The Uncertainty Podcast

Miles K. Donahue
undefined
Nov 13, 2026 • 1h 40min

#106 Do Arguments for God Succeed? - Oppy, Linford, Bray, Donahue, Boyce, and Mullins

Graham Oppy, Dan Linford, Nathan Bray, Kenny Boyce, R.T. Mullins, and myself come together to ask (and answer) the question: does natural theology succeed?Video of this interview is available on YouTube.To support the channel, do please oh please consider donating, either via PayPal or Buy Me a Coffee.Follow me on X because you’re awesome.EPISODE CHAPTERS:00:00:00 Introduction00:01:46 R. T. Mullins opening speech00:05:45 Miles Donahue opening speech00:09:56 Dan Linford opening speech00:14:22 Kenny Boyce opening speech00:18:15 Nathan Bray opening speech00:25:30 Graham Oppy opening speech00:30:23 R. T. Mullins cross-examination00:40:29 Miles Donahue cross-examination00:56:14 Dan Linford cross-examination01:07:11 Kenny Boyce cross-examination01:16:50 Nathan Bray cross-examination01:31:18 Graham Oppy cross-examination Get full access to Miles K. Donahue at mileskdonahue.substack.com/subscribe
undefined
Nov 7, 2026 • 1h 1min

#105 We Can Use Probability to Reason About God - Kenny Boyce

Kenny Boyce, a philosophy Ph.D. student specializing in Bayesian reasoning and philosophy of religion, explores whether probability can illuminate questions about God. They examine fine-tuning, epistemic versus objective probability, Bayesian priors, John Norton’s critique of induction, rational credences, and whether deeper physics could explain life-permitting constants. Kenny also shares his deepest philosophical uncertainty.
undefined
Oct 29, 2026 • 1h 49min

#104 Against Angels, Miracles, & Hell: Refuting Bad Theology - Both Sides Brigade

A lively philosophical takedown of three difficult ideas: whether failed supernatural custodians explain natural evil, whether Catholic miracle reports withstand skeptical scrutiny, and whether eternal conscious torment can fit with divine goodness. The discussion examines Padre Pio, Calanda, Fátima, divine hiddenness, moral skepticism, and attempts to defend endless punishment.
undefined
Oct 23, 2026 • 1h 37min

#103 Catholicism, Popes, and Homosexuality: A Defense - Noah McKay

Noah McKay, a Princeton philosophy Ph.D. student focused on religion and Catholic theology, recounts his journey from Protestantism to Catholicism. He discusses contemporary miracles, Marian apparitions, Eucharistic claims, and arguments for Christianity. The conversation then turns to Peter, papal authority, apostolic succession, church unity, Catholic sexual ethics, homosexuality, and his deepest metaphysical uncertainties.
undefined
Oct 15, 2026 • 1h 22min

#102 An Unheated Discussion on Science, Probability, and Induction - Mike Titelbaum

Mike Titelbaum, a philosopher and author of Fundamentals of Bayesian Epistemology, explores Bayesianism, graded confidence, and when precise probabilities break down. He tackles John Norton’s material theory of induction, cosmological fine-tuning, evidence for God, and the divide between everyday and mathematical probability. The conversation also examines incommensurable beliefs, subjective Bayesianism, and the limits of rational standards.
undefined
Oct 2, 2026 • 1h 2min

#101 We Must Save Science from Quantum Mechanics - Emily Adlam

Emily Adlam discusses the problems facing several interpretations of quantum mechanics: principal among them, the probability problem. Prepare for discussion of self-locating credences, branch-counting, and whether a mechanism deposits consciousness throughout the branching wavefunction of the universe.Video of this interview is available on YouTube.To support the channel, do please oh please consider donating, either via PayPal or Buy Me a Coffee.Follow me on X because you’re awesome.EPISODE CHAPTERS:00:00:00 Introduction00:01:52 The problem of recovering empirical confirmation00:04:47 The many-worlds interpretation00:07:01 The measurement problem00:08:42 The probability problem in many-worlds00:12:06 The decision-theoretic approach to probability00:16:33 Self-locating evidence and Everettian quantum mechanics00:19:20 Pure vs. superficial self-locating credence00:25:08 Can the Born rule constrain self-locating credence?00:30:15 Interpretations vs. theories of quantum mechanics00:34:51 Can we save science from quantum mechanics?00:44:30 What happened to the Copenhagen interpretation?00:46:45 What do physicists believe about quantum mechanics?00:48:27 The anthropic argument for God00:56:22 Multiverses, fine-tuning, and self-locating evidence Get full access to Miles K. Donahue at mileskdonahue.substack.com/subscribe
undefined
Sep 24, 2026 • 1h 5min

#100 A Heated Discussion on Science, Probability, and Induction - John Norton

In the hundredth episode of this podcast, I discuss the use, and misuse, of probability in science and philosophy with John Norton. Prepare for a contentious conversation about fundamental issues in probability theory, induction, and cosmic fine-tuning. This one does not disappoint.Video of this interview is available on YouTube.To support the channel, do please oh please consider donating, either via PayPal or Buy Me a Coffee.Follow me on X because you’re awesome.EPISODE CHAPTERS:00:00:00 Introduction00:00:30 Formal vs. material theories of induction00:04:58 Does material induction make induction redundant?00:11:15 Bayesianism vs. the material theory00:16:47 Can we say evolution is “probably” true?00:19:23 Evidential support without probabilities00:23:16 Can Bayesianism capture inference to the best explanation?00:25:00 The outcome space dispute00:29:47 Probability and the danger of false precision00:31:03 The simulation argument and misapplied probability00:35:39 The doomsday argument and self-locating evidence00:38:33 Objective vs. subjective Bayesianism00:43:36 The bootstrapping problem for probability00:50:53 Probability in cosmology and the multiverse00:57:59 Does inflation make our universe more probable?01:00:19 What is John Norton most uncertain about? Get full access to Miles K. Donahue at mileskdonahue.substack.com/subscribe
undefined
Sep 10, 2026 • 1h 27min

#99 An Oxford Philosopher Investigates the Meaning of Life - Tim Mawson

Tim Mawson, professor of philosophy at Oxford, discusses the contours of the newly emerging philosophical investigation into the meaning of life. What does it mean to say that life's meaning is subjective versus objective? Would life be meaningful if we were immortal? And what difference does God make, and not make, to whether life means anything?Video of this interview is available on YouTube.To support the channel, do please oh please consider donating, either via PayPal or Buy Me a Coffee.Follow me on X because you’re awesome.EPISODE CHAPTERS:00:00:00 Introduction00:02:55 Open theism and God's relationship to time00:11:09 Returning to the meaning of life00:12:06 Why philosophers neglected the meaning of life00:15:48 What does it mean for life to have meaning?00:19:20 Objectivism, subjectivism and hybrid theories00:28:23 Objective meaning, subjective states and purpose00:35:00 Can there be no meaning to life?00:39:47 What can God add to life's meaning?00:43:25 Vocation, purpose and meaningfulness00:50:50 Does God give some people more meaningful lives?00:59:20 Death, immortality and the meaning of life01:00:25 Would eternal life become unbearably boring?01:07:48 Does infinite time destroy urgency?01:13:23 Would praising God forever become boring?01:18:14 What God cannot add to life's meaning01:21:55 Can God's existence make a life less meaningful?01:24:18 What is the meaning of life? Get full access to Miles K. Donahue at mileskdonahue.substack.com/subscribe
undefined
Sep 3, 2026 • 2h 13min

#98 Every Argument for God, Refuted - Kevin Scharp

Kevin Scharp comes back on the podcast to discuss William Lane Craig’s eight-part case for the existence of God: contingency, cosmology, mathematics, fine-tuning, consciousness, morality, miracles, and experience.Video of this interview is available on YouTube.To support the channel, do please oh please consider donating, either via PayPal or Buy Me a Coffee.Follow me on X because you’re awesome.EPISODE CHAPTERS:00:00:00 Introduction00:01:20 Behind the scenes: Kevin vs. William Lane Craig00:14:11 Craig on probability & inference to the best explanation00:23:07 Divine psychology and fine-tuning00:27:06 Argument #1 - Contingency00:43:30 Does everything need an explanation?00:49:48 Argument #2 - Kalam cosmological argument00:51:35 Actual infinity and Hilbert’s Hotel01:03:06 Argument #3 - Fine-tuning01:09:53 What does the Big Bang actually tell us?01:11:53 Divine psychology01:27:08 Argument #4 - Applicability of mathematics01:35:08 Argument #5 - Consciousness01:40:47 Does consciousness really get us to God?01:45:41 Argument #6 - Morality01:54:43 Argument #7 - The resurrection of Jesus01:58:27 Miracles and the laws of nature02:08:25 Argument #8 - Experience of God Get full access to Miles K. Donahue at mileskdonahue.substack.com/subscribe
undefined
Aug 27, 2026 • 1h 35min

#97 Why Belief in the Soul Makes Sense - Ralph Stefan Weir

Ralph Weir answers all my questions about the mind-body problem, how we define "physical," whether I can conceive of philosophical zombies, and where panpsychism fits into all this.Video of this interview is available on YouTube.To support the channel, do please oh please consider donating, either via PayPal or Buy Me a Coffee.Follow me on X because you’re awesome.EPISODE CHAPTERS:00:00:00 Introduction00:02:35 How Ralph got into philosophy of mind00:05:52 Eliminativism: do mental states exist?00:09:00 What is illusionism?00:10:56 What is phenomenal consciousness?00:17:53 What are qualia?00:21:33 What does “physical” actually mean?00:29:03 Is panpsychism a form of physicalism?00:35:45 Mapping the mind-body problem00:45:16 Property dualism vs. substance dualism00:53:10 What is the strongest case against physicalism?01:00:32 Philosophical zombies and modal skepticism01:10:23 Can science settle the mind-body problem?01:18:20 Mental causation and physical anomalies01:22:31 Does the evidence favor physicalism?01:34:07 Which philosophical view is Ralph most uncertain about? Get full access to Miles K. Donahue at mileskdonahue.substack.com/subscribe

The AI-powered Podcast Player

Save insights by tapping your headphones, chat with episodes, discover the best highlights - and more!
App store bannerPlay store banner
Get the app