Dateline NBC

Eddie Mulligan, a longtime friend of Cliff Lambert, recounts the unsettling details surrounding Cliff's disappearance, launching a complex investigation. Lisa DiMaria, the lead prosecutor, shares the challenges of a no-body case and courtroom drama involving the defendants. Tech entrepreneur Tyson Wrench reveals his investigation into digital evidence linking key suspects to the plot. The trio dives into deception, tangled relationships, and the shocking twists that led to life sentences for those involved in the crime.

A Texas toddler, Nikki, dies under suspicious circumstances, leading to her father's arrest for murder. Medical experts discuss signs of shaken baby syndrome, casting doubt on the father's account of a fall. Investigators uncover troubling evidence and witness testimonies that build a strong case against him. As appeals unfold, new information emerges, challenging the certainty of guilt. This gripping narrative explores themes of innocence, justice, and the chilling reality of capital punishment.

Gretchen Sween, an attorney passionate about justice, shares her experience challenging Robert Roberson’s conviction. She delves into Nikki's overlooked medical history, revealing alarming findings about her health issues. Gretchen highlights how expert opinions evolved on shaken baby syndrome, impacting the case's validity. Her dedication shines as she investigates new leads to uncover the truth about Robert's innocence, showcasing the complexities of forensic science and defense strategy in capital cases.

Brian Wharton, a former detective turned United Methodist minister, shares his deep-seated doubts about the investigation that led to Robert Roberson's death row conviction. He discusses the troubling implications of a discredited shaken baby syndrome theory and the failure to properly account for Roberson's autism. Excitingly, missing CAT scans found in a courthouse basement contradict crucial autopsy findings. Wharton expresses remorse over investigative failings and vows to help Robert, weaving a tale of justice, faith, and second chances.

In a gripping legal saga, Robert Roberson's last-minute fight against execution unfolds. Emotional testimonies reveal a chaotic scramble for justice, with a recanted juror casting doubt on the original trial. Experts highlight a nationwide reevaluation of controversial diagnoses, including shaken baby syndrome. Advocacy from former detectives and personal stories of wrongful convictions deepen the narrative. A stay from the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals offers a glimmer of hope, leaving everyone questioning the next steps in this heart-wrenching case.

Chloe Malas, an NBC News entertainment correspondent, shares insights on Sean Combs' sentencing, where he addressed the courtroom, pleading for mercy but ultimately receiving over four years in prison. She discusses the impactful victim letters and the judge's reasoning emphasizing deterrence. Additionally, the podcast delves into the compelling case of Robert Roberson, highlighting new evidence that could change perceptions around his guilty verdict, and the scientific scrutiny of the shaken baby diagnosis that led to his conviction.

Keith Morrison, a veteran Dateline correspondent, dives into the intriguing Bucket Hat Mystery, involving the tragic murder of acupuncturist Jon Tokuhara in Hawaii. The investigation unearths a web of love, jealousy, and betrayal, ultimately leading to Eric Thompson's conviction. Keith reveals how crucial CCTV footage and a fallen bucket hat played pivotal roles in the case. He also shares insights from a juror reflecting on courtroom deliberations and discusses community reactions, as well as the complexities of the relationships at the heart of this gripping story.

Liz Thompson, a retired homicide detective, dives into the chilling murder of acupuncturist Jon Tokuhara. She analyzes intriguing evidence, from a surgical mask to a mysterious bucket hat caught on surveillance. The case unfolds with unexpected romantic entanglements leading to a prime suspect, Eric Thompson, after DNA and vehicle ties emerge. Tension builds through a gripping narrative of trials and mistrials, illuminating the search for justice within a grieving community.

Lester Holt dives into the gripping case of Robert Roberson, a Texas father on death row for the tragic death of his daughter. The podcast unveils key evidence and testimonies that challenge the conviction and questions of innocence. Hear from those closest to the investigation, including a lead detective who feels he may have wrongfully convicted an innocent man. The narrative raises haunting questions about justice, truth, and the possibility of a grave mistake in the system that could cost a life.

The trial of Sarah Hartsfield is underway, centering on accusations she murdered her fifth husband with insulin. A mistrial was declared in a separate case in Mississippi, where jury deliberations ended in a deadlock. The podcast also dives into various legal updates, including significant developments involving Donna Adelson and Nicholas Rossi. Additionally, listeners learn about the rising costs of spam calls and texts, with tips on how to recognize and avoid these scams, highlighting the urgency of the issue.