Mushroom Case Daily
ABC listen
From court recaps to behind-the-scenes murder trial explainers, and post-verdict analysis, Mushroom Case Daily is your eyes and ears inside the courtroom.
It's the case that has captured the world's attention. Three people died and a fourth survived an induced coma after eating beef Wellington at a family lunch, hosted by Erin Patterson.
Police alleged that the beef Wellington contained poisonous mushrooms, but Erin Patterson said she was innocent.
This podcast follows every development of the trial as the accused triple murderer fights the charges in a regional Victorian courthouse. Reporters Kristian Silva and Rachael Brown are with producer Stephen Stockwell on the ground, bringing you all the key moments as they unravel in court.
It's the case that has captured the world's attention. Three people died and a fourth survived an induced coma after eating beef Wellington at a family lunch, hosted by Erin Patterson.
Police alleged that the beef Wellington contained poisonous mushrooms, but Erin Patterson said she was innocent.
This podcast follows every development of the trial as the accused triple murderer fights the charges in a regional Victorian courthouse. Reporters Kristian Silva and Rachael Brown are with producer Stephen Stockwell on the ground, bringing you all the key moments as they unravel in court.
Episodes
Mentioned books
21 snips
Jun 20, 2025 • 36min
Kill them all, or reconnect? Our Friday Wrap
The trial of Erin Patterson takes center stage as closing arguments reveal sharp contrasts between the prosecution's claim of a sinister plot and the defense's plea for innocence. Delve into the emotional and moral complexities surrounding a family lunch gone tragically wrong, where poisonous mushrooms allegedly led to three deaths. There's intrigue over missing phone evidence and how it shapes the narrative. With the jury preparing for deliberations, the stakes couldn't be higher in this captivating courtroom drama.
12 snips
Jun 19, 2025 • 24min
Maybe? Likely? Probably? Defence's final bid to the jury
Explore the gripping final defense arguments in a high-profile murder trial involving Erin Patterson, accused of serving a deadly beef Wellington. The defense claims her actions were honest and questioned the prosecution's evidence. Tensions rise in the courtroom as the jury prepares to deliberate, with an emphasis on the need for clarity and open minds. The hosts also tackle listener questions, clarifying the case as an unfortunate accident and discussing critical moments that challenge the narrative of guilt.
Jun 18, 2025 • 30min
"Not on trial for being a liar" - defence closing continues
The defense is crafting a compelling argument for Erin Patterson, emphasizing that the jury should separate her alleged dishonesty from her guilt. They caution against hindsight reasoning and delve into her health and personal struggles. The podcast examines alarming testimonies regarding food poisoning and the controversial mushroom toxicity. Listeners get a glimpse into the implications of the trial while engaging with questions about the justice system, making it both informative and captivating.
10 snips
Jun 17, 2025 • 29min
Defence zeros in on lack of motive
The trial of Erin Patterson unfolds with gripping courtroom drama, as prosecutors accuse her of deception while defending against the charge of triple murder. Key arguments center on the puzzling lack of motive, especially with her close ties to the victims. Intriguing insights examine the nature of the allegedly poisoned beef wellington, and the actions of Patterson post-incident raise questions. As jurors deliberate, the stakes feel higher than ever in this captivating true crime saga.
10 snips
Jun 16, 2025 • 36min
"A sinister deception": Prosecution's closing address begins
The prosecution outlines four key deceptions they claim incriminate Erin Patterson in a chilling triple homicide. Claims of a fabricated cancer story and the deliberate poisoning of a family meal paint a sinister picture. Tensions rise in the courtroom as inconsistencies in Patterson's testimony come under scrutiny. Emotional narratives surrounding the case juxtapose parental responsibilities with tragic outcomes. As the trial unfolds, the jury holds the weight of interpreting complex evidence and intentions.
21 snips
Jun 13, 2025 • 35min
The biggest moments of Erin's Evidence: Our Friday Wrap
Erin Patterson's dramatic trial takes center stage as she steps down from the witness box. The prosecution intensifies as cross-examinations reveal emotional courtroom exchanges and credibility concerns. Insights into jury dynamics reflect both tension and engagement, captivating audiences worldwide. The hosts share heartfelt reflections while connecting with global listeners. A surprising courtroom moment adds intrigue, keeping everyone on the edge of their seats as the case unfolds with grave implications.
21 snips
Jun 12, 2025 • 26min
Erin Patterson's final words to the jury
The trial of Erin Patterson reaches a gripping climax as she delivers her final words to the jury. Tensions flare with arguments about key witness testimonies and questionable claims regarding her mushroom sourcing. The defense tackles misunderstandings around her pursuit of gastric surgery and explores canceled medical appointments. As courtroom drama unfolds, the hosts reflect on the emotional weight of the trial and its impact on the community awaiting a verdict. This case has captivated the world, with chilling implications surrounding a fatal family meal.
16 snips
Jun 11, 2025 • 30min
Late-breaking evidence on Erin's gastric bypass claims
Fresh evidence shakes Erin Patterson's claims of gastric bypass surgery, raising questions about her credibility. The prosecution's narrative unfolds with key testimonials revealing inconsistencies in her mushroom purchases. A deep dive into her emotional responses during cross-examination adds tension to the courtroom drama. The hosts explore the intriguing citizen science connections related to the case, showcasing a community effort to document toxic mushrooms. All eyes remain on the courtroom for further revelations in this captivating trial.
17 snips
Jun 10, 2025 • 23min
Body image, body fluids and body functions: Erin's evidence challenged
The courtroom drama intensifies as Erin Patterson's credibility is put to the test during her trial. Prosecutor Dr. Nanette Rogers digs into her claims about weight loss surgery and health, revealing inconsistencies that raise eyebrows. Meanwhile, the chilling implications of Death Cap mushrooms come to light, sparking emotional turmoil for everyone involved. With behind-the-scenes insights and riveting exchanges, the tension in the courtroom is palpable as audiences are left questioning the truth.
12 snips
Jun 6, 2025 • 34min
Explaining Erin's evidence: Our Friday wrap
Tension mounts as Erin Patterson faces intense cross-examination about her relationships with lunch guests amid allegations of a deadly meal. The courtroom dynamic reveals her conflicting narratives and strained familial ties. Erin's candid remarks about disordered eating and her questionable medical claims add layers to her character. As details about her actions post-lunch emerge, including her concerns for her children's safety, the pressure intensifies. Listeners are left on the edge of their seats, eager for the next unfolding drama in this gripping case.
