Unholy: Two Jews on the News

Amos Harel, a military affairs analyst for Haaretz, dives deep into the recent breakthrough deal aimed at bringing hostages home after a grueling 15-month conflict in Gaza. He discusses the complex emotions of hope and apprehension surrounding the agreement. Harel sheds light on the political dynamics influencing ceasefire negotiations and the roles of U.S. envoys. The conversation touches on the emotional toll on families of hostages and the moral dilemmas in public discourse, emphasizing the fragile path toward healing amidst ongoing trauma.

General David Petraeus, former CIA Director and CENTCOM commander, shares his insights on Israel's military successes against Iran and Hezbollah while voicing concerns about the ongoing war in Gaza. He discusses the geopolitical implications of current U.S. foreign policy, the complexities of counterinsurgency in urban warfare, and the necessity for humanitarian efforts in conflict zones. Petraeus also highlights the impact of artificial intelligence on journalism and reflects on the unpredictable nature of future U.S.-Israel relations.

Suzanne Maloney, Vice President and Director of the Foreign Policy Program at the Brookings Institution, provides keen insights on the Middle East and Iran. She discusses the geopolitical implications of recent U.S. political changes and the potential shifts expected by 2025. Maloney delves into Iran's nuclear ambitions and its influence on Israel, examining how these dynamics could disrupt regional stability. The conversation also reflects on the legacy of Jimmy Carter in Middle Eastern politics and highlights the pressing need for effective foreign policy in turbulent times.

A gripping discussion unfolds as hostages in Gaza mark another Chanukah in captivity. Tensions soar with an investigation into Sara Netanyahu, revealing her family's controversial tactics. Listeners reflect on the duality of holiday cheer and the ongoing crisis, while hopes are expressed for 2025. Amid geopolitical turmoil, the potential of Donald Trump's involvement in Middle Eastern peace is examined. The resilience of Israeli society shines through, highlighting individual efforts to maintain normalcy and the importance of education during these challenging times.

This week, Simon Sebag Montefiore, a best-selling historian known for his insights on figures like Stalin and the Romanovs, joins the discussion. He delves into the complexities of the Gaza conflict and the emotional toll of hostage negotiations. The conversation also touches on the challenges of anti-Semitism faced by Jewish communities globally, particularly in light of recent hate crimes. Montefiore highlights the historical ties between Ireland and Jewish identity, while examining the intricate political dynamics in Syria and their impact on regional stability.

Richard Haass, a veteran in US foreign policy and former president of the Council on Foreign Relations, shares insights on the impending fall of the Assad regime in Syria. Award-winning filmmaker Alexis Bloom discusses her documentary on Benjamin Netanyahu's corruption trial, revealing the intertwining of politics and personal relationships. They navigate complex geopolitical dynamics, the implications of military actions, and the challenges of documentary filmmaking in today's climate. The conversation is both poignant and illuminating.

As a veteran of Israel's security establishment, a former defence minister with roots on the Israeli right, says Israel is engaged in "ethnic cleansing" in Gaza, there's renewed talk of a deal to secure a hostage release and ceasefire before Donald Trump takes office in January. Yonit and Jonathan discuss all that - and they speak with Yael Alexander, whose son Edan is still held captive and was this week shown alive in a video released by Hamas. There's a bulging list of chutzpah nominees, stretching from Rumania to New Jersey, and big news about Unholy itself - with a chance for listeners to join the Unholy family.  Subscribe to our new Patreon community Social media links (Instagram, X, Bluesky, Youtube and Facebook) available here Our membership tiers: $8/month (Friend of the Pod): Get 2 bonus episodes a month, early access to event tickets, discounts on merch, and access to a members-only chat room.$25/month (Family Member): Enjoy everything in the Friend tier, plus a live Zoom call with us once a quarter and a limited-edition tote bag at no extra cost. Special Holiday Promotion: Sign up for the Family Member tier now and get 80% off your first month!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Former Prime Minister of Israel, Ehud Barak, discusses the recent ceasefire between Israel and Hezbollah and shares his insights on ending the conflict in Gaza. He reflects on the implications of a nuclear Iran and how Israel must adapt to this reality. Barak also critiques Israel's media landscape and recent legislative shifts threatening press freedom. Amidst serious topics, the conversation includes a light-hearted nod to cultural traditions and the humorous 'Mensch of the Week' awards.

Thomas Friedman, Pulitzer Prize-winning columnist from The New York Times, and Ilana Dayan, acclaimed journalist from Israel's Channel 12, dive into the sensitive geopolitical landscape marked by recent ICC arrest warrants for Israeli leaders. They discuss the implications for Israel's future, including potential shifts in U.S.-Israel relations under a possible second Trump term. Dayan shares insights from a landmark speech, emphasizing the importance of journalism and truth in seeking a peaceful coexistence between Israelis and Palestinians.

Alyssa Farah Griffin, a former Trump White House official and current co-host of The View, discusses the impact of Trump’s potential second term on U.S. foreign policy, especially regarding Israel and the ongoing conflict in Gaza. Military affairs analyst Amos Harel provides insights into the military strategies at play in Gaza and the broader implications of recent geopolitical shifts. They also touch on rising anti-Israel sentiments in Amsterdam and share a lighthearted moment about Radiohead's connection to Israel.