"Unbelievable?" explores the journey of two gay Christians who interpret the Bible's teachings on sexuality differently. David Bennett, a former gay activist, shares his transformational conversion to Christianity and commitment to a celibate life. Taylor Telford, an academic theologian, discusses her progressive views on gay marriage. They touch on topics like reconciling faith and sexuality, celibacy, toxic relationships, and embracing differences within the church. The podcast emphasizes the importance of love, inclusivity, and creating a supportive community for LGBTQ+ Christians.