Intellectual Catholicism

Kyle King (Orthodox, former Catholic) and Ben Bollinger (Catholic, former Orthodox) debate whether clerical celibacy as practiced by Latin Catholics has a stronger basis in antiquity than the Eastern Catholic/Orthodox practice.

Fr. Brian Dunkle, SJ, a noted Jesuit priest and Patristics scholar from Boston College, delves into the complexities of the First Council of Nicaea. He discusses the distinction between historical and theological perspectives on councils. Fr. Dunkle reviews key surviving documents and illustrates how Nicaea shaped sacred tradition. He also explores the ongoing mysteries of the Trinity and the evolving understanding of Trinitarian thought. His insights invite listeners to contemplate the theological richness that arose from the council.

Robert Fastiggi, a Catholic theologian and editor of key Catholic texts, joins Suan Sonna to explore the Church's evolving stance on the death penalty. They discuss how John Paul II emphasized the dignity of even murderers, making capital punishment inadmissible today. Fastiggi clarifies that while the death penalty isn't labeled intrinsically evil, it raises deep moral concerns. Historical shifts, the interpretation of scripture, and the significance of mercy in punishment are also key topics, reflecting on compassion and the possibility of conversion.

Dave Armstrong, a Catholic apologist and author, dives into five Bible verses that challenge Protestant views. He discusses 1 Timothy 3:15, emphasizing the Church's authority as crucial to truth. Armstrong analyzes Jesus’ teachings in Mark 10, advocating for faith accompanied by works. He also unpacks 1 Corinthians 15:29, linking it to baptismal practices and intercession for the dead. Notably, he highlights Matthew 25:31–46, showing that works and mercy play a key role in final judgment. The conversation intertwines faith, works, and the nuances of Catholic doctrine.

Matthew J. Thomas reconstructs the early succession from Peter in Rome.

Suan summarizes his recent research on icons, including new second century evidence, and how to find the weaknesses in Gavin Ortlund's case against images.

In this engaging discussion, Erick Ybarra, a Catholic speaker with a deep grasp of theology, is joined by Ben Bollinger, a thoughtful commentator on church history, and Elijah Yasi, an insightful theologian on Eastern Orthodoxy. They tackle Seraphim Hamilton's claims about Eastern Orthodoxy being the true church, delving into papal infallibility and apostolic succession. Topics like the filioque controversy reveal historical tensions, while reflections on 11th-century reforms highlight the complexities of church authority. The conversation is a rich blend of respect and rigorous debate.

Hassan Ahmad and Suan Sonna discuss whether Christians and Muslims worship the same God.

Philosopher John Skalko discusses how one's belief (or lack thereof) in the afterlife might influence their stance on assisted suicide.

Pat Flynn and Daniel Vecchio permanently put the logical problem of evil to rest.