

Octothorpe
John Coxon, Alison Scott, Liz Batty
A Hugo Award-winning podcast about science fiction and SF fandom from John Coxon, Alison Scott, and Liz Batty.
Episodes
Mentioned books

Apr 14, 2022 • 46min
55: Beatboxing Champagne
John is a Hugo Award finalist, Alison is a Hugo Award winner, and Liz’s mum got a folk award once.
Please email your letters of comment to octothorpecast@gmail.com and tag @OctothorpeCast when you post about the show on social media.
Content warnings this episode: classism (chapter 2)
Hugo Awards
We are a finalist for Best Fancast
We are SO EXCITED
John and Alison are almost certainly going to Chicon 8 (Liz is a “maybe”)
We will be thrilled to lose to any of the other finalists (especially Hugo, Girl!)
Letters of comment:
Ali Baker
A whole emergency episode of Fantasy Book swap!
Malcolm Hutchison
DC
Duncan MacGregor
Nick Gibbins
Jonny Baddeley
Eastercon
We are live from Eastercon at 1:30pm on Monday!
The fan funds are having “amazeballs” and a silent auction
Auction catalogue
Register to bid
Place bids
The Hugo Awards
Do these all look Chinese?
Liz has been listening to Lifewriting by Tananarive Due and Stephen Barnes
Brandon Sanderson
Alex Holden’s concertinas
Brandon Sanderson’s YouTube channel
His confession
They backed every publishing Kickstarter
The project on Kickstarter
It made $41m!
Sanderson’s blog post about the Kickstarter
Including details about how he wanted to have an alternative platform away from Amazon dominance
His team is so big he has an HR director, he’s splitting that cash quite a lot of ways
Tolstoy on wax cylinder
Picks
Rossum’s Universal Robots on BBC Radio 4
Liz: Base Notes by Lara Elena Donnelly (paperback, Kindle, John can’t find an alternative ebook vendor)
Nice review from Lee Mandelo
John: Moon Knight vol. 7 (comiXology, Marvel)
Credits
Cover art: WSFS/The Hugo Awards (!)
Theme music: Fanfare for Space by Kevin MacLeod (CC BY 4.0)

Mar 31, 2022 • 51min
54: Embrace the Sweat
John is dancing, Alison is listening, and Liz is Batman.
Please email your letters of comment to octothorpecast@gmail.com and tag @OctothorpeCast when you post about the show on social media.
Content warnings this episode: COVID (chapter 1), war and human rights (chapter 2)
Letters of comment:
Chris Garcia
Everyone liked Sue’s art and everyone wants John to get better soon
Liz saw a cat
Jonny Baddeley is giving John his old Netrunner stuff
Jonny Baddeley has questions about discos in COVID times
Lori really liked Six Wakes and is going to try to convince her cohosts to add it to her schedule eventually
Chengdu 2022
Human rights
GoH Sergei Lukyanenko signed a letter on Ukraine
Netflix distance from Cixin Liu
Open letter to try and revoke the 2023 site selection
Liz’s links to different indices for measuring this
Democracy Index
Freedom in the World
Membership rates
Cheap and cheaper
But they are selling one without WSFS voting rights
To the WSFS constitution, Bat-Liz!
If you simply define a single programme item that the non-WSFS members can’t attend you don’t break the rules – win!
FAAn awards
The Incompleat Register has the results
Congratulations to the winners!
Thanks to the people who voted for us anyway even after we told you not to
Picks:
John bought a house
Alison is listening to My Real Children by Jo Walton (paperback, epub, Kindle, Audible)
Liz has read The Last Graduate by Naomi Novik (hardback, paperback, epub, Kindle, audiobook)
Credits
Cover art: Alison Scott
Theme music: Fanfare for Space by Kevin MacLeod (CC BY 4.0)

Mar 17, 2022 • 14min
53: It Was John’s Idea
John has COVID, Alison wanted to do a podcast, and Liz had no better offers.
Please email your letters of comment to octothorpecast@gmail.com and tag @OctothorpeCast when you post about the show on social media.
Content warnings this episode: None
Find a text version of our answers to Cora’s questions here!
Cover art: Sue Mason
Theme music: Fanfare for Space by Kevin MacLeod (CC BY 4.0)

Mar 3, 2022 • 58min
52: Who’s Robert Picardo?
John, Alison and Liz have been nominated for a BSFA Award! (Also, Liz is on holiday, naturally.)
Please email your letters of comment to octothorpecast@gmail.com and tag @OctothorpeCast when you post about the show on social media.
Content warnings this episode: None
Letters of comment
Chris Garcia
The Flying Fantastical Books of Mr. Morris Lessmore
Peter Sullivan
Chris for TAFF
Kin-Ming Looi
Duncan MacGregor
Lori Anderson
Hugo deadline is March 15th
We recommended some things on Cora Buhlert’s blog
Tears of the Anaren by C. W. Longbottom
Eastercon: What do you want from your bids?
Liz:
Who’s running it and why?
Where and why?
Are there significant drawbacks?
Commitment to having code of conduct/access policies, even if they’re in progress
Why will it be particularly fun?
What bits of Eastercon tradition don’t you plan to implement (if any)?
What are your plans for hybrid/virtual content?
Do you have a good presentation that shows you have organisational nous?
Alison:
Expanding on who’s running the convention a little
Are you running at Easter? (See Eastercon tradition)
What about real ale?
What are your provisions for children?
John:
How much will it cost?
Picks
Liz: The Fifty-Year Mission: The Next 25 Years: From The Next Generation to J. J. Abrams: The Complete, Uncensored, and Unauthorized Oral History of Star Trek (hardback, epub, Kindle)
John: Android: Netrunner (eBay)
Alison: I Didn’t Do the Thing Today by Madeleine Dore (paperback, epub, Kindle)
The Jasmine Throne by Tasha Suri (paperback, epub, Kindle)
Music credits
Our theme music is Fanfare for Space by Kevin MacLeod, used under a CC BY 4.0 license

Feb 17, 2022 • 56min
51: Make TAFF a Four-Way Tie
John is a spoilsport, Alison is promoting and Liz might come to Eastercon.
Please email your letters of comment to octothorpecast@gmail.com and tag @OctothorpeCast when you post about the show on social media.
Content warnings this episode: COVID-19 (chapter 2), Spider-Man: No Way Home casting spoilers (chapter 6)
Letters of comment
Chris Garcia
Ali Baker
Mark Plummer
TAFF ebooks
Geri Sullivan
TAFF administrators’ FAQ
COVID-19
Reclamation are requiring vaccination for all attendees
Hotel bookings are open, and the booking code has gone out to members
Podcast corner:
The Incomparable Gameshow
The Incomparable #600
Become the Teapot
DisCon III Tweet from Mary Robinette Kowal
The proposal for Game Hugo is out!
Jason Sanford is doing a survey on SF&F magazines and the pandemic to compare to his pre-pandemic data
Picks
Liz: Far from the Light of Heaven by Tade Thompson (paper, epub, Kindle)
Alison: Loki (Disney+)
John: Spider-Man: No Way Home (in cinemas)
tick, tick… BOOM! (Netflix)
Music credits
Our theme music is Fanfare for Space by Kevin MacLeod, used under a CC BY 4.0 license

Feb 3, 2022 • 59min
50: This is How Boxing Championships Work
John is exchanging, Alison is rekindling her sensawunda, and Liz is watching the builders.
Please email your letters of comment to octothorpecast@gmail.com and tag @OctothorpeCast when you post about the show on social media.
We are fifty! That’s kind of unbelievable.
Letters of comment
Bill Burns
Dave Coxon
You can follow us on:
BoardGameGeek (John, Alison)
Goodreads (John, Alison, Liz)
Letterboxd (John, Alison)
Untappd (John, Alison, Liz)
What’s our favourite beer style?
Chris Garcia
Peter Sullivan on Twitter
Podcast corner:
Liz has been listening to the Caribbean SF Podcast
Brandon O’Brien Can You Sign My Tentacle?
Karen Lord The Plague Doctors
Convention corner:
Redemption has been postponed by a year
Corflu Pangloss has been postponed by six months
The FAAn awards have not moved
The TAFF Free eBooks page
TAFF voting is here
Alison says “Anders for TAFF!”
John is pro-Dill Chips (Fia)
Professor Esther MacCallum-Stewart’s inaugural lecture is on Dungeons and Dragons and is being streamed online
The BSFA Awards Long List
Thank you to whoever nominated us!
The Vimes Boots index
Picks
John: Leviathan Falls by James S.A. Corey (hardback, epub, Kindle)
Alison: The Actual Star by Monica Byrne (hardback, epub, Kindle)
Tweet
Liz: Elder Race by Adrian Tchaikovsky (paperback, epub, Kindle)
Music credits
Our theme music is Fanfare for Space by Kevin MacLeod, used under a CC BY 4.0 license

Jan 20, 2022 • 46min
49: Not Sufficiently Sassy
John is demanding, Alison joined a Discord, and Liz knows a lot about the WSFS Constitution.
Please email your letters of comment to octothorpecast@gmail.com and tag @OctothorpeCast when you post about the show on social media.
Content warnings this episode: Genocide and war (chapter 1), racism and capitalism (chapter 2), sexism (chapter 5)
Letters of comment
Liquid of comment from This Never Happens (Cornish branch)
Jonathan Baddeley: “Tedious NPC” would make a great badge ribbon
Ali Baker
Dave Coxon
Chris Garcia
Kat Tanaka Okopnik says Nice is not bidding for 2026
Crying movies
Fran Dowd: Platoon
Farah Mendlesohn: Fried Green Tomatoes
Ang Rosin: Dead Poets Society
Alison very much appreciated this sponsor read on Podside Picnic
Year’s Best African Speculative Fiction edited by Otherwise Award-winning author Oghenechovwe Donald Ekpeki
Kindle Direct Publishing took down Ekpeki’s account shortly before having to pay him royalties
File 770 reports on the eventual end of the saga
This is a continuation of Jason Sanford’s discussion of financial barriers to global authors
The DisCon III Site Selection fiasco
Salon Futura’s write-up of DisCon III
File 770’s comment thread with a lot of inside baseball
Steve Cooper has set up a mailing list on groups.io to look at Electronic Site Selection
Chicon 8 says:
“Hugo nominations will open later in January, and will run through mid-March. All members of DisCon III and anyone who joins Chicon 8 before the 31st of January 2022 will be eligible to nominate in this year’s Hugo Awards.”
Section 3.7.1 of the WSFS constitution, fact fans
Awards!
Nicholas Whyte answers our questions
Nerds of a Feather has recused itself from the 2022 Hugo Awards
Commentary and interesting history courtesy of File 770
We listened to Hugo, Girl!, a fancast in which feminists read and discuss SF
The FAAn Achievement Awards 2022
The Incompleat Register 2021
“A ‘fanzine’, for our purposes, is defined as an immutable artefact, once published not subject to revision or modification. The fanzine might not exist in a physical form. A PDF, for example, is an artefact.”
“[A perzine is a] fanzine which typically has few, if any, contributors other than its editor(s).”
Alison has joined the Hugo Award Study Committee which is a Discord server
If you’d like to join then contact the chair, Cliff Dunn
Their last report was in 2018 at the San Jose Worldcon
New Year’s resolutions
John: Publish more fanzines and make an app
Alison: Have at least one SFF book a month ready to talk about on Octothorpe.
Alison’s super nerdy iPad board game challenge
Liz: Read 80 books on Goodreads (maybe)
Picks
Alison: Sinopticon: A Celebration of Chinese Science Fiction translated and edited by Xue Christine Ni (epub, Kindle)
Liz: She Who Became The Sun by Shelly Parker-Chan (epub, Kindle, hardback, paperback pre-order)
John: The Expanse (Amazon Prime)
Music credits
Our theme music is Fanfare for Space by Kevin MacLeod, used under a CC BY 4.0 license

Jan 6, 2022 • 46min
48: The Things You Nominate Are All Extremely Unpopular
John and Alison are watching cutting-edge TV, and Liz is hungry.
Please email your letters of comment to octothorpecast@gmail.com and tag @OctothorpeCast when you post about the show on social media.
Content warnings this episode: genocide (chapter 2); war and defence contracting (chapter 4)
Letters of comment
Farah Mendlesohn asks “but what did you think of DisCon III?”
Doug Faunt asks about the opening ceremony’s Christmas music
Flick asks why we didn’t mention the Xinjiang region
UK House of Commons motion
Tahir Hamut Izgil writing at The Atlantic
We’re sorry to Ira Alexandre for mispronouncing their name in episodes 20 and 21
Hugo Awards
Octothorpe was almost nominated for the Hugo Awards
Octothorpe was the last fancast to be eliminated from the ballot!
We were surprised and very thrilled and thank you so much for nominating us
E Pluribus Hugo
Helsinki’s explanation of how this works
Nicholas Whyte analyses the Hugo Awards in detail
Camestros Felaptron’s Hugo posts: 1, 2, 3
The Hugo Awards long list
It always has delights on it and this year is no exception
Best Series: Ben Aaronovitch’s Rivers of London
Best Related Work: The Hugo Spreadsheet of Doom 2021 (presumably it was actually 2020 that was nominated now that we think of it)
2022 open for your suggestions now. Get those fanzines and fan writers and fan artists and fancasts that you think are absolutely great on there!
Direct link: https://bit.ly/hugoaward2022
Fanzines just below the line included Bill Bowers’ Outworlds, William Breiding’s Portable Storage and Chris Garcia’s The Drink Tank
Sponsorship
Shaun Duke points out that Raytheon was one of the contractors that was employed in launching the James Webb Space Telescope
NASFiC
File 770 reports that Winnipeg are pivoting to a 2023 NASFiC
Orlando in 2026 is also pivoting to a 2023 NASFiC
File 770
Official site
This leaves the 2026 field
Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
Los Angeles, CA, USA
Nice, France
Brice de Nice
Glasgow has launched a lovely "move 500 miles poster
John can walk 804.672 kilometres
Earworm
A fantastic edit
Play along on Strava
Picks:
Alison: The Expanse (Amazon Prime)
OK she is a bit behind but it is a 2022 Plan
Liz: Vita Nostra by Marina and Sergei Dyachenko, translated by Julia Meitov Hersey (paperback, epub, Kindle)
John:
Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Coco (Disney+)
Music credits
Our theme music is Fanfare for Space by Kevin MacLeod, used under a CC BY 4.0 license

Dec 23, 2021 • 48min
47: Authors Eating John
John is sleepy, Alison is talking to Chinese fans, and Liz went to the Hugos.
Please email your letters of comment to octothorpecast@gmail.com and tag @OctothorpeCast when you post about the show on social media.
Content warnings this episode: COVID-19 (chapter 2); racism (chapter 3); foreign policy and sexism (chapter 4)
Letters of comment
Farah and Fran talking about masking at Novacon
A big discussion about BSFA
You can get by just NOT TELLING THE BSFA your address (DON’T TRY THAT WITH THE WORLDCON)
Chris Garcia
Site selection at DisCon III
Chengdu in 2023 won
File 770’s reporting on the win
Chinese fans seem nice!
The livestream was good, and had 106,000 viewers
Lots of different Chinese university SF societies encouraging the bid; spot the flag in Gallifreyan and the monolith
WSFS Business Meeting
The video of the session we discuss
Kevin Standlee’s LiveJournal post about it
File 770’s reporting on the session
There are legitimate concerns about China
John found he generally agreed with these tweets from Jeannette Ng
Tweet
Thread #1
Thread #2
The guests are Liu Cixin, Sergei Lukyanenko and Robert J. Sawyer
A File 770 commenter outlines the issues with Lukyanenko
Hugo Awards
If Fanzine had 53 fewer votes and Fancast had 42 fewer votes they would not have been awarded
Picks
John: The Psychopath Club by Sandra Bond (paperback, Kindle)
Alison: Sibilant Fricative by Adam Roberts (paperback, Kindle)
Liz: The Witness for the Dead by Katherine Addison (epub, paperback, Kindle)
Picks for Christmas song
Alison: Chiron Beta Prime by Jonathan Coulton
John:
California Christmastime by Crazy Ex-Girlfriend
Oh Santa! by Mr.B the Gentleman Rhymer
Liz: Bethlehem Down
Alison’s playlist of Christmas songs which do not presuppose God or Santa
Music credits
Our theme music is It’s Christmas Time by Frank Schröter, used under the Simplified Filmmusic.io Standard License

Dec 9, 2021 • 57min
46: Is My Head Extremely Solid, Or What
John is afraid, Alison is in Portugal, and Liz is an absolute unit.
Please email your letters of comment to octothorpecast@gmail.com and tag @OctothorpeCast when you post about the show on social media.
Content warnings this episode: COVID-19 (chapters 1 and 2, but particularly chapter 2)
Thanks to Stow Shirts for sponsoring this week's episode! Use code OCTOTHORPE for a 10% discount.
No letters of comment this week, we will do them next week!
Smofcon Europe
COVID round-up
World Fantasy Convention
The person who got COVID Tweeted
Novacon
Alan Bellingham
Tony Cullen
Dave Lally
Caroline Mullan
Colette Reap
Nicholas Whyte
Worldcon site selection
Deadline on 14 December for returning PDF ballots
PDF ballots are available here
Future Convention Q&As from Worldcon/Eurocon/Smofcon bids
Join the BSFA
Picks
Liz: Did Alison already have Hades or can I have Hades?
Roguelikes vs Roguelites
John: Playing board games with friends
Sushi Go Party!
Escape from the Aliens in Outer Space
Zombie Dice
EXIT: The Game: Advent Calendar: The Mystery of the Ice Cave
Alison: The Man in the High Castle (Amazon Prime)
Based on the Philip K. Dick book (paperback, ebook, Kindle)
Music credits
Our theme music is Fanfare for Space by Kevin MacLeod, used under a CC BY 4.0 license