also critiques gender representation and political undertones in these tales of survival. Ultimately, the podcast uncovers why audiences across the spectrum are drawn to these rugged, complex stories.

Delve into the intriguing world of first-person narration, a technique that draws us into the thoughts and feelings of others. Discover how films like 'Nickel Boys' and classics such as 'Lady in the Lake' use this perspective to create emotional depth. The discussion also explores the rise of personal narratives in modern media, raising questions about authenticity and connection. From literature to cinema, the complexities of identity and empathy are examined, revealing the challenges and beauty of seeing through another's eyes.

Explore the enchanting realms created by Hayao Miyazaki, where childhood meets bittersweet reality. His films reveal deep themes of loss, transformation, and the complexities of growing up amidst the backdrop of history and war. Delve into 'The Boy and the Heron,' a tale of grief and resilience, highlighting the interplay of beauty and darkness. Discover the influence of Miyazaki on animated storytelling and how childhood autonomy is mirrored in his masterpieces. Join a discussion that celebrates creativity, responsibility, and the philosophical questions of life.

The hosts dive into a whirlwind of high-profile failures, from Coppola's costly flop "Megalopolis" to Kamala Harris's political missteps. They explore the fickle nature of celebrity fame and how social media affects success perceptions. Discussions about artistic flops reveal how failures can spark cultural dialogues and fan reactions while also highlighting the emotional turmoil artists face. The conversation embraces the idea that failure may lead to creativity and growth, turning disappointments into transformative opportunities.