Veronica Gedeon, a pulp magazine model, was found murdered in her apartment along with her mother and a boarder on Easter Sunday, 1937. The murders captivated New Yorkers during the Great Depression. The investigation led to a suspect named Bob Irwin, who confessed his obsession with beauty and rejection. The podcast explores mental illness in the 1930s, legal proceedings, and conflicting views on sanity.

Veronica Gedeon, a pulp magazine model, was found murdered alongside her family members on Easter Sunday in 1937. The case shocked investigators due to the lack of forced entry and missing items. The media sensationalized the story, focusing on Veronica's beauty rather than the tragedy. The grieving process took a troubling turn when a parent falsely accused their deceased child. Detectives explored suspects, including Joe Gideon, leading to his interrogation and the hint of a revelation in the next part of the story.