Russell Shorto, Director of the New Amsterdam Project and author, and Ted Johnson, Senior Advisor at New America, dive into New York City's complex legacy as it celebrates 400 years. They explore the city’s Colonial past, stressing the need to include diverse narratives in its history. The conversation shifts to America's upcoming 250th anniversary, tackling the impact of slavery and the importance of acknowledging historical injustices. Together, they call for a more nuanced understanding of America's multifaceted identity.