Theology Unplugged

In this episode of Through Theology in a Year, C. Michael Patton explores the Roman Catholic view of authority, often referred to as Sola Ecclesia or what he calls the "Tri-Fold" view. This theological framework relies on three interconnected sources of authority: Scripture, Sacred Tradition, and the Magisterium. Michael walks through seven key arguments in defense of this position, presenting the logic, historical context, and challenges surrounding this Roman Catholic understanding of dual sources of revelation. Whether you are a Catholic, Protestant, or curious observer, this episode will help you better understand and engage with the Catholic theological system.

In this episode of Theology Unplugged, Michael unpacks the recent controversy surrounding Wesley Huff's debate with Billy Carson, which led to Huff's appearance on Joe Rogan's podcast. While Huff passionately defended the reliability of biblical manuscripts, his claim that the Isaiah Scroll is "word for word identical" to Codex Leningradus sparked criticism. Michael explains why this statement was problematic, clarifies the remarkable accuracy of biblical manuscripts, and encourages listeners not to lose confidence in the transmission of Scripture. He also discusses reactions from figures like Alex O'Connor, RussianKD, and Gavin Ortlund, offering insights into the broader debate.

In session 66 of Through Theology in a Year, titled Authority Across the Spectrum, we examined various perspectives on authority in the Christian faith. Using detailed charts, we defined and compared Sola Scriptura with Sola Ecclesia, Dual Source Theory, Regula Fide, and Nuda Scriptura. Each perspective was explored, including its rationale and implications for how Christians view authority in Scripture and tradition.

In session 65 of Through Theology in a Year, titled The Church Fathers and Authority, we explored how early church fathers like Tertullian, Irenaeus, Chrysostom, Augustine, and Athanasius understood the concept of authority. Together, we examined their balanced perspectives, recognizing Scripture as the ultimate authority while also valuing the significant role of tradition. By analyzing their writings and beliefs, we gained fresh insight into how the early church viewed authority and how these perspectives shape our understanding today. This session sets the stage for next time, as we delve into Sola Scriptura and its defense.

In this special edition, we step outside Through Theology in a Year to explore something different. First, we tackle Christianity versus other religions-what makes the Christian faith distinct in a world of competing beliefs? Then, we dive into an exciting new journey: Church Fathers in a Year, where we'll uncover the rich writings of early Christian thinkers and their relevance today. Finally, we highlight Papyrus 115 (P115), one of the oldest biblical manuscripts, and its fascinating place in the story of Scripture.

In this episode, I walk through the Development of Doctrine chart step by step, exploring how theology has progressed throughout church history. We discuss why doctrinal development is inevitable and how understanding this progression is essential for engaging theology today. While presenting an irenic perspective on various approaches, I argue that Sola Scriptura is the most natural and logical outcome of this framework. The Household of Scripture naturally fits into this progression-it doesn't produce it, but it arises as a natural result. Join me as we trace the church's history and its theological journey.

In this session of Through Theology in a Year (TTY), we dive into The Doctrinal Development Debate. How have Roman Catholics, Protestants, and Eastern Orthodox believers viewed the development of doctrine throughout history? This session is all about tracing our doctrinal DNA, understanding how theology has unfolded over time, and deciding how much room there is for growth within the bounds of Scripture. Each tradition approaches this differently, and it's absolutely vital to grasp these distinctions to navigate theological conversations today.

In this episode of Theology Unplugged, we're diving into the four types of doubt that can challenge your faith: intellectual, existential, temperamental, and obsessive-compulsive doubt (scrupulicity). Whether you're wrestling with big questions about the resurrection and Scripture, feeling a shift in how you believe, struggling with a melancholic temperament, or experiencing obsessive doubt that keeps you stuck, we cover it all. Doubt is not a one-size-fits-all experience, and understanding its nuances is key to walking through it with confidence and grace.

In session 62 of Through Theology in a Year, we'll explore theological authority by examining 'Prima Scriptura' and 'Sola Fide.' We'll discuss the meaning of 'Prima Scriptura,' which sees Scripture as primary but in dialogue with tradition and reason, and 'Sola Fide,' the Protestant belief that salvation comes by faith alone. Additionally, we'll touch on how different Christian traditions-Roman Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, and Protestant-interpret and apply these principles, shaping their views of faith and authority. The next session will dive deeper into 'Sola Scriptura.

Description: In this special After Hours edition of Through Theology in a Year, part of Theology Unplugged, I take a closer look at the popular video "Why Be Catholic and Not Just Christian?" by Ascension Presents featuring Father Mike Schmitz. In the video, Father Schmitz argues that the key difference between Catholicism and other Christian traditions comes down to one thing: authority. Join me as I evaluate his claims, explore the concept of authority in the Christian tradition, and discuss how it aligns with Protestant theology.