Tania Lombrozo, an expert in cognitive science, joins Toby Ball, a social science researcher, to delve into our love for simple explanations amid complex realities. They discuss the infamous Rendlesham Forest incident, where mysterious phenomena led to various speculations. Toby highlights the battle between straightforward narratives and the nuanced truth behind UFO sightings. Tania explores how our cognitive biases push for simplicity, often at the expense of deeper understanding, reminding us to embrace complexity in our reasoning.