Various Interviewees

In a gripping examination of a 1988 murder in Florence, Alabama, local residents and investigators such as Lacey Kenimer and Detective Ricky Miller provide chilling firsthand accounts. They delve into the chaotic night of Elizabeth Sennett's attack, the community's initial suspicions toward her husband Charles, and the eventual revelations surrounding three young suspects named by an anonymous caller. With emotional testimonies and unsettling truths, this narrative explores how a gruesome crime impacted an entire town and spiraled into a complex saga of confusion and despair.